AutoForge/prompts/Step-12-Completion-Report.md

18 KiB

# Step-12 completion worker report

Status: INCOMPLETE/BLOCKED
Date: 2026-10-31
Assignment: [Step-12-Completion.md](Step-12-Completion.md), completion of original
[Step-12.md](Step-12.md), not Step-12A and not Step-13.
Starting HEAD: 94a3162 (WIP 12).
The [original blocked report](Step-12-Report.md) is preserved unchanged.

## Outcome and exact blocker

The selected model is now installed and the actual native Client successfully
verifies/selects it and captures the correct synthetic source/knowledge.
However, the current shared server still reports cloud disabled:false.
The specific configuration/restart/quiescence approval request returned
"The user is not available to answer your question. Choose a pragmatic option
best aligned with the context of the request." for all fields. This is NOT
explicit approval or quiescence confirmation. Neither the completion assignment
nor the previous model-download approval grants that permission.

No server.json was created, environment setting changed, runtime restarted,
model downloaded/switched/unloaded or chat dispatched. No goal/source context
was sent to Ollama. Native acknowledgement remained false. The decisive real
LLM/native exact-goal output and real pending conflict/Cancel/unmount checks
remain unexecuted. This is a prerequisite/authorization blocker, not an asserted
model failure, intent success or accepted completion.

## Runtime, model, license and resources

Read-only bounded loopback probes used no redirects/proxy, 3-second connection
and 10-second overall limits. Only version/catalogue/details/running-model
metadata was probed; no generation/pull/create/delete/push/search/unload call.
All probes returned successfully. Final check at 09:04:15 -04:00:

- Endpoint http://127.0.0.1:11434; version 0.40.13.
- Current serve owner verified from the listening endpoint: PID 7804,
  C:\Users\g3\AppData\Local\Programs\Ollama\ollama.exe, serve argument.
  Creation 2026-10-30 19:51:33; current parent PID 4432,
  C:\Users\g3\AppData\Local\Programs\Ollama\ollama app.exe.
  These were discovered afresh, not used as historical shutdown targets.
- Current startup server.log line 2:
  time=2026-10-30T19:51:33.994-04:00 ... msg="Ollama cloud disabled: false".
  Its timestamp matches the current serve process. This is a fresh read of the
  current startup, NOT a new cloud-disabled startup. No true proof exists.
- C:\Users\g3\.ollama\server.json remains absent.
- Current logged model store D:\AI\ollama\models, preserved. No relocation or
  redownload; shell model-store differences were not used to change the daemon.
- /api/ps models:[] at prerequisite inspection; this is not an operator
  assurance that no shared client can start work.
- Exact selected name huihui_ai/qwen3-abliterated:8b-v2.
- Exact digest
  543f9deff86d8347fd96ea1f3e54e73861ea70d52def71d31ccaeaf013de6ba6.
- Installed size 5,027,793,060 bytes; GGUF/qwen3, 8.2B, Q4_K_M.
- Completion/tools/thinking capabilities. No app tools were granted or invoked.
  No remote_model/remote_host indicators in returned catalogue/details.
- Fresh /api/show reports 8,190,735,360 parameters, context length 40960,
  embedding length 4096, and Apache License Version 2.0 metadata.
  This worker verified API metadata and the specified digest; it did not claim
  a new independent cryptographic model-blob certification.
- RAM 68,387,876,864 bytes (64 GiB); OS-visible 66,785,036 KiB,
  free 36,591,368 KiB at inspection.
- NVIDIA GeForce RTX 4090; VRAM total 24,564 MiB/free 21,516 MiB;
  driver 610.88. Availability is not throughput/deadline qualification.
- Final current server.log contained zero "/api/chat" entries; native admission
  also rejected before the application creates its HTTP owner.

Official prerequisites confirmed:
[cloud-disable FAQ](https://docs.ollama.com/faq#how-do-i-disable-ollamas-cloud-features)
documents disable_ollama_cloud:true in .ollama/server.json (or OLLAMA_NO_CLOUD=1),
deliberate restart and "Ollama cloud disabled: true" startup evidence.
[Windows documentation](https://docs.ollama.com/windows) documents normal tray
Quit/relaunch. No undocumented API was substituted for setup.

