AutoForge/prompts/STATE.md

83 KiB

AutoForge orchestration state

Current handoff

Field Value
Updated 2026-10-30
Phase Step-07 reviewed; archive/lifetime/visible-I/O correction required
Active step Step-07A - Source-faithful archives and bounded capture cleanup
Assignment Step-07A.md
Assignment status READY FOR WORKER / AWAITING MANUAL HANDOFF
Expected worker report prompts/Step-07A-Report.md - not yet created
Last accepted correction Step-06A - accepted 2026-10-30
Last accepted major milestone Step-06 with Step-06A - accepted 2026-10-30
Outstanding corrections Step-07 R-01 through R-04 against original frozen criteria
Step-02 status ACCEPTED after Step-02A
Step-03 status ACCEPTED after Step-03A/Step-03B
Step-04 status ACCEPTED after Step-04A/Step-04B
Step-04A review All original corrective criteria closed with Step-04B
Step-05 status ACCEPTED after Step-05A/Step-05B
Step-05A review All original corrective criteria closed with Step-05B
Step-06 status ACCEPTED after Step-06A
Step-07 status REQUIRES CORRECTION / NOT ACCEPTED
Step-08 status Recorded telemetry replay; BLOCKED until Step-07 acceptance
Worker execution Step-07 returned; Step-07A not invoked
Immediate next action User manually directs the worker to execute Step-07A with original Step-07 and shared quality gate
Next orchestrator action After manual return, inspect the assignment, report, implementation, tests, Git changes, documentation and recorded command evidence

Repository baseline at initialization

  • Repository: D:\_Repos\Code\GAJ3T\AutoForge.
  • Branch observed: main, tracking origin/main.
  • Initial worktree: clean.
  • Initial tracked files: root README.md and .gitignore.
  • No existing solution, projects, tests, docs, src, or prompts were present.
  • No applicable AGENTS.md was found in the repository or its ancestor locations.
  • No .github instruction files were found. In particular, .github/copilot-instructions.md was absent and must remain absent.
  • Existing README describes the product vision, not verified implemented features; Step-01 requires preserving it while making implementation status explicit.
  • Existing .gitignore already includes common Visual Studio/.NET build patterns. Worker must extend only where necessary and preserve existing entries.
  • Initial orchestrator changes were limited to prompts/ROADMAP.md, this file, and prompts/Step-01.md. Step-01 subsequently added the implementation below.

Architecture decisions in force

See ROADMAP.md for the full planned architecture and milestones.

  1. The repository has only three top-level project directories: docs, src, prompts; existing protected infrastructure is preserved. Tests are under src/tests. No root tests, root artifacts, or nested AutoForge directory.
  2. Keep the existing single src/AutoForge.slnx, Core, Application, UnitTests and IntegrationTests. Accepted target-selection code/tests remain useful.
  3. Sole initial application executable: AutoForge.Client, .NET 10 MAUI Blazor Hybrid, initially Windows. No required standalone WebAssembly/web shell or separate backend. Ordinary desktop capabilities run in-process as a modular monolith; additional hosts/processes need a concrete approved requirement.
  4. Accepted Step-01A established Client -> UI -> Components. Client is thin native startup, BlazorWebView and DI/lifecycle/platform composition. UI owns complete routes, pages, navigation/layouts and feature presentation. Components owns generic reusable controls. UI cannot reference Client; Components cannot reference UI.
  5. Application is needed now and retained. Organize use cases into cohesive feature slices, beginning with existing execution-target selection. No mediator, generic repository/manager layer, prescribed boilerplate or empty future slices. UI invokes application contracts; business logic stays outside Razor components.
  6. Reusable domain, simulation, diagnostic, calibration, telemetry and AI capability libraries remain independently testable and are added only when justified. They do not depend on Client/UI or their coordinating application slices. Hardware, inference, storage and UI implementations never own domain truth.
  7. Simulation, replay, and physical hardware targets are explicit and cannot silently substitute for one another. Selection is not connection or execution.
  8. Synthetic data is labeled; simulation is deterministic and independent of AI, and verification uses an isolated oracle unavailable to ordinary UI/AI paths.
  9. AI plans are validated runbooks; no arbitrary hardware commands or offsets. Local inference is replaceable; core operation does not require AI/cloud.
  10. Initial hardware integration is read-only. Simulated approval, physical capability discovery, and driver availability cannot authorize physical writes. Bench and vehicle programming require separate future authorization/evidence.
  11. All handoffs are manual. Orchestrator never invokes the worker, implements application changes, or executes application builds/tests.
  12. The worker does not change the roadmap, state, or assignment; it may write only the current assignment's report under prompts. No automatic commits/pushes.

Historical Step-01 acceptance review

Decision at that review: ACCEPTED, 2026-10-28, with no identified blocking defect under the then-current architecture. This acceptance and its evidence remain historical facts. The later owner decision now requires Step-01A before progression; it does not erase the accepted implementation or its reports.

Reviewed Step-01, the worker report, all seven production source files, all three test source files, four project files, solution, five root configuration files, README/ignore diffs and all four technical documents. The source enforces explicit identity/kind selection, case-insensitive uniqueness, no cross-target fallback, immutable descriptors and registration snapshots. Integration tests exercise the real DI/Core/Application path rather than mocks.

Criterion Decision Evidence
AC-01 ACCEPTED Expected README/ignore changes only among pre-existing implementation files; empty index; original assignment/roadmap/state hashes matched the report before orchestration updates; protected instructions absent
AC-02 ACCEPTED Actual root project directories are docs/src/prompts; tests under src/tests; no root tests/artifacts or nested repository
AC-03 ACCEPTED Inspected solution and all project references: Core has none; Application -> Core; both test projects -> Core/Application; all net10.0
AC-04 ACCEPTED Inspected SDK policy, nullable/build/editor settings, central package pins and assets; worker records installed SDK 10.0.402 and actual VSTest execution
AC-05 ACCEPTED Descriptor/resolver/DI source satisfies explicit validation, uniqueness, snapshot and no-fallback requirements; no production provider is fabricated
AC-06 ACCEPTED All composition tests inspected; real container/service path covers positive selection and empty/invalid/mismatched/duplicate cases
AC-07 ACCEPTED ON WORKER EXECUTION EVIDENCE Reported final Release build: zero warnings/errors; unit 35/35, integration 19/19, zero failures/skips; source case counts and existing restore/Release outputs corroborate the report
AC-08 ACCEPTED Documentation index, architecture/error contract/Mermaid, ADR, build/test guide and README describe actual scope and planned features accurately
AC-09 ACCEPTED No operational hardware/AI/UI dependency or extra placeholder project; no automatic handoff introduced
AC-10 ACCEPTED Complete report contains exact command outcomes, corrected failures, acceptance mapping and required sections in one plain copy window; no later implementation present

Worker-reported execution: Windows x64, SDK 10.0.402, runtime 10.0.13; restore, Release build and both suites succeeded after the documented repository-local NuGet feed correction. Reported total: 54 passed, zero failed, zero skipped. Existing assets confirm the framework/dependency graph; Release binaries exist for all four projects. Their presence is corroboration, not an independent test execution.

