AutoForge/prompts/Step-07B-Report.md

9.4 KiB

# Step-07B worker report

## Status

COMPLETE — Step-07B implementation and verification are complete. Manual
orchestrator review remains pending. Step-07 and Step-07A remain NOT ACCEPTED;
Step-08 remains blocked and was not started.

## Implementation

`DiagnosticSession.DisposeAsync` now uses `_lifetimeGate` only to establish
close ownership, publish the closed state, snapshot/clear registered resources
and publish a single shared disposal task. After releasing the gate, one
caller starts cancellation and resource/control/transport cleanup. Concurrent
callers return the same task and observe its actual completion or failure.
Late resource registration remains rejected after close ownership begins.
Existing resource ordering and error aggregation are unchanged.

The test-only `BarrierObservationProtocolClient` forwards actual calls and
observations from `SyntheticDiagnosticProtocolClient` and places a controlled
barrier in the actual capture subscription's dispose path. It exposes no
production race selector and does not mock the session, capture or protocol.
The cleanup-error regression uses a task-owned `IAsyncDisposable` resource.

Changed files:

- [DiagnosticSessionService.cs](../src/AutoForge.Application/Features/Vehicles/Diagnostics/DiagnosticSessionService.cs)
- [TelemetryRecordingIntegrationTests.cs](../src/tests/AutoForge.IntegrationTests/TelemetryRecordingIntegrationTests.cs)
- [README.md](../README.md)
- [docs/README.md](../docs/README.md)
- [architecture.md](../docs/architecture.md)
- [build-and-test.md](../docs/build-and-test.md)

## Pre-fix reproduction

Command:

`dotnet test .\src\tests\AutoForge.IntegrationTests\AutoForge.IntegrationTests.csproj --configuration Release --filter "FullyQualifiedName~SessionCloseDuringCaptureDetach_DoesNotDeadlockOrLoseFailurePrefix"`

Exit 1: the two theory cases failed and zero passed. Each case used controlled
barriers to establish the exact order: an actual diagnostic operation reached
capture limit/error detach after releasing the capture lock; close/reset
entered the second subscription-dispose call while the callback still owned
observation dispatch; then the callback barrier was released. After the
five-second safety deadline the test reported, for both the close and reset
cases, `Operation completed=False; close/reset completed=False.` This is the
observed lock cycle, not an inferred timing race or a compile failure. The
bounded xUnit process exited normally with the failures; no process tree had
to be terminated and no intentionally blocked task remained in a normal
passing run.

## Frozen corrective matrix

| Requirement | Evidence and result |
|---|---|
| C-01 normal stop/close with or without active capture | Existing stop-drain, repeated-registration, source-close retention, stopped saveability and cross-scope tests remain in the focused suite. Native static/dynamics workflow was also repeated. PASSED. |
| C-02 limit-detach competing with source close | `SessionCloseDuringCaptureDetach_DoesNotDeadlockOrLoseFailurePrefix(reset: False)` forces the callback/close interleaving above. Post-fix both operation and close complete, the one-observation prefix remains `Incomplete / LimitExceeded`, and session registration is released. PASSED. |
| C-03 observation-error detach competing with reset | The same regression with `reset: True` forces error detach against `DiagnosticSessionService.ResetAsync`. Post-fix both operation and reset complete; the original one-observation prefix remains `Error / ObservationFailure`; the replacement has a new session identity and its real signal read does not mutate the old snapshot. PASSED. |
| C-04 concurrent disposal, late registration and cleanup failure | `ConcurrentSessionDispose_SharesCompletionAndReportsCleanupFailure` verifies concurrent callers receive the same `Task`, late registration throws `ObjectDisposedException`, the controlled resource is disposed once, and both callers receive the same explicit cleanup exception. Barrier release is in `finally`. PASSED. |
| C-05 existing archive/registration/storage/panel/source/model/unit/native paths | All 310 Step-07A cases remain in the 313-test full suite; the three new theory/test cases pass. Fixed archive and capture limits, source semantics and native record/save/readback are preserved. PASSED. |
| AC-01 C-01..C-03 safe close/reset | Actual pre-fix lock-cycle reproduction and controlled post-fix completion/prefix/reason/replacement assertions. PASSED. |
| AC-02 C-04 shared cleanup semantics | Concurrent disposal identity/count, rejection and shared cleanup error assertions plus source ordering review. PASSED. |
| AC-03 C-05 regressions/build/native | 179 unit + 134 integration tests, nine-project Release build and native static/dynamics smoke. PASSED. |
| AC-04 scope/history/docs/self-review/report | Related documentation updated; protected files/history preserved; this report saved and worker stops before Step-08. PASSED. |