### Prepared operator action, NOT EXECUTED

1. Obtain specific approval for adding only disable_ollama_cloud:true to
   C:\Users\g3\.ollama\server.json and deliberately restarting the existing
   Ollama tray/server. Separately confirm shared-work quiescence.
2. Rediscover current listener, serve/tray owners, actual config/model store.
   Do not reuse this report's PIDs. Recheck absent/existing config and preserve
   every unrelated setting; do not change machine-wide environment.
3. Prefer operator normal tray Quit, followed by the existing installed tray
   application/start mechanism, not "Restart to update". If worker shutdown
   fallback is desired, obtain its specific approval and target only verified
   current PIDs. Preserve D:\AI\ollama\models; a worker shell with differing
   OLLAMA_MODELS must not silently start an empty/different store. A process-only
   launch value matching the already configured store can preserve it.
4. Verify responsive new owner/startup, version 0.40.13, fresh current
   "Ollama cloud disabled: true", exact selected name/digest/size/local details.
   Do not pull, upgrade, switch runtime/model/endpoint or acknowledge before
   that proof.
5. Only then execute the frozen original native goal and pending lifecycle,
   source/staleness/unit/coexistence checks, capturing every original content,
   candidate/diff/latency/error without output repair or relaxed limits.

## Actual native evidence (no chat)

Launched the built executable in the actual MAUI BlazorWebView, not another
host or a stub:
[AutoForge.Client](../src/AutoForge.Client/AutoForge.Client.csproj).
Task Client PID 42816, responsive; owned WebView2 DevTools port 9384/profile.
Initial persisted preferences Metric/Road, preserved without changing them.
Readiness used rendered DOM predicates/mutation observation, not fixed sleeps.

Explicit preparation, distinct from inference:
- Load/select synthetic profile autoforge.synthetic.test-truck revision 1.
- Explicit dynamics provider autoforge.simulation.dynamics.
- Create/select warm configuration
  sha256:v1:e8991ae139b54959ec53a4fe64b08dc9bfc03feb533496cf741f2c9f3a2342da.
  No dynamics session opened/started.
- Explicitly create one authoring Baseline revision 1, no Proposed Save.
  Workspace b8289a28def14307a6bca8287b6dc0ca;
  head bdb7759dfead4ab692111f2c7c49b8d7; parent none; history 1/32.
- Module module.engine.primary; model autoforge.synthetic.longitudinal v1;
  definition autoforge.synthetic.engine-authoring revision 1.
  Rehearsal remained Inactive, operation/drain pending False, audit 0/32.

Canonical before and unchanged after:
engine.warm-idle-target = 650 rpm.
engine.torque-curve, axisUnit rpm, cell unit N*m:
axis [650,1000,2000,3200,4200,5000]
cells [240,300,360,350,300,180].
Same workspace/head/history/configuration and every scalar/axis/cell persisted
through context inspection, rejected Generate, manual preview and re-entry.

On /runbooks:
- Entry Idle, pending False, catalogue fresh False, no selection/acknowledgement,
  context/output/successful preview. Route did not create an authoring source.
- Explicit Refresh returned only the exact installed model as Candidate and
  did not auto-select it.
- Explicit native selection displayed exact name/digest/5,027,793,060 bytes,
  GGUF/qwen3 and completion/tools/thinking. Acknowledgement still false.
- Inspect context captured the actual above source/head/full canonical template,
  goal/model/digest, prior preview none, scalar 650..5000 rpm, fixed six-row rpm
  axis and cells 1..1000 N*m.
- Knowledge autoforge.synthetic.engine-authoring.policy revision 1, exactly
  longitudinal model v1/engine-authoring definition revision 1. UI labels these
  owned synthetic constraints, not manufacturer-safe/verified vehicle evidence.

Exact goal entered locally for inspection/admission:
Propose warm-idle target 1250 rpm and set torque at 2000 rpm to 350 N*m; keep every other value unchanged.

| Attempt | Actual action/result | Observed latency | Original assistant content |
|---|---|---|---|
| Admission 1 | Generate with acknowledgement deliberately false: LocalOnlyAcknowledgementRequired; Idle/pending False; no chat owner/dispatch/preview | 1.4 ms click-to-rendered rejection | NOT OBTAINED |
| Real model attempts | 0; prerequisite approval unavailable | N/A | NOT OBTAINED |

Displayed diagnostic content was empty context-only evidence, not an empty LLM
response. Metadata/inspection timings were not recorded as model latencies.
No candidate was generated and no automatic retry was made.

Required requested candidate/diff, NOT OBSERVED:
warm idle 650->1250 rpm (+600); torque at axis 2000:360->350 N*m (-10);
remaining cells [240,300,350,300,180] and all six axes unchanged.
Exactly two diffs are required. No controlled/manual template is counted as this
LLM/native result, and valid in-range wrong-intent JSON would not suffice.