The orchestrator executed only read-only inspection and document/Git checks, including static test-case counting and ignore-policy checks. It did not execute dotnet, application builds, tests, formatting or hardware operations. Runtime results are explicitly worker evidence. The worker's original report and assignment remain unchanged; implementation is not committed by this review.

Owner architectural realignment and current inspection

On 2026-10-28 the owner canceled the two-shell plan, required Client/UI/Components and application Vertical Slice Architecture, and directed correction before Step-02. Step-01A was the corrective assignment and is now accepted.

At correction planning, inspection found the original four-project solution unchanged: Core has no dependencies, Application references Core and DI abstractions, and both tests reference Core/Application. The existing target resolver and eager registration are suitable for a feature slice and must be preserved.

There was no host/component implementation to delete or migrate. Correction was additive UI composition plus feature organization, not a repository restart. The old Step-02 was held, not executed.

After acceptance, Step-02 was regenerated from the seven-project implementation and explicitly supersedes the prior unexecuted assignment. It now uses application feature slices, reusable Core models and a thin profile metadata consumer in the existing UI. Step-02 implementation/report now exist; acceptance was initially withheld for the findings below and is now granted after Step-02A.

Step-01A acceptance review

Decision: ACCEPTED, 2026-10-28. No Step-01B assignment is required.

Reviewed the assignment, worker report, solution and all project references, Client native/bootstrap/host code, RCL routes, feature pages/view model/component/styles, moved Application feature, new rendered/ graph tests, package/build configuration, README and all affected technical docs.

Criterion Decision Evidence
AC-01 ACCEPTED Existing descriptor/resolver semantics and 54 prior cases retained; expanded suites contain 39 unit/26 integration cases; root layout/history/manual workflow preserved
AC-02 ACCEPTED Actual seven-project solution, one production executable, MAUI/Windows Client configuration and native Release output
AC-03 ACCEPTED MainPage hosts UI Routes through BlazorWebView; UI owns routes/layout/pages, Components owns StatusNotice; native route/assets observations reported
AC-04 ACCEPTED Project files, graph test and independent static traversal confirm Client -> UI -> Components, allowed Application references and no cycles
AC-05 ACCEPTED Feature folder contains real resolver/DI/errors with stable public namespace and unchanged explicit selection/snapshot/no-fallback behavior
AC-06 ACCEPTED Actual HtmlRenderer component/route tests use real Core/Application DI, cover errors/unknown routes and safe text rendering, without Client references
AC-07 ACCEPTED ON WORKER EXECUTION EVIDENCE Reported complete Release solution and direct Windows Client builds: zero warnings/errors; 39 unit plus 26 integration passed, zero failed/skipped; matching source counts and Release outputs inspected
AC-08 ACCEPTED ON WORKER NATIVE EVIDENCE Detailed reported native home/selection/unregistered-physical/not-found checks, hidden error banner and both RCL CSS assets loading; native executable exists, not rerun by orchestrator
AC-09 ACCEPTED README/index/architecture/build guide and ADR-0001/0002 reflect one shell, two RCLs, VSA/modular monolith and metadata-only limitations
AC-10 ACCEPTED Evidence-bearing report, corrected failures and environment deviation disclosed; historical reports/assignments preserved and Step-02 unexecuted

Worker-reported verified platform: SDK 10.0.402, runtime 10.0.13, Windows 10.0.26100.0/win-x64, MAUI Windows manifest 10.0.110 and WebView2 155.0.4283.62. The source counts, framework/assets, seven-project graph and native/portable Release artifacts corroborate the report. They do not prove an independent runtime run. No application builds/tests/native launch were performed here.

Acceptance covers the application correction, not approval of the unintended workload action or a claim that the broader tool environment is unchanged. The deviations below are non-blocking for this verified Windows foundation and must remain visible. No environment rollback or source fix was attempted.

Historical Step-02 review and corrective decision

Initial decision: REQUIRES CORRECTION, 2026-10-28. The findings and criterion table below describe the pre-correction implementation. They are preserved as history and closed by the Step-02A acceptance review that follows.

Inspected the assignment, worker report, complete new Core/profile codec/catalog/DI/UI code, all new unit/integration tests, synthetic fixtures, existing composition/reference changes, README and affected technical/schema/ADR documentation.

Criterion Review result Evidence / remaining work
AC-01 Preserved on inspected evidence Same seven-project graph, existing target/UI regressions and manual/protected workflow; no new dependency or shell
AC-02 Present; validation correction required Immutable profile/revision/module model works for supplied fixtures, but valid partial module-evidence context is rejected
AC-03 Present on inspected evidence Five capability states, custom operations and explicit undeclared Unknown retained; no operational authority
AC-04 NOT SATISFIED R-02 treats absent optional evidence identity constraints as exact null matches, rejecting compatible module-scoped evidence
AC-05 NOT SATISFIED R-01 permits incomplete timestamp strings that infer ambient date or offset, violating explicit schema data
AC-06 Existing path inspected; correction regressions required Real DI catalog/UI and atomic failed imports exist; both findings need direct/service/UI regression coverage
AC-07 Present on inspected evidence Three synthetic fixture documents cover baseline, variant, alternate/custom module and all five states
AC-08 Existing suite passed per worker; insufficient coverage Reported 59 unit + 34 integration passed, zero failed/skipped; solution/native build and native smoke passed; findings are absent from this coverage
AC-09 Corrective alignment required Documentation exists, but timestamp/optional applicability behavior must match the stated contract and correction status
AC-10 Report/preservation inspected Required report and scope evidence present; original assignment/report remain unchanged; no Step-03

R-01 - Ambient-dependent timestamp import

VehicleProfileJsonCodec.cs, line 478, delegates to DateTimeOffset.TryParse with RoundtripKind. Official .NET documentation states that a missing date defaults to the current day, a missing offset defaults to the local time zone, and RoundtripKind has no effect for this type. Time-only, date-only and offset-free date/time strings therefore are not reliably rejected by this supposedly explicit/clock-independent import contract. Both publishedAt and retrievedAt use this path.

R-02 - Absent evidence constraints rejected

VehicleProfile.cs, lines 367 and 408, validates each optional module identity using a helper that requires both values to be null when the evidence field is null. A module with known hardware cannot accept module-scoped evidence that leaves hardware applicability unspecified, even when vehicle/profile/module and all supplied constraints match. This contradicts the documented optional identity context. Fix absence handling without weakening supplied-constraint or unknown-target checks.

These are source/contract findings, not claims of independently executed failures. Official API documentation corroborates R-01; Step-02A requires worker reproduction, corrected regressions and native/UI evidence, now supplied and reviewed below.

Worker-reported Step-02 execution remains historical: complete seven-project and direct native Release builds with zero warnings/errors; 59 unit and 34 integration cases passed, zero failed/skipped; native profile import/select/variant/error/export and old route/asset checks reported. Static test counts, fixture shape, restore assets and Release/native artifacts corroborate it. No build/test/native/workload command was executed by the orchestrator.