## Post-fix commands and results

Focused, build and full-suite commands ran sequentially:

| Command | Exit | Result |
|---|---:|---|
| `dotnet test .\src\tests\AutoForge.IntegrationTests\AutoForge.IntegrationTests.csproj --configuration Release --filter "FullyQualifiedName~SessionCloseDuringCaptureDetach_DoesNotDeadlockOrLoseFailurePrefix|FullyQualifiedName~ConcurrentSessionDispose_SharesCompletionAndReportsCleanupFailure"` | 0 | Three cases passed, zero failed/skipped. |
| `dotnet test .\src\tests\AutoForge.IntegrationTests\AutoForge.IntegrationTests.csproj --configuration Release --filter "FullyQualifiedName~TelemetryRecordingIntegrationTests"` | 0 | 29 passed, zero failed/skipped. |
| `dotnet build .\src\AutoForge.slnx --configuration Release --no-restore` | 0 | All nine projects, including Windows Client; zero warnings and zero errors. The XAML source-generation notice was informational. |
| `dotnet test .\src\AutoForge.slnx --configuration Release --no-build` | 0 | 179 unit + 134 integration = 313 passed; zero failed/skipped. |

The full suite preserves the 310-case Step-07A baseline (179 unit and 131
integration) and adds the two barrier theory cases plus one concurrent-dispose
case. Existing fixed limits remain 4,096 observations, 16 MiB encoded
observations, 1 MiB header, 32 MiB archive and JSON depth 128.

## Native versus controlled evidence

The rebuilt Windows Client was operated through its local WebView2 DevTools
endpoint:

- Static v1 recorded two actual operations (`read.dtcs` and `read.signals`),
  stopped, then closed its source while the unsaved capture remained
  inspectable. It was explicitly saved afterward. After app restart, the
  archive loaded with its original raw bytes and two decoded signals.
- Dynamics v2 was explicitly stepped to model step 7 / 0.7 seconds. With
  gauges hidden, two actual telemetry reads captured four actual
  `read.signals` observations at the same model context. The capture was
  stopped and the source closed before save; the stopped unsaved data remained
  inspectable. After app restart, the archive loaded with raw data and decoded
  source/model/configuration/run context.
- Both archives were loaded after restart. Metric/Road preferences remained
  unchanged. Exact task-owned IDs were `3b6bbb098a094ac2ba10c042dcd4fbf0`
  (static v1, two observations) and `ac5b4d4e814d4905a0d454292b4dde87`
  (dynamics v2, four observations). After closing the Client and DevTools
  listener, only those exact verified archive files were removed. The app's
  existing/default WebView profile and unrelated application data were not
  removed or reset.

Native evidence verifies normal static/dynamic record, stop, source close,
retained capture, explicit save, restart and readback. The exact race is
proved by controlled integration barriers, not by a human-timed native claim.

## Documentation, self-review and preservation

Updated the architecture contract to state that close ownership, closed-state
publication, resource snapshot and shared task publication occur under the
lifetime gate, while cancellation and resource/control/transport disposal run
after the gate is released. The root and docs READMEs now describe the
Step-07B correction and link this report. The build guide records the actual
pre-fix reproduction, final commands/counts and native/control distinction.
Step-07 and Step-07A reports and their positive archive/native evidence remain
unchanged.

Post-green self-review traced `DiagnosticSession.DisposeAsync` through close,
reset, cancellation, capture `StopForSourceClose`, limit/error detach,
unregistration, control and transport disposal. The gate is no longer held
while callbacks or observer drain run. `_disposeTask` is published before
another caller can start cleanup; registration checks the closed state under
the same gate; unregistration remains available after the close snapshot.
Disposal error aggregation and completion ordering are preserved. The
barrier tests assert operation and close/reset completion together, the exact
failure prefix/reason, registration release and replacement isolation. The
concurrent cleanup test releases its barrier in `finally`. No additional
issue was found in the review.

`git diff --check` passed. Only the six listed implementation/test/documentation
files and this requested report were changed. Step-07/07A assignment files,
historical reports, Step-07B assignment, state, roadmap and quality gate remain
unchanged. No package/project/system/workload changes, staging, commit, push,
or Step-08 work occurred. Step-07/07A acceptance remains for manual review.
Stop here.