AutoForge/prompts/Step-01-Report.md

403 lines
23 KiB
Markdown

```
# Step-01 worker report
## 1. Step identifier and title
Step-01 - Repository and solution foundation.
Establish the .NET 10 repository, headless application foundation, real tests,
and truthful developer documentation.
Execution date: 2026-10-28. Role: worker. Only Step-01 was executed.
## 2. Completion status
COMPLETE - worker implementation and required verification succeeded.
Manual orchestrator review/acceptance is pending; this is not an acceptance claim.
All AC-01 through AC-10 are mapped below. No required check is blocked or skipped.
## 3. Implemented functionality
- Platform-neutral, immutable execution-target metadata for Simulation,
RecordedReplay and PhysicalHardware.
- Descriptor construction rejects null/blank/padded identifiers and all undefined
kinds, including zero/default. Both identifier and kind must be explicit.
- Provider identifiers use ordinal case-insensitive comparison without trimming
or culture-sensitive normalization; original registered spelling is preserved.
- The resolver returns the exact registered descriptor only when both the
requested identifier and kind match.
- Missing selections, unknown registrations, duplicates/casing ambiguity, and
kind mismatches fail explicitly. No guessed default or cross-target fallback.
- Private snapshotting isolates validated registrations from caller collection
mutation. Sealed, get-only descriptors cannot be mutated through the public API.
- Ordinary Microsoft.Extensions DI composition validates eagerly at setup.
Repeated resolver setup is rejected instead of silently replacing the registry.
- Empty production-like registration is valid but every selection reports
ProviderNotRegistered. Production code supplies no synthetic or real providers.
Selection is metadata only: no connection, availability, discovery, execution,
read/write capability or approval is asserted. All test metadata is synthetic.
## 4. Files created
25 new files, including this report. All remain unstaged/uncommitted.
Root configuration (5):
- [.editorconfig](../.editorconfig)
- [global.json](../global.json)
- [Directory.Build.props](../Directory.Build.props)
- [Directory.Packages.props](../Directory.Packages.props)
- [NuGet.Config](../NuGet.Config)
Solution and projects (5):
- [src/AutoForge.slnx](../src/AutoForge.slnx)
- [AutoForge.Core.csproj](../src/AutoForge.Core/AutoForge.Core.csproj)
- [AutoForge.Application.csproj](../src/AutoForge.Application/AutoForge.Application.csproj)
- [AutoForge.UnitTests.csproj](../src/tests/AutoForge.UnitTests/AutoForge.UnitTests.csproj)
- [AutoForge.IntegrationTests.csproj](../src/tests/AutoForge.IntegrationTests/AutoForge.IntegrationTests.csproj)
Production source (7):
- [ExecutionTargetKind.cs](../src/AutoForge.Core/ExecutionTargets/ExecutionTargetKind.cs)
- [ExecutionTargetDescriptor.cs](../src/AutoForge.Core/ExecutionTargets/ExecutionTargetDescriptor.cs)
- [IExecutionTargetResolver.cs](../src/AutoForge.Application/ExecutionTargets/IExecutionTargetResolver.cs)
- [ExecutionTargetResolver.cs](../src/AutoForge.Application/ExecutionTargets/ExecutionTargetResolver.cs)
- [TargetSelectionFailure.cs](../src/AutoForge.Application/ExecutionTargets/TargetSelectionFailure.cs)
- [TargetSelectionException.cs](../src/AutoForge.Application/ExecutionTargets/TargetSelectionException.cs)
- [ServiceCollectionExtensions.cs](../src/AutoForge.Application/ExecutionTargets/ServiceCollectionExtensions.cs)
Tests (3):
- [ExecutionTargetDescriptorTests.cs](../src/tests/AutoForge.UnitTests/ExecutionTargetDescriptorTests.cs)
- [ExecutionTargetResolverTests.cs](../src/tests/AutoForge.UnitTests/ExecutionTargetResolverTests.cs)
- [TargetSelectionCompositionTests.cs](../src/tests/AutoForge.IntegrationTests/TargetSelectionCompositionTests.cs)
Technical documentation (4):
- [docs/README.md](../docs/README.md)
- [docs/architecture.md](../docs/architecture.md)
- [docs/adr-0001-headless-foundation.md](../docs/adr-0001-headless-foundation.md)
- [docs/build-and-test.md](../docs/build-and-test.md)
Worker handoff (1):
- [Step-01-Report.md](Step-01-Report.md)
Template Class1 and UnitTest1 files were removed before validation. They were
newly generated, not deletions of pre-existing tracked implementation.