Step-02A acceptance and corrected Step-02

Decision: ACCEPTED, 2026-10-28. Step-02A closes R-01/R-02; the corrected Step-02 milestone is accepted. No Step-02B is required.

Reviewed Step-02A, its report, the complete new timestamp parser/shared evidence helper, correction unit/real DI/rendered UI tests, data mutation helpers, schema/ADR/README/testing updates and project scope.

Criterion Decision Evidence
AC-01 ACCEPTED Anchored ASCII full-date/time/offset grammar, exact invariant calendar parse, bounded minute offset and typed property failures; both timestamp fields have positive/negative vectors and exact offset/tick assertions
AC-02 ACCEPTED Null constraint is absence; non-null requires known matching target; each-field omission/matching/mismatch/unknown-target constructor tests and all-null real DI round-trip inspected
AC-03 ACCEPTED Actual service/page path accepts module-only evidence, rejects timestamp/supplied mismatch, preserves catalog/current selection and renders explicit errors
AC-04 ACCEPTED Previous 93 cases remain in the expanded 140-case suite; fixtures, seven-project graph, metadata/target isolation and public contracts retained
AC-05 ACCEPTED ON WORKER EXECUTION EVIDENCE Reported actual pre-fix failures; focused corrected runs; complete sequential Release build 0 warnings/errors; 103 unit + 37 integration passes, zero failed/skipped; native scenarios and original fixtures observed
AC-06 ACCEPTED Schema/ADR specify precise grammar/null/offset limits and absent-versus-supplied identity constraints; README/index/test guide preserve historical versus corrective results
AC-07 ACCEPTED Scope remains two fixes/tests/docs/report; no new package/project/workload action or later-step implementation; historical assignments/reports preserved

Coverage precision: the direct unit helper's null label retains all known constraints, while its four named cases omit each constraint individually. The separate real DI/UI integration test supplies all four nulls and constructs/ round-trips the actual Core model. Acceptance uses that combined inspected coverage, not an assumption that the unit loop's null label means all-null.

Worker-reported execution: SDK 10.0.402/runtime 10.0.13; Windows target 10.0.26100.0/win-x64; MAUI Windows manifest 10.0.110; WebView2 155.0.4283.62. Before-fix command outcomes and focused runs are recorded in the unchanged report. Final build: complete seven-project Release solution, zero warnings/errors. Final suites: 103 unit and 37 integration passed, zero failed/skipped. Native observations include full explicit-offset timestamps/partial evidence, exact invalid-time path, conflicting supplied constraint with unchanged catalog/ selection, original baseline/variant/alternate imports and target metadata route.

Static source case counts, seven-project acyclic references, restored assets, Release assemblies and native executable corroborate the report. The orchestrator did not execute application builds/tests/native launch or workload commands. The original Step-02 and Step-02A assignments/reports remain historical evidence.

Step-03 is prepared against the actual accepted profile/Application/UI baseline. It assigns Diagnostics and Simulation as two real new library boundaries, with provider-neutral Application features and Client composition. They now exist and the corrected Step-03 milestone is accepted; dynamics/physical adapters remain unimplemented until their separate assignments.

Historical Step-03 review and corrective decision

Initial decision: REQUIRES CORRECTION, 2026-10-28. R-01/R-02/R-03 below describe the pre-Step-03A code and are now closed. Step-03 still requires the additional R-04 correction recorded after the Step-03A review below.

Inspected the assignment, worker report, Diagnostics contracts/codec/client, Simulation definitions/provider/state and internal oracle, application session service, UI view model/page, new protocol/ session/rendered tests, project references, README and protocol/simulation/ADR/ build documentation.

Criterion Review result Evidence / remaining work
AC-01 Preserved on inspected evidence Nine-project graph, sole Client, no reverse references/cycles and IntegrationTests-only internal oracle
AC-02 Present on inspected evidence Explicit exact profile/provider/kind/session selection and reset/close with no fallback
AC-03 Present; validation correction required Real frames traverse transport, but omitted/duplicate request fields and semantically invalid positive replies are not adequately rejected
AC-04 Normal flow works per inspected/reported evidence State isolation, read/clear/reset and static signals present; R-03 must detect clear acknowledgement without empty readback
AC-05 NOT SATISFIED R-01/R-02 expose malformed/ambiguous frames and invalid typed data outside existing fault tests
AC-06 NOT SATISFIED Probe identity mismatch becomes a discovery ProtocolError after its exchange was already traced PositiveResponse
AC-07 Corrective verification required UI/session/provider composition is real, but nonempty successful readback is labeled cleared/verified
AC-08 Existing suite passed per worker; insufficient coverage 108 unit + 53 integration passed, zero failed/skipped; complete Release/native build and native smoke reported; new vectors not covered
AC-09 Corrective alignment required Documentation exists; wire presence/ambiguity, semantic validation and verified-clear contracts/lifecycle must be aligned
AC-10 Report/preservation inspected Required report and scoped changes present; original assignment/report preserved; no Step-04

Step-03 R-01 - Required and unambiguous frames

SyntheticProtocolV1.cs, lines 45 and 82, defaults Version to 1 and deserializes without requiring its presence or rejecting duplicate JSON properties. Omitting version leaves a valid v1 object; omitting logicalTimeTicks can leave zero. Repeated service/version/ correlation fields can be resolved by last-value deserialization rather than rejected. With otherwise valid session binding, the transport can dispatch a virtual clear from a malformed/ambiguous request.

Step-03 R-02 - Service semantics and truthful trace

SyntheticDiagnosticProtocolClient.cs, line 143, reads signal ticks and strings into unvalidated result records. For example a negative logicalTimeTicks or blank signal ID/unit can still become PositiveResponse. DTC strings likewise lack semantic validation.

The probe module-identity check at line 55 occurs outside the exchange decoder. A mismatched probe is recorded positive at line 289 before discovery converts it to ProtocolError. Returned outcome and raw exchange trace therefore disagree. Validate the complete interpreted payload before positive result/trace commitment.

Step-03 R-03 - Acknowledgement versus verified clear

DiagnosticPageViewModel.cs, line 261, tests only readback.IsSuccess and then says the state was cleared. A successful response containing remaining DTCs still takes this success path. The logical use case must fail verification when readback is nonempty or failed/unknown/cancelled, while preserving the actual observed data and no physical-operation claim.

These are static source/contract findings, not parent-executed reproductions. The worker subsequently supplied actual reproductions and corrected evidence.

Reported Step-03 evidence remains historical: complete nine-project/native Release build zero warnings/errors; 108 unit + 53 integration passed, zero failed/skipped; native explicit open/probe/read/clear/reset/close/trace and old routes observed. Static case counts, graph, restore assets and Release/native outputs corroborate the report. No build/test/native/workload command was executed by the orchestrator.

Historical Step-03A scoped acceptance and additional discovery finding

Decision: Step-03A's R-01/R-02/R-03 corrections ACCEPTED, 2026-10-28. At that review the parent Step-03 milestone was NOT ACCEPTED: R-04 required Step-03B. The three successful corrections remain closed; R-04 is now also closed by the subsequent acceptance review below.