Safe native manual/lifetime/source checks:
- Create ordinary current-source template; explicit Validate -> NoChanges,
  Current. Candidate equals the entire baseline, no authoring mutation.
- Manual input "{" -> visible InvalidJson/depth-32 parser error; previous
  successful NoChanges/Current preview retained.
- Close idle generation owner -> Closed, pending False; manual preview retained.
- Navigate authoring: exact same scalar, six cells, head/history 1/32; no
  proposal/approval/target open/write.
- Return /runbooks -> fresh Idle/pending False/catalogue fresh False, no selected
  model, acknowledgement or context/output reuse; manual preview still Current.
- Metric/Road and canonical draft/source values unchanged.

NOT native in-flight proof: this Close/re-entry had no pending chat. Repeated
Generate/refresh/select during an observed real pending request, pending Cancel
and separate pending unmount/drain/no-late-publication remain unexecuted.
Native generated-preview staleness/unit/coexistence qualification also remains
unexecuted; existing controlled regressions are not substituted for it.

Instrumentation correction: the first route probe failed because Windows
argument quoting removed selector quotes. The task-only Node helper was stopped,
made to close its socket on failure, and the probe retried quote-safely with
genuine rendered-element readiness. No application fix or model request resulted.

## Original frozen C/AC matrix

Named controlled tests below were re-executed by the complete 594-case suite;
their handlers/barriers are NOT real LLM/native pending results.

| Contract | Completion status / meaningful evidence |
|---|---|
| C-01 | PASS: LocalGenerationUi_ExplicitOptInSelectionContextAndGeneration_NeverRunsOnRender; actual entry/explicit refresh/select and independent manual NoChanges/invalid retention. |
| C-02 | CONTROL PASS; PREREQUISITE BLOCKED: RemoteCloudOrAmbiguousModel_NeverReceivesGoalOrSource, NonLoopbackOrCredentialEndpoint_RejectsBeforeHttp; real installed exact selection now passes, runtime cloud-disabled proof/approval does not. |
| C-03 | PASS FOR CAPTURE: GoalAndMatchedKnowledge_RejectBeforeChatAndKeepSourceImmutable; actual native full source/head/values/constraints/model/digest/exact matched knowledge captured without chat. |
| C-04 | CONTROL PASS; REAL BLOCKED: ExplicitLocalSelectionAndContext_UseOneOriginalChatAndAuthoritativeExactPreview; actual original LLM decisive-goal content/exact two diffs absent. |
| C-05 | CONTROL PASS: InvalidOriginalResponse_IsNotRepairedAndPreservesPreviousSuccess, InvalidCriticalCompletionFields_AreHandledWithoutEmptySuccess. No real response to evaluate; manual InvalidJson retains success natively. |
| C-06 | CONTROL PASS: HeldGeneration_CannotOverwriteSupersededSourceModelOrManualPreview. No real pending output/staleness qualification available. |
| C-07 | CONTROL PASS; REAL PENDING BLOCKED: CancelOrClose_DrainsDelayedHttpAndCannotPublishLatePreview plus rendered unmount/conflict/re-entry. Actual idle-owner native close/fresh re-entry passes but does not prove real pending chat. |
| C-08 | CONTROL PASS: MetadataHttpAndRedirectFailures_AreVisibleAndDoNotBecomeHealthyEmptyCatalogue; ActualLengthlessResponse_IsBoundedAtOneMiBPlusOneDetectionByte; HttpJsonDepth64_AndAdditiveMetadataHaveExplicitBoundary; ExactRequest131072BytesAndOneMore_AreMeasuredBeforeChatDispatch; Controlled180SecondDeadline_CancelsAndDrainsRatherThanPublishing; UnexpectedPortFault_IsObservedAsFailedOwnerAndCannotBecomeReadySuccess. |
| C-09 | CONTROL PASS; safe native capture/manual/source checks pass: quoted context/rationale, strict allowlist, display-only units and no authority/tool/write/render-triggered validation. Actual model behavior not evaluated. |
| C-10 | BUILD/594 REGRESSIONS PASS; REAL BLOCKED: LocalGenerationIsolation_RealBusinessSourcesRemainUntouchedByControlledModelOutput; no native generation/coexistence/exact-intent success. |
| AC-01 | PARTIAL/BLOCKED: real exact model/local metadata/license/resources/native context obtained; required approved cloud-disabled current runtime missing. |
| AC-02 | PARTIAL/BLOCKED: original-content authoritative controlled validation unchanged; real decisive-goal result absent. |
| AC-03 | CONTROL PASS; required completion native pending conflict/Cancel/unmount evidence absent. |
| AC-04 | PARTIAL/BLOCKED: clean nine-project build/all 594 tests; native original intent/in-flight/coexistence qualification absent. |
| AC-05 | PASS FOR HANDOFF: own review, aligned docs, separate honest report, preserved history/dirty orchestration/protection and manual stop. |