## 5. Files modified and preservation evidence
Only two pre-existing files changed:
- [README.md](../README.md): preserved the complete original product description,
labeled it as vision, and added truthful scope, prerequisites and documentation.
- [.gitignore](../.gitignore): retained existing entries; appended seven lines
for local environment secrets, a visible .env.example exception, and ignored
src/local-data/ for private captures/firmware/models.
Baseline Git status was clean. Five tracked files were present: these two root
files and the three orchestration documents. No concurrent changes were observed
or discarded. No staging, Git initialization, commits, pushes or Git configuration
changes were performed.
The assignment, roadmap and state were read in full and preserved. SHA-256 values
recorded before implementation matched afterward:
| Protected file | Unchanged SHA-256 |
|---|---|
| Step-01.md | D7412E8F47BCDE11E9F6902E35455CC3F6D3BF60AD2D334B093C4575FF8C0C90 |
| ROADMAP.md | F9E1B12C78D0C8FC6D5BD83007B9C71F4CF2FC841CB5ED2D664375736A0EC78C |
| STATE.md | 0BD016FFE478B2EC9B2C577E0C04E4F85FD9F93D26F24F1FA3D0C7BDFDB8E2E6 |
No applicable AGENTS.md existed in the repository or its ancestor locations.
.github/copilot-instructions.md was absent and remains absent. No replacement
instruction file was created. Git diffs for protected documents and the index
were empty, exit 0.
Final pre-report inventory: two modified tracked files and 24 intended untracked
files; this report is the 25th new file. Untracked source was explicitly listed.
No credentials, private captures, firmware or model assets were introduced.
## 6. Architecture and actual dependency graph
All four projects target net10.0. Actual project-reference queries confirmed:
| Project | Project references | Direct production infrastructure package |
|---|---|---|
| Core | None | None |
| Application | Core | Microsoft.Extensions.DependencyInjection.Abstractions |
| UnitTests | Core, Application | Not a production project |
| IntegrationTests | Core, Application | Concrete DI container only in tests |
Application -> Core; UnitTests -> Application/Core;
IntegrationTests -> Application/Core. No production-to-test dependency exists.
Core owns the validated descriptor and target-kind invariant. Application owns
resolution, typed selection/ambiguity exceptions and DI registration.
Invalid inputs use standard argument exceptions with parameter names.
TargetSelectionException exposes ProviderNotRegistered, KindMismatch or
DuplicateProviderIdentifier for application failures. Duplicate detection happens
at resolver construction/DI extension invocation, before container building.
Get-only descriptors and a private dictionary form the mutation boundary.
One identifier names one kind, including across case variants. Registration
requires a single deliberate setup call; no plugin framework/service locator.
Actual top-level directories: .git (preserved metadata), docs, prompts, src.
The only project directories are docs, src and prompts. Tests are under src/tests.
No root tests, root artifacts, nested AutoForge project directory or nested
src/.git was present. No future-feature placeholder directories were created.
Both eventual Blazor hosts and shared components/screens RCLs are staged for
Step-05, not replaced by another architecture. No host exists in Step-01.
## 7. Unit tests created and behavior coverage
35 discovered/passed cases in two real Core/Application test classes:
| Test group / method | Cases | Behavior |
|---|---:|---|
| Descriptor: Constructor_PreservesExplicitIdentifierAndKind | 3 | All defined kinds, exact input metadata |
| Descriptor: Constructor_RejectsNullIdentifier | 1 | Null identifier and parameter name |
| Descriptor: Constructor_RejectsBlankOrPaddedIdentifier | 5 | Empty, whitespace, leading/trailing whitespace |
| Descriptor: Constructor_RejectsUndefinedKind | 4 | Negative, default, out-of-range and maximum integer |
| Resolver: Resolve_ReturnsExactRegisteredDescriptor | 3 | Same registered object for each kind |
| Resolver: Resolve_UsesOrdinalCaseInsensitiveIdentifiers | 1 | Case-insensitive lookup preserves registered casing |
| Resolver: Resolve_DoesNotUseCultureSensitiveIdentifierComparison | 1 | Dotless-i lookalike is not substituted |
| Resolver: Resolve_RejectsMissingSelection | 1 | Null request fails explicitly |
| Resolver: Resolve_EmptyRegistryReportsNotRegistered | 3 | No fabricated availability for any kind |
| Resolver: Resolve_UnknownIdentifierDoesNotSelectAnotherProviderOfSameKind | 1 | No same-kind default/fallback |
| Resolver: Resolve_RejectsEveryKindMismatchWithoutFallback | 6 | All ordered cross-kind mismatches; another matching-kind provider cannot substitute |
| Resolver: Constructor_RejectsDuplicateIdentifiersRegardlessOfKind | 3 | Exact/case-ambiguous duplicates, including across kinds |
| Resolver: Constructor_SnapshotsCallerCollection | 1 | Clear/replace/add duplicates after construction cannot change validated metadata |
| Resolver: Constructor_RejectsNullRegistrations | 1 | Null collection rejected |
| Resolver: Constructor_RejectsNullDescriptor | 1 | Null entry rejected |
No placeholder tests, mocks of the use case, skipped cases or zero-discovery
projects are used.