Reviewed Step-03A, its report, strict wire presence/uniqueness logic, complete reply/trace validation, Application verified clear/result and UI adaptation, unit/state-oracle/real-DI/rendered fault tests, test-only rewriting transport and directly related docs.

Criterion Scoped decision Evidence
AC-01 ACCEPTED All ten request fields required, explicit zero retained, duplicate/unknown fields rejected; malformed clear vectors leave independent state unchanged
AC-02 ACCEPTED Exact reply/service shapes, semantic identifiers/timing/uniqueness and positive/error/data consistency validated before positive result; malformed vectors return no value
AC-03 ACCEPTED Wrong probe module is now checked within the exchange decoder; one matching ProtocolError trace retains actual request/reply rather than false positive
AC-04 ACCEPTED Application clear-and-verify separates acknowledgement/readback, rejects nonempty/failed/unknown readback, preserves remaining codes and renders failure
AC-05 ACCEPTED WITHIN CORRECTIVE SCOPE Original 161-case baseline retained, nine-project graph/state/target/profile/clock boundaries unchanged; R-04 is an additional pre-existing discovery case
AC-06 ACCEPTED ON WORKER EXECUTION EVIDENCE Reported actual 2-unit/5-integration pre-fix failures; corrected focused runs; full Release build 0 warnings/errors; 111 unit + 64 integration passes, zero failed/skipped; native baseline observed
AC-07 ACCEPTED README/protocol/simulation/ADR/test docs reflect corrected wire/verification and historical versus corrective results
AC-08 ACCEPTED No new project/package/workload action or future step; original assignments/reports and orchestration files preserved by worker

Worker-reported final coverage: 175 passed (111 unit, 64 integration), zero failed/skipped. Native evidence covers genuine verified clear/empty readback, probe/read/trace/reset/close and old routes. The false-ack/nonempty-readback fault is explicitly real DI/rendered integration evidence, not native coverage; the production Client has no runtime fault control and none was added just for proof.

Static source case counts, nine-project acyclic graph and existing restore/ Release/native artifacts corroborate the report, not independent runtime execution. The orchestrator did not run builds/tests or launch the app.

R-04 - Successful probe evidence discarded when identity is unavailable

SyntheticDiagnosticProtocolClient.cs, line 72, always follows a valid probe with an identity read, then constructs the entry solely from identity outcome and drops the validated service list when identity fails. ProviderContracts.cs, line 257, defines Responders as non-null identities. DiagnosticPageViewModel.cs, line 132, labels this identity count as actual endpoints that responded.

A valid module definition implementing probe but not read.identity is allowed. It returns a positive validated probe and an unsupported identity reply, yet it is omitted from the responder count. Likewise, a successful probe is lost if the subsequent identity reply is malformed, timed out or cancelled. Reachability, advertised services and identity verification are different facts.

Step-03B was required to preserve both phase outcomes, keep valid probe/service evidence, label probe responders versus identified modules honestly, and keep unavailable identity explicit without fabricating profile-derived identity or relaxing existing identity-dependent action guards. The source finding was not executed by the orchestrator; the worker subsequently supplied the pre-fix reproduction reviewed below.

Step-03B acceptance and corrected Step-03

Decision: ACCEPTED, 2026-10-28. Step-03B closes R-04; corrected Step-03 is accepted with Step-03A/Step-03B. No Step-03C is required.

Reviewed Step-03B, its report, phase-specific discovery/probe/identity models and aggregation, UI summary/rows/ guards, actual Simulation/DI/rendered regression tests, trace assertions and directly related protocol/simulation/ADR/README/testing documentation.

Criterion Decision Evidence
AC-01 ACCEPTED Valid positive probe and immutable services retained independently of optional identity result; unsupported/unavailable identity stays null with explicit phase reason
AC-02 ACCEPTED Expected/probed/identified counts distinct; partial UI preserves services and unknown identity; controls disabled and direct view-model guards emit no operation
AC-03 ACCEPTED Negative/malformed/mismatched/timed-out/cancelled identity preserves positive probe and its own trace; failed probe does not invent identity/services; close clears active presentation
AC-04 ACCEPTED Normal synthetic workflow, R-01/R-02/R-03, profile/target/state/oracle boundaries and nine-project graph retained; 175 prior cases included in 183
AC-05 ACCEPTED ON WORKER EXECUTION EVIDENCE Reported actual pre-fix phase-conflation failure; focused 35 passes; complete Release build zero warnings/errors; 111 unit + 72 integration passes, zero failed/skipped; native baseline observed
AC-06 ACCEPTED README/protocol/simulation/architecture/ADR/testing docs describe phase/count/action policy and native versus rendered evidence
AC-07 ACCEPTED Only scoped source/tests/docs/report work; previous assignments/reports and orchestration files preserved; no new project/package/workload action or future step

Chosen policy: a validated probe without advertised read.identity does not issue an unsupported identity request. Its probe/services remain available as claims; identity is explicitly not attempted and never populated from profile metadata. Identity-dependent actions stay fail-closed.

Worker-reported coverage: 183 passed (111 unit, 72 integration), zero failed/skipped. Native baseline covers explicit load/open, 3 expected/2 successful probes/2 identified modules, no-response, read/static signals/raw trace, verified clear, reset/close and old routes. Partial-identity faults/action guards/cancellation are real-DI/rendered test coverage, not claimed native fault coverage.

Static source counts, nine-project acyclic references and existing restore/ Release/native artifacts corroborate the report. No application build/test/ native/workload command was executed by the orchestrator.

Step-04 is prepared against the actual accepted interfaces. It assigns a separate explicit dynamics provider/configuration, fixed-step clock/model/scenario controls, configuration-preserving reset and versioned dynamic telemetry through diagnostics. The dynamics implementation now exists under review, still without any extra executable/project, physical integration or calibration programming.

Historical Step-04 review and corrective decision

Initial decision: REQUIRES CORRECTION, 2026-10-28. The original findings below describe pre-Step-04A code. At the follow-up, most were fixed but an overlap criterion still required Step-04B. The closing review below now accepts the corrected milestone.

Inspected the assignment, worker report, configuration/initial/model validation and fingerprinting, complete physics/ scenario/control implementation, dynamic provider and v2 binding, Application configuration/session paths, UI controls/status, all new unit/integration tests and related model/protocol/build documentation.