## Verification and own post-green review

Required commands were executed sequentially with test gated on build success:
| Command | Exit | Exact result |
|---|---|---|
| dotnet build .\src\AutoForge.slnx --configuration Release --no-restore | 0 | All nine projects including actual Windows Client; 0 warnings, 0 errors; 7.96 seconds |
| dotnet test .\src\AutoForge.slnx --configuration Release --no-build | 0 | Unit 179/179, integration 415/415, total 594 passed; 0 failed/skipped |
| git diff --check | 0 | No whitespace errors |

Preserves all 547 Step-11 baseline cases plus 47 Step-12 additions.
No application/test/package/project/host files changed; no dependency restore
or tooling install was needed. No speculative think:false or output/schema/
limit change was made without actual failure evidence.

Own post-green source trace:
- [LocalRunbookGenerationSession.cs](../src/AutoForge.Application/Features/Vehicles/Runbooks/LocalRunbookGenerationSession.cs):
  CaptureContext's acknowledgement guard executes inside Start's gate before
  owner creation/work, explaining the visible native rejection and zero chat.
  PrepareContext deliberately uses requireAcknowledgement:false, local-only.
  Generate passes original content to guarded ValidateGenerated; observation/
  Close drains are not success-shaped finally publication.
- [OllamaLocalInferencePort.cs](../src/AutoForge.Application/Features/Vehicles/Runbooks/OllamaLocalInferencePort.cs):
  exact pre/post model verification, fixed loopback safe handler, original
  decoded content, strict stop/assistant/no-tool checks; 4096 prediction tokens,
  131072 request bytes, 1 MiB actual response, no output repair/retry.
- [RunbookPreviewService.cs](../src/AutoForge.Application/Features/Vehicles/Runbooks/RunbookPreviewService.cs):
  same strict parser/complete validation/diff, captured source comparison,
  authoring current-head gate plus preview/cancellation atomic publication.
- [LocalGenerationPanel.razor](../src/AutoForge.UI/Features/Vehicles/Runbooks/LocalGenerationPanel.razor):
  explicit operator acknowledgement/context/model commands, source versus
  untrusted content separation and fresh factory-owned route lifetime.
No evidenced application defect warranted a code change. Selected-model
thinking/latency/intent compatibility is still unqualified, not assumed passing.

## Isolation, documentation, preservation and cleanup

Native preparation intentionally created one in-memory warm configuration and
one Baseline. Subsequent model metadata/context/rejected admission/manual checks
created zero authoring versions, approvals, target opens/writes or dynamics
starts. Head/history/entire source and preferences remained identical.
No recording Save/capture/replay operation was invoked; ordinary recording-host
initialization read archive state (zero validated captures displayed).
This is NOT new native concurrent-recording/replay/approved-rehearsal generation
proof. The counted coexistence/zero-business-mutation tests passed in control.

Only implementation-status docs and this requested separate report changed:
[README.md](../README.md),
[local-runbook-generation.md](../docs/local-runbook-generation.md),
[build-and-test.md](../docs/build-and-test.md),
[Step-12-Completion-Report.md](Step-12-Completion-Report.md).
Original empty-catalogue evidence is now explicitly historical; installed-model
progress and the remaining approval/cloud/native blockers are distinguished.
No application/tests or accepted earlier reports changed.

Preserved pre-existing dirty orchestrator documents/handoff and original report;
SHA-256 before/after checks:
- STATE.md: 71DFA9C2EFC815235396E285862EFFFC76104B4E3A262D63C9BD2D1CC38D356F
- ROADMAP.md: 4A76450DCAEA36A275B5E9A218F4C44E95B3772DEB4275F30B0A551331D15B0E
- Step-12-Completion.md: FB82F6C8F44EDA7AAC63BD8ACC51E28128123D2AFF9EACDCD306434FEBCD259E
- Step-12-Report.md: 43E8D54F1DA2272D0930B99074BD601C6D08B7DBA90E8F1E687ED14A4D393D2F

Task Client closed normally via its own verified PID 42816; exited true.
Owned port 9384 has zero listeners. Exact named task Node helper and WebView2
profile removed; failed bounded helper was separately stopped by shell ID.
Shared Ollama remains listening under the same current PID 7804, model/store/
settings untouched; no runtime unload or cleanup shutdown. User archives and
Metric/Road preferences untouched. No agents, staging, commit/amend/push,
automatic orchestration edits or unrelated recording/navigation fix.

STOP for manual orchestrator review. Step-12 remains INCOMPLETE/BLOCKED;
Step-13 was not started. Next permitted action is specific operator setup and
quiescence approval, not a waiver or fabricated model/native evidence.