## 8. Integration tests created and actual boundary coverage
19 discovered/passed cases in TargetSelectionCompositionTests. Every selection
uses the application service obtained through the actual DI extension/container.
| Method | Cases | Real boundary exercised |
|---|---:|---|
| Composition_ResolvesExactExplicitSyntheticMetadata | 3 | Real Core validation, registration, container and exact descriptor identity/kind |
| Composition_EmptyProductionLikeRegistryIsUnavailable | 3 | Empty composition fails for every target kind |
| Composition_MismatchDoesNotSelectOtherProvider | 3 | Physical/simulation/replay mismatch despite alternative metadata |
| Composition_DuplicatesFailAtRegistrationBeforeContainerBuild | 2 | Same/cross-kind casing ambiguity fails eagerly, leaving services unchanged |
| Composition_CallerMutationBeforeContainerBuildCannotChangeRegistry | 1 | DI setup snapshot survives list replacement/ambiguity before container build |
| Composition_RejectsRepeatedSetupRatherThanSilentlyReplacingResolver | 1 | Repeated registration fails; original service behavior remains |
| Composition_RejectsMissingSelectionThroughResolvedService | 1 | Missing selection through actual resolved service |
| Composition_RejectsInvalidIdentifierAtSelectionBoundary | 2 | Invalid identifier cannot enter the composed use case |
| Composition_RejectsUndefinedKindAtSelectionBoundary | 1 | Omitted/default kind cannot enter the composed use case |
| Composition_RejectsNullRegistrationsWithoutAddingServices | 1 | Invalid setup is explicit and atomic |
| Composition_RejectsNullServiceCollection | 1 | Invalid composition argument is explicit |
The registry is in-memory metadata, not simulated hardware. Physical-kind
descriptors have no connection/write-approval fields or operational services.
These tests do not claim device integration evidence.
## 9. Environment, packages and runner
Inspected dotnet --info, dotnet --list-sdks, dotnet new list,
dotnet new xunit --help and dotnet new sln --help before scaffolding.
The installed templates explicitly support net10.0 and slnx.
| Item | Observed/selected |
|---|---|
| OS | Windows, version 10.0.26200 |
| RID / execution architecture | win-x64 / x64 |
| Installed and selected SDK | 10.0.402 |
| MSBuild | 18.9.15+a8dd0577c |
| Used Microsoft.NETCore.App host/runtime | 10.0.13, x64 |
| Target/configuration | net10.0 / Release, all four projects |
| SDK policy | 10.0.402, latestPatch, allowPrerelease=false |
| Runner | VSTest, SDK default; no MTP opt-in |
The SDK policy permits later stable patches only within 10.0.4xx, not other
feature bands or major versions. dotnet --version after configuration returned
10.0.402. No SDK, workload, driver or model installation was performed.
Package versions were checked against public nuget.org version indexes and
nuspec dependency/framework groups before final dependency changes:
| Package | Requested/resolved version | Compatibility evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Microsoft.Extensions.DependencyInjection.Abstractions | 10.0.14 | net10.0 dependency group; Application restore/build succeeded |
| Microsoft.Extensions.DependencyInjection | 10.0.14 | net10.0 group, matching abstractions; real container tests succeeded |
| Microsoft.NET.Test.Sdk | 18.11.0 | net8.0 test-host assets usable from net10.0; both suites discovered/executed |
| xunit | 2.9.3 | Framework family/version supplied by installed .NET 10 xUnit template; actual net10.0 execution |
| xunit.runner.visualstudio | 4.0.1 | Metadata explicitly supports xUnit v1/v2/v3 and .NET 8+; actual net10.0 execution |
Both test projects use identical central test package pins. The official xUnit
v2 package guidance states critical-fix maintenance continues, while new features
are developed in v3: https://xunit.net/docs/nuget-packages-v2 .
This is a supported maintenance-framework choice, not a claim that v2 is the
newest framework. No incompatible MTP/VSTest combination was added.
The unused template coverage collector was removed.
dotnet list .\src\AutoForge.slnx package --no-restore confirmed all exact direct
versions above and no packages in Core. Per-project dotnet msbuild queries for
TargetFramework, Nullable, ImplicitUsings and TreatWarningsAsErrors returned
net10.0, enable, enable and true for every project.