Criterion Review result Evidence / remaining work
AC-01 Present; reference correction required Immutable config/shape/fingerprint and profile binding exist; missing profile/module references can escape the import UI's handled exception contract
AC-02 NOT SATISFIED Progress resets at phase boundaries and async owner/active-pacer behavior lacks controlled proof; tests use wall delays/polling
AC-03 Present on inspected evidence Separate static/dynamics factories and exact original-config reset/session isolation implemented; no fallback or extra project
AC-04 NOT SATISFIED Initial and runtime locked-RPM/speed/gear consistency is not guaranteed across accepted inputs; independent force tests are absent
AC-05 Baseline passed per worker Default 650-rpm/45-MPH/full 300-s hold/stop/repeatability gates are meaningfully asserted; broader boundary inputs are not covered
AC-06 Present; fault policy correction required Actual strict v2 snapshots and static v1 compatibility exist; faulted/invalid model state must not become healthy success or an unhandled serialization failure
AC-07 Corrective lifecycle/status required Real controls/table/DI exist; faulted-run success notices, overwritten cancellation ownership and stale async publication require correction
AC-08 Existing suite passed per worker; insufficient coverage 115 unit + 75 integration passed, zero failed/skipped; complete Release/native and numerical baseline evidence supplied; review vectors not covered
AC-09 Corrective alignment required Equations/contracts/native guide present; operating envelope, fault/progress/clock ownership and corrected verification need documentation
AC-10 Report/preservation inspected Required report, nine-project scope and prior history preserved; no Step-05

Step-04 R-01 - Unhandled configuration reference errors

DynamicsConfigurationService.cs, line 68, selects the referenced profile inside Import but catches only JSON and argument exceptions. Missing profile/revision throws VehicleProfileCatalogException. DynamicsConfiguration.cs, line 340, uses GetModule and can throw KeyNotFoundException for a missing module. SimulationPageViewModel.cs, line 106, handles only DynamicsConfigurationException for import. Those valid JSON/invalid-reference inputs can therefore escape the ordinary visible-error path instead of leaving a usable page with actionable input feedback.

Step-04 R-02 - Unsupported or contradictory drivetrain states

Configuration checks RPM range/gear count but not redundant initial kinematics. For example a running first-gear state at 10 m/s and 650 rpm is accepted under the default ratios even though reset publishes zero slip and the wheel equation requires a different RPM. Reading before any step exposes the contradiction.

DynamicsEngine.cs, line 385, independently caps coupled RPM with Math.Min while leaving speed/gear and zero slip unchanged. Allowed high-speed/shift configurations can violate the promised locked equation. At line 368, a slipping condition caused by below-idle wheel RPM can also produce zero reported slip when speed exceeds a low configured launch threshold. Validation or truthful modeled limits/slip/failure must replace those healthy contradictory states, without gaming the default cruise gate.

Step-04 R-03 - Progress, terminal failures and async ownership

DynamicsEngine.cs, line 486, clears cumulative completed time immediately after adding the finished phase, so scenario progress drops at phase transitions.

SimulationPageViewModel.cs, line 204, reports every returned scenario status via SetSuccess, including Faulted; RefreshTelemetryAsync can overwrite the failure with another success. The run method also replaces its pending cancellation slot before rejecting a second runner, leaving the first runner no longer reachable through Cancel. Post-await status/data publication lacks the earlier diagnostic UI's current- session guard, so old work can update presentation during reset/close/reopen.

Finite/domain failures mutate engine fields before checking them. The producer can then read that failed snapshot and serialize positive Good telemetry; non-finite fields can instead escape as a serialization exception. A clear failed-run/last-valid-snapshot or typed negative policy is required.

The active pacer uses direct Task.Delay; the lifecycle test uses fixed wall delays and polling, and repeatability tests bypass the pacer. Add a controlled scheduler/ time seam and actual active-run pause/resume/stop/reset/restart/close and pacing tests, plus independent force/kinematic boundary evidence.

All findings are source/contract review, not orchestrator-executed failures. Worker baseline evidence remains historical: complete nine-project/native Release build zero warnings/errors; 115 unit + 75 integration passed; 3,361 equal samples, 10 s warm idle, 10.3 s acceleration, 3,000/3,000 cruise samples in band/coupled, 5.8 s braking and 10 s return idle, plus actual native workflow. These useful default results do not prove the missing boundary/failure/lifecycle cases. Source case counts, graph and existing artifacts corroborate the report.

Historical Step-04A review and focused follow-up

Decision at that review: most scope was satisfied, but existing R-03/AC-04 required Step-04B. The follow-up below has now closed that condition.

Reviewed Step-04A, its report, typed reference handling, initial/runtime coupling/limit guards and rollback, phase/ overall progress, terminal v2 failures, UI generations/cancellation ownership, actual controller/pacer code, independent numerical and controlled tests and docs.

Criterion Review result Evidence / remaining work
AC-01 Satisfied on inspected/reported evidence Missing profile/revision/module/calibration inputs are typed and atomic; rendered/native recoverable input errors reported
AC-02 Satisfied on inspected/reported evidence Initial coupled relation, redline validation/runtime guard, actual RPM-discrepancy slip and rollback; independent force/RPM boundary tests
AC-03 Satisfied on inspected/reported evidence Cumulative/phase progress corrected, fault snapshots rollback, negative DYNAMICS_RUN_FAULTED, persistent error and no healthy poisoned telemetry
AC-04 NOT YET SATISFIED Sequential controlled lifecycle and UI owner tests improved, but Start/Resume can mutate before rejecting an undrained advancement task
AC-05 Existing regressions/numerical gates retained Reported unchanged 3,361-sample baseline and all 190 cases within 202 passes; static/profile/wire/clear/discovery/source graph preserved
AC-06 Reported execution inspected Before-fix reference/coupling/progress failures, corrected focused runs, clean complete Release build, 122 unit + 80 integration passes and native smoke supplied
AC-07 Satisfied on inspected evidence Directly related model/config/lifecycle/v2/README/testing documentation updated
AC-08 Preservation/scope inspected Only scoped correction/source/tests/docs/report; no new project/package/workload action, orchestration/history edit or later step

Remaining existing criterion: reject before lifecycle mutation

DynamicsEngine.cs, StartOrResumeAsync around line 772 calls engine.Start/Resume before StartRunnerLocked checks its still-active task. StopRunnerAsync changes state, cancels the owner, releases the gate and then awaits its completion.

If Resume/Start arrives while that cleanup is pending, the engine can become Running and only then throw "already active". The cancelled old owner exits and the rejected command can leave Running without an owner. A rejected operation must wait under a documented policy or leave state unchanged; it cannot mutate first. Existing controlled tests await Pause/Stop/Reset before the next start/ resume, so the pending-transition overlap is absent.

This is a source/contract finding within the original Step-04A overlap/lifecycle criterion, not a new requirement introduced by the owner's process-improvement request. The orchestrator did not execute it; Step-04B requires a controlled pre-fix reproduction and is limited to this issue.

Worker-reported Step-04A results remain historical: full nine-project/native Release build zero warnings/errors; 122 unit + 80 integration passed (202 total, zero failed/skipped); unchanged default numerical gates, independent force equations, controlled pacing comparison and native input/fault/baseline smoke. Source counts, graph and existing artifacts corroborate that evidence; the orchestrator ran no application builds/tests/native/workload commands.

Step-04B acceptance and corrected Step-04

Decision: ACCEPTED, 2026-10-28. C-01 through C-05 and the remaining Step-04A criterion are satisfied; corrected Step-04/04A/04B are accepted. No Step-04C is required.

Reviewed Step-04B, its report, the shared owner precondition before all start mutations, complete controlled status/ sample assertions for pending pause/stop/reset, cleanup/retry/invalid/disposed cases, real SimulationPage service/UI rejection and documentation/self-review.

Criterion Decision Evidence
AC-01 ACCEPTED All frozen cases covered; EnsureNoActiveAdvancementOwner precedes engine.Start/Resume/scenario state changes, with defensive check retained at owner installation
AC-02 ACCEPTED Old task drains without holding its cleanup gate; rejection preserves full status/sample count; one retry advances once; real UI error never reports resumed success
AC-03 ACCEPTED ON WORKER EXECUTION EVIDENCE Reported complete Release build zero warnings/errors; 126 unit + 81 integration passes (207 total, zero failed/skipped), original numerical gates and native lifecycle/reset/telemetry smoke
AC-04 ACCEPTED C-01..C-05 matrix, actual pre-fix observations, source-path self-review and matching lifecycle/README/testing policy
AC-05 ACCEPTED Single-issue guard/tests/docs/report change, no new project/package/interface/physics/protocol; historical assignments/reports and orchestration files preserved

Worker source-path self-review explicitly walks precondition order, producer/ consumer callers, failure cleanup and barrier-finally behavior. The exact race is controlled unit/real-DI/UI evidence, not claimed human-timed native proof.

Static source case counts, nine-project acyclic references, restored assets, Release assemblies and native output corroborate the report. The orchestrator did not execute application builds/tests/native/workload commands.

Step-05 is prepared under the revised prospective policy: one user outcome, one acquisition-owner contract, numeric/bar rendering and validated in-memory configuration. No new persistence/wire format, clock/model, project or host. The frozen matrix states missing/uncertain/stale/range and source-lifetime outcomes before coding; future enhancements stay out of acceptance.

Prospective orchestration/process improvement

The owner requested fewer corrective handoffs through better planning/prompts. The revised roadmap policy and WORKER-QUALITY-GATE.md now require:

  • Smaller capability-complete assignments instead of several new subsystems/ state machines/formats in one handoff.
  • A compact agreed input/outcome/transition matrix before implementation.
  • Worker source-path self-review after the first green run, fixing issues inside the active assignment before COMPLETE.
  • Evidence mapped to exact cases/invariants, not test-count proxies.
  • One consolidated review against frozen criteria; new preferences are planned, not retroactively called defects.

The rules apply to new work beginning with Step-04B, not retroactively to Step-04A. No automated agents/handoffs or weaker quality bar is introduced. Step-01A was owner-driven architecture change, not an implementation-quality failure. Earlier technical cycles exposed contract/coverage and overlarge-scope gaps; orchestration shares responsibility for those gaps.

The Step-05 dashboard envelope remains limited to numeric/bar gauges, validated bindings/ranges/units and missing/stale states with one acquisition owner. Basic add/edit/remove controls are already assigned; advanced charts and layout designers stay later. Future broad calibration/AI/ hardware envelopes must be split before assignment if needed; history is not renumbered and corrective letters are not used for planned features.

Historical Step-05 review and required completion

Decision at that review: REQUIRES CORRECTION / NOT ACCEPTED, 2026-10-29. The returned report says PASSED with native smoke NOT EXECUTED. That is not satisfaction of Step-05 or its shared exit gate. Step-05A addresses only existing C-01..C-10/AC-01..AC-07; no new feature is assigned.

Reviewed all new dashboard models/acquisition/component code and tracked host/DI changes, actual diagnostic session cancellation/disposal, existing route tests, simulation host inventory, technical-document status, nine-project references and existing Release outputs. Source review identifies:

Finding Evidence Original contract
R-01 - incomplete/broken configured host workflow DiagnosticPageViewModel validates generated definitions before its fresh feed has read bindings; with no prior reads it starts empty and has no editor. Only Numeric defaults exist; simulation host is unwired. Start disables on any snapshot, including Stopped, and background refresh changes fields without a page render notification. C-01/C-04/C-10, required UI section, AC-01/AC-04
R-02 - owner/source lifetime Factory Create always returns a new independent feed. Its token is not session-linked. Close/reset stops but never clears/disposes the old feed/callback, so later startup reuses the old session; scope disposal is not implemented. Direct session close does not end the poll loop. C-05/C-06/C-07, AC-02
R-03 - false current data and failed cleanup Error feed state can still project cached positive data as Good; Stop rethrows a faulted owner, skipping the host's session-close/reset path. Latest unit changes are not compared to the definition, and the UI drops RangeState and sample context. C-02/C-03/C-08/C-09, AC-01/AC-02/AC-03
R-04 - unsafe/incomplete presentation Empty bar divs have no height/styles, so width alone cannot display a bar. Null percent becomes 0 and NaN can become a CSS width. Range/state/source-time presentation and accessible descriptions are incomplete. C-01/C-02/C-03/C-04, required component section, AC-01/AC-04
R-05 - unsupported completion claims Tests and technical docs/README are unchanged; no dashboard test references exist. Only the original 207 tests are reported, with no case-specific executions. Required native smoke is unexecuted, not out of scope. C-01..C-10, AC-05/AC-06/AC-07, shared gate
Original criterion Decision Evidence gap
AC-01 NOT ACCEPTED Some definition/number validation exists; assigned rendered states/editor and meaningful component tests do not
AC-02 NOT ACCEPTED Single loop per instance is not single owner per session; source/fault/cleanup paths are incomplete and untested
AC-03 NOT VERIFIED Source groups module reads, but no actual wire-count/v1-v2/paused-model dashboard test proves the criterion
AC-04 NOT ACCEPTED Generic dependency boundary is preserved, but real configured static/dynamic host workflow is incomplete
AC-05 PARTIAL / NOT ACCEPTED Worker reports zero-warning/error Release build and baseline 126 unit + 81 integration passes; no new dashboard tests, required native smoke NOT EXECUTED
AC-06 NOT SATISFIED No technical-document/README updates; claimed matrix/self-review lacks named assertions and executed cases
AC-07 PARTIAL / NOT ACCEPTED Prompt protection, historical reports and single-fenced report preserved; completion/coverage claims do not meet the exit contract

The nine-project graph remains acyclic with one Client executable and independent Components. Existing Release assemblies corroborate compilation artifacts only; they do not independently prove test execution or dashboard behavior. The orchestrator ran no application builds/tests/native/workload commands and did not execute these reproductions.

Preserve the returned report unchanged. Step-05A requires actual pre-fix failures for existing broken paths, completion of the already-assigned editor/static-dynamic integration, controlled source/owner/rendering tests and honest native evidence. If native execution is unavailable, report the exact blocker and INCOMPLETE/BLOCKED, not PASS or an acceptance waiver. At that review Step-06 denoted recording/replay. Its assignment was withheld. The owner decision below now inserts display units first.

Historical Step-05A review and focused follow-up

Decision at that review: most scope was corrected, but Step-05B was required for the remaining existing range/test obligations. The closing review below now accepts corrected Step-05/05A/05B. The new units request was not used as an acceptance criterion for these completed assignments.