NuGet.Config selects only public nuget.org at repository scope. Shared props
enable nullable references, implicit usings, deterministic builds and warnings
as errors. Editor conventions use CRLF for code/config and LF for Markdown.
## 10. Exact restore/build commands and results
Commands were run from D:\_Repos\Code\GAJ3T\AutoForge in PowerShell.
| Command | Execution/result |
|---|---|
| dotnet restore .\src\AutoForge.slnx | Initial exit 1: NU1507 treated as error because two inherited package feeds were configured with central package management |
| dotnet restore .\src\AutoForge.slnx | After repository NuGet.Config: exit 0, all four projects restored, no warnings/errors emitted |
| dotnet build .\src\AutoForge.slnx --configuration Release --no-restore | Initial post-restore build: exit 0, 0 warnings, 0 errors; 3.05 seconds |
| dotnet build .\src\AutoForge.slnx --configuration Release --no-restore | Final post-source-format build: exit 0, 0 warnings, 0 errors; 0.58 seconds |
Meaningful initial failure: "NU1507: Warning As Error: There are 2 package sources
defined in your configuration. When using central package management, map your
package sources ... or specify a single package source."
Resolved at repository scope without suppressing warnings or modifying
user/machine feeds. No restore/build failure remains.
Scaffolding used dotnet new sln --format slnx and net10.0 classlib/xunit templates
with --no-restore; dotnet sln add and dotnet add reference established the graph.
All scaffolding/reference commands succeeded. No manual solution format invention.
Formatting commands both exited 0:
- dotnet format whitespace .\src\AutoForge.slnx --no-restore --verbosity minimal
- dotnet format whitespace .\src\AutoForge.slnx --no-restore --verify-no-changes --verbosity minimal
Solution membership: dotnet sln .\src\AutoForge.slnx list, exit 0, exactly four
expected projects.
## 11. Exact test command and per-project results
dotnet test .\src\AutoForge.slnx --configuration Release --no-build
Executed twice: after the initial successful build and after C# formatting/final
build. Both invocations exited 0 with identical counts. No runner adaptation.
Final measured output:
| Project | Discovered/total | Passed | Failed | Skipped | Runner duration |
|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---|
| AutoForge.UnitTests (net10.0) | 35 | 35 | 0 | 0 | 24 ms |
| AutoForge.IntegrationTests (net10.0) | 19 | 19 | 0 | 0 | 31 ms |
| Total | 54 | 54 | 0 | 0 | Not a deterministic performance claim |
Each project's output identified .NETCoreApp,Version=v10.0 and one matched test
assembly. No zero-discovery project, necessary skipped test or failed case.
No retained TRX was requested/generated. These durable counts and command results
are evidence; the temporary prerequisite tool output was removed after recording
its values, and this report does not depend on an ephemeral log path.
## 12. Acceptance verification
| ID | Status | Concrete evidence |
|---|---|---|
| AC-01 | PASSED | Initial clean status; only README/ignore modified among prior tracked files; protected hashes and Git diffs unchanged; index empty; no init/commit/push |
| AC-02 | PASSED | Actual root directories .git/docs/prompts/src only; tests under src/tests; prohibited root/nested paths absent |
| AC-03 | PASSED | slnx membership lists exactly four projects; per-project reference queries and MSBuild property inspection confirm net10.0 and inward graph |
| AC-04 | PASSED | Installed/selected SDK 10.0.402, runtime 10.0.13 x64; shared nullable/editor/build settings; central compatible pins and actual VSTest execution |
| AC-05 | PASSED | Core descriptor plus Application resolver/DI snapshot enforce explicit identity/kind, every mismatch, missing/unknown/duplicate errors and mutation isolation; 35 unit cases |
| AC-06 | PASSED | 19 real DI-based cases cover all target kinds, empty/invalid/mismatched/duplicate configuration and selection, without mocking the service |
| AC-07 | PASSED | Successful restore and final Release build, 0 build warnings/errors; both suites executed with 35/19 passed and 0 failed/skipped |
| AC-08 | PASSED | Four actual docs include index, architecture/Mermaid/error contract, ADR and exact build/testing policy; README distinguishes implemented/in-progress/planned |
| AC-09 | PASSED | Actual project/package graph has no operational/UI/AI/hardware dependency; no fake production providers, host substitution, automatic handoff or placeholder project |
| AC-10 | PASSED | This exact Step-01-Report.md contains the required evidence/sections inside one plain copy window; worker stops without advancing |
## 13. Documentation changes
Created the documentation index, actual dependency/Mermaid architecture and
failure contract, foundation ADR, and build/test guide. They document eager
registration validation, immutable snapshots, identifier comparison, package/SDK
policy, exact commands, test boundaries and current limitations.
Future read-only hardware and AI-independent deterministic simulation/oracle
boundaries are recorded as requirements, not implemented capabilities. Both
future Blazor hosts/shared RCLs are explicitly preserved.
## 14. Root README changes
Changed: YES. Original product description retained verbatim as product vision.
Added IMPLEMENTED, IN PROGRESS and PLANNED sections; explicit Step-01 manual
acceptance status; actual graph/layout, SDK policy and exact commands; real
documentation links; headless test entry point; no interactive startup command;
and explicit absence of simulation/diagnostics/backups/AI/UI/hardware operations.
## 15. Known limitations
- Metadata selection only; no real providers, discovery, connections, capability
inspection, operations or approval service.
- Simulation, replay, diagnostics, profiles, telemetry, calibration, backups,
persistence, AI, UI and hardware programming remain unimplemented.
- No real vehicle, native driver, MAUI host or model was used or verified.
- Core/Application are platform-neutral, but runtime verification is Windows x64
only. No cross-platform or UI build is claimed.
- xUnit v2 is critical-fix maintained, not the newest framework feature line.
- Direct dependency pins are centralized; no transitive lock file, offline
package mirror or coverage percentage is claimed.
- Initial restore needs nuget.org access; the use case/tests need no network,
hardware, wall-clock input, randomness or AI service.
- Manual acceptance is pending. No later assignment has been started.
## 16. Outstanding issues, failures, warnings and unexecuted scope
No blocking prerequisite, unresolved implementation defect or required failed/
unexecuted check remains.
Corrected execution/inspection issues:
1. Initial restore failed NU1507, exit 1; repository-local single-source
NuGet.Config fixed it. Subsequent restore/build/test succeeded.
2. Exploratory dotnet list .\src\AutoForge.slnx reference reported
"Project `.\src\AutoForge.slnx` is invalid." This reference subcommand did not
accept the solution path; it was not a solution build failure. Its individual
exit was not captured in that exploratory batch (the later package query
made the batch exit 0). Corrected per-project reference queries all exited 0:
- dotnet list .\src\AutoForge.Core\AutoForge.Core.csproj reference
- dotnet list .\src\AutoForge.Application\AutoForge.Application.csproj reference
- dotnet list .\src\tests\AutoForge.UnitTests\AutoForge.UnitTests.csproj reference
- dotnet list .\src\tests\AutoForge.IntegrationTests\AutoForge.IntegrationTests.csproj reference
3. Auxiliary Git whitespace check returned exit 2 after trying CRLF normalization
of README. Explicit LF Markdown convention and normalization restored
git diff --check to exit 0. This changed no functional source. The user's
core.autocrlf=true still emits a non-blocking README LF-to-CRLF notice; no Git
configuration was changed. Build warnings/errors remain 0/0.
4. Final ignore assertions used git check-ignore --no-index --quiet, avoiding
verbose output's matched-negation ambiguity. Confirmed .env/.env.local,
local private data, bin/obj and TestResults are ignored; .env.example,
synthetic fixture paths and both assignment/report paths remain visible.
Final Git status/diff/inventory and protected-file/index checks were reviewed.
No accidental extra files, secret assets, staged files or scope drift were found.
Generated output stays under ignored src project bin/obj directories.
Hardware, UI/MAUI, simulation, AI and non-Windows runtime checks were NOT EXECUTED
because they are outside Step-01, not skipped requirements or success claims.
## 17. Deviations and rationale
- User supplied "promps/Step-01.md"; that path does not exist. Executed the actual
repository assignment at prompts/Step-01.md after recursively reading all
repository content outside Git metadata. No replacement assignment was created.
- Added repository-local NuGet.Config, a permitted root config, to remove
inherited-feed ambiguity exposed by actual restore. No architecture change.
- Identifier padding rejection and repeated DI setup rejection are documented,
tested local invariant choices, not target inference or fallback.
- No required scope, target framework, UI architecture or handoff was substituted.
No other agent was invoked.
## 18. Recommendations and stop
Orchestrator should compare the implementation and test coverage with the
original assignment, inspect the unchanged protected files and actual reference
graph, and review the recorded restore correction, package support choice and
54 passing cases. Worker completion does not update orchestration state.
If accepted, the orchestrator may prepare a separate Step-02 assignment for
manual handoff. This worker has not created it, modified roadmap/state, committed,
pushed or begun any later feature.
Worker stops after persisting this report.
```