Reviewed Step-05A report, all dashboard/session-lifetime/ host/component changes, all new dashboard tests and existing route assertions, technical-document/README changes, nine-project graph and existing Release outputs. Original scope decisions:

Area Decision Evidence
Host/editor/start/stop/live rendering Corrected on inspected evidence Same panel in diagnostics/simulation; actual feed discovers choices before edit; state-based actions; dispatcher subscription and rendered cycle-2 assertion
Single owner/session/visibility lifetime Corrected on inspected evidence Session-keyed shared factory, registered session resource, cancel-before-drain/disposal, direct close/scope/late-response tests and widget-independent polling
Fault/unit/context/presentation Mostly corrected; range edge remains Terminal error yields Stale/Error; cleanup continues; unit/origin changes rejected; visible safe geometry and source/time context. Uncertain branch omits range projection.
Tests/build/native/docs Substantial evidence supplied; test gaps remain Worker reports 133 unit + 91 integration passes, zero failed/skipped, clean full Release build; actual static/dynamic native workflows and final rebuilt-Client recheck; new usage/docs
Protected workflow/history/dependencies Preserved on inspected evidence Nine acyclic projects, one Client, independent Components; original assignments/reports and orchestration files retained; no dependency/system change reported

Remaining findings, limited to existing criteria:

  1. R-01: In CreateGaugeValueLocked, Uncertain values call CreateValue without GetRangeState. CreateValue does not derive range from that quality, so -10/1100 over 0..1000 has no low/high label. Existing Step-05 C-02/C-03 and Step-05A R-03 require independent quality/range.
  2. R-02: The invalid-definition test covers unit/span overflow/count but not the full originally required C-04 bounds/precision/kind/ID/source vectors. Non-finite geometry tests set Unknown/--, so they pass without exercising the finite-percent guard. The controlled Stop-drain test releases its barrier and session only after assertions, not in finally as the existing gate requires.

These are source/test-inspection findings; the orchestrator executed no runtime reproduction, application build/test, native launch or workload command. The reported 224 cases preserve the prior 207 and add seven unit plus ten integration cases. Existing assemblies and case inventory corroborate the report, not independent execution or missing matrix assertions.

Native evidence now explicitly covers static 850 rpm/85% bar, invalid range/unit, editor/hide/remove/stop/restart/reset/close; actual v2 time/config/run context, explicit stepping and paused polls not advancing physics; old routes and a final-build static/dynamic cycle-1/close recheck. Preserve this positive evidence. Do not redo corrected features or add conversion work to Step-05B.

Step-05B acceptance and corrected Step-05

Decision: ACCEPTED, 2026-10-29. Frozen C-01..C-05 and AC-01..AC-05 are satisfied. Step-05 with Step-05A/05B is accepted; no Step-05C is required.

Reviewed Step-05B, its report, the focused projection diff, actual real-provider/rendered range tests, independent invalid definition vectors, isolated finite-percent assertions, finally/async cleanup, documentation and existing Release/native artifacts.

Criterion Decision Evidence
AC-01 ACCEPTED Actual pre-fix Uncertain -10 expected OutOfRangeLow/actual null; shared helper now supplies range without changing quality/value; real numeric/bar low/high and exact-bound assertions
AC-02 ACCEPTED Independent invalid bounds/precision/kind/ID/label/source/unit/count vectors assert exact prior snapshot/source/Running state; Good numeric percent-only null/NaN/infinities test and actual 85% width/accessibility control
AC-03 ACCEPTED Stop-drain finally releases its barrier before awaiting cleanup; session disposal is protected on failed assertions; other new session tests use async lifetime cleanup
AC-04 ACCEPTED ON WORKER EXECUTION EVIDENCE Reported complete nine-project Release build zero warnings/errors; 134 unit + 91 integration passes (225 total, zero failed/skipped); rebuilt native static-v1 bar/dynamics-v2 numeric baseline and close recheck
AC-05 ACCEPTED Focused projection/tests/verification-doc change and single corrective report; no future feature/dependency/project/interface/physics/wire expansion; original assignments/history preserved

Worker self-review maps finite-value validation through independent quality/ range to actual numeric/bar consumers and safe test cleanup. Native observations are distinguished from controlled Uncertain/invalid-input proof; no production fault selector or fabricated native fault claim was introduced.

Source case inventory, unchanged nine-project acyclic references and existing Release outputs corroborate the report. The orchestrator ran no application builds/tests/native/workload commands and did not execute the reproduction.

Original Step-05 findings and its Step-05A follow-up are closed. Preserve the 207-/224-/225-case reports and original dynamics numerical/native history. At that acceptance Step-06 was prepared for new display units, with one shared preference/conversion contract and explicit editor/raw-data invariants. Its returned implementation is reviewed below.

Owner decision - imperial-default display units

The owner approves a Metric / Imperial toggle with Imperial (US) default while keeping all internal calculations in SI. This is a new presentation requirement, not a Step-05A defect. It must be implemented before recording/replay.

The dated roadmap contract inserts the next major Step-06 for display units and shifts only former unassigned Steps 06-20 to 07-21. At that decision the combined recording/replay envelope became Step-07. The prospective split below now separates recording and playback. Completed history and original assignments/reports keep their existing numbering.

Intended display defaults: mph for normal vehicle speed (ft/s engineering option), ft lengths, lb mass, lb/h fuel mass rate, lbf*ft torque, degF temperature and ft/s^2 acceleration. Metric counterparts include km/h or m/s as appropriate. RPM/volts/ratios/booleans/counts remain unchanged. Preserve source/SI values in physics/config/wire/raw views; use one shared presentation conversion path with explicit source versus display units. Convert gauge labels/editor bounds without changing canonical physical bounds, quality, range or acquisition/model ownership.

First use is Imperial (US); retain an explicitly saved local choice across navigation/restarts. Unsupported units remain explicitly unconverted, and no fuel mass-to-volume conversion may invent density. Apply consistently across current human-facing simulation/diagnostic/dashboard surfaces.

Following Step-05B acceptance, Step-06 assigned the two unit systems plus Road/Engineering speed presentation, first-use/saved/error behavior, exact conversion vectors and stable source-unit gauge bounds. Its implementation now exists and is accepted after Step-06A below. The default and unit mappings remain approved and unchanged.

Historical Step-06 review and focused correction

Decision at that review: REQUIRES FOCUSED CORRECTION / NOT ACCEPTED, 2026-10-30. Reviewed Step-06, its report, all new conversion/ preference/native-store/presentation code, changed shell/host/editor paths, new unit and actual-provider tests, docs, nine-project references and artifacts.

Positive evidence: exact forward/inverse mappings and rounding, Imperial/Road default, explicit stored/corrupt/read/write states at the service boundary, real MAUI adapter, pinned native editor behavior, 20 controlled toggles preserving actual source/canonical/model/trace bytes and no extra reads. Worker reports clean nine-project Release build, 178 unit + 92 integration passes (270 total, zero failed/skipped), real native four-mode speed/range/editor/route smoke and saved preference restoration. Existing artifacts/case inventory corroborate that report, not independent orchestrator execution.

Finding Evidence Original contract
R-01 - incomplete rejection boundary TrySet calls Initialize before checking IsValid; a fresh invalid request can load/change selection/initialized state. MainLayout uses plain value/onchange for both selectors, so rejected browser selection is not bound back to the unchanged service value. Existing negative tests initialize first and test service state, not the failed control event/DOM state. C-09, section A reject-before-any-state/store-mutation, AC-01/AC-03/AC-04
R-02 - unavailable/non-numeric readout bypass DisplayUnitPresentation echoes JsonElement.ToString for every non-number or sourceText when NumericValue is absent. Null can be blank, wrong-type numeric values are echoed as normal readings, unsupported-unit text has no notice, and callers omit source quality when projecting Unknown numerics. The gauge path handles placeholders, but diagnostics/simulation readout paths do not apply the same contract. C-07/C-08/C-10, section C all assigned surfaces, AC-02/AC-03/AC-04
Original criterion Decision Evidence/gap
AC-01 PARTIAL / NOT ACCEPTED Default/restoration/native storage work; fresh-invalid and failed-selector rejection are not fully atomic
AC-02 PARTIAL / NOT ACCEPTED Exact numeric vectors/inverses/rounding supported; non-numeric/unavailable paths bypass validation/notice
AC-03 PARTIAL / NOT ACCEPTED Source/bounds/draft and Good-speed toggle evidence supported; rejection and all-surface Unknown/missing outcomes remain unmet
AC-04 PARTIAL / NOT ACCEPTED Current surfaces are wired and raw data retained; primary readouts need consistent unavailable handling
AC-05 WORKER EXECUTION EVIDENCE REVIEWED Reported 270 passes/clean Release/native smoke are preservation/positive evidence; they do not prove the missing negative paths
AC-06 PARTIAL / NOT ACCEPTED Docs/report/self-review exist; C-07/C-09 claims need decisive event/readout evidence in the corrective report
AC-07 PRESERVATION SUPPORTED Original prompts/history/shared gate, nine projects/references and protected files preserved; no later step or package/system change reported

The static-v1 contract permits null/non-numeric JSON signal values; these do reach the diagnostics display helper. Dynamic v2 remains strictly typed and must not be weakened to create test inputs. Valid boolean false and numeric zero must remain distinct from unavailable readings.

The official Blazor binding guidance confirms why event-handler-only value attributes do not guarantee DOM/model reconciliation after rejection. This is source/framework evidence, not a claim that the orchestrator ran the failing native interaction.

No application builds/tests/native/workload commands or runtime reproductions were executed by the orchestrator. Preserve Step-06-Report.md unchanged. At that review Step-06A was limited to those findings and Step-07 was withheld. The closing review below accepts the corrected milestone.

Step-06A acceptance and corrected Step-06

Decision: ACCEPTED, 2026-10-30. Frozen C-01..C-07 and AC-01..AC-05 are satisfied. Step-06 with Step-06A is accepted; no Step-06B is required.

Reviewed Step-06A, its report, the actual guard/typed-error and get/set selector changes, shared JSON/scalar/quality projection and callers, all new control/readout/provider/state tests, docs, unchanged nine-project references and existing Release outputs.

Criterion Decision Evidence
AC-01 ACCEPTED Invalid proposal is checked before initialization/read/write; exact unchanged state/zero store-call assertions; both actual binding callbacks reject failed saves and recover with aligned controls/cascaded readout
AC-02 ACCEPTED Real static-v1 route and shared helper cover null/wrong type/Unknown/unsupported text/zero/false with exact source context; real-feed converted Uncertain/Stale/Stopped/unavailable projection preserves state/range/time
AC-03 ACCEPTED ON WORKER EXECUTION EVIDENCE Reported complete nine-project Release build zero warnings/errors; 179 unit + 105 integration passes (284 total, zero failed/skipped); isolated rebuilt native default/four-mode/editor/restored-Metric/close smoke
AC-04 ACCEPTED Actual fresh-service and presentation pre-fix failures, honest framework-event versus native fault distinction, source-path self-review and aligned docs/README
AC-05 ACCEPTED Focused source/tests/docs/report scope; original assignments/reports, unit constants, defaults, source contracts, dependencies and manual workflow preserved

No separate pre-fix native DOM failure or native storage-fault injection is claimed. The corrected framework-supported binding plus actual callback/render tests establish the assigned reconciliation path. Native positive behavior is reported separately. The 14 added cases comprise one unit and 13 integration; all 270 original cases remain in the 284-case report.

The orchestrator ran no application builds/tests/native/workload commands and did not execute the reproductions. Source inventory, graph and existing outputs corroborate worker evidence, not independent runtime verification.

Prospective telemetry split and Step-07 handoff

The former combined recording/replay envelope would introduce capture ownership, archive storage and a playback clock in one assignment. Apply the existing bounded-scope policy before execution:

  • Step-07: actual session observation capture with a bounded in-memory owner, explicit stop/limits, source-faithful save and strict archive readback.
  • Step-08: recorded playback/seek/speed feeding shared presentation, without querying a live source or rerunning physics. Not assigned yet.
  • Former unassigned Steps 08-21 become 09-22, preserving all later capability/ authorization gates and all completed numbering/history.

Step-07 freezes the capture window, loss/close/reentry outcomes, exact count/size limits and strict archive/I/O semantics. No polling of the 200-entry UI trace, hidden new acquisition loop or display-unit data rewrite is allowed. Recording remains in memory until explicit save after Stop; no crash-durable/live-streaming or unlimited-duration claim is made. The next review must not demand the deferred Step-08 playback controls.

Step-07 review and required correction

Decision: REQUIRES CORRECTION / NOT ACCEPTED, 2026-10-30. Reviewed Step-07, its report, all observation/ capture/workspace/codec/filesystem/UI changes, actual new integration tests, related docs/README, source lifetime registration, graph and Release artifacts.

Positive evidence includes real observations beyond the UI buffer, actual per-operation raw/decoded association, separate capture/diagnostic/model time, exact count/header/observation/file limits, explicit memory-only/partial states, real file readback and native retained capture after route unmount. Worker reports clean complete nine-project Release build and 179 unit + 124 integration passes (303 total, zero failed/skipped), preserving all 284 prior cases and adding 19 integration cases.

Finding Evidence Original contract
R-01 - valid source observations rejected Codec requires bytes for ProtocolError even when the real source recorded null for an empty reply. Codec uses Ordinal trace/snapshot/envelope identity comparisons where the source client accepts case-insensitive identities; a valid uppercase endpoint module can therefore fail save. C-02/C-04/C-08, AC-01/AC-03
R-02 - invalid archive boundary incomplete Positive read.signals with signalSnapshot null calls ValidateSignalResponse before the required association check and dereferences null. Consistent edits to raw/decoded v2 values are not checked against known IDs/unit/type rules; duplicate IDs and negative model time also lack equivalent guards. C-09, strict typed/context validation, AC-03
R-03 - capture retention and failure-safe teardown SessionTelemetryCapture.Start registers each capture with the session, but stop/discard/replacement never unregister it. DiagnosticSession retains those objects/buffers until source disposal, defeating bounded in-memory history across repeated captures. The blocking Stop test lacks finally release before observer disposal. C-05/C-06/C-07, testing cleanup requirement, AC-02/AC-05
R-04 - storage failure visibility ListAsync returns an empty list for an existing file used as root. The panel unconditionally RefreshAsync after workspace SaveAsync catches a failure; refresh clears Error and replaces failure status with a healthy catalogue message. C-10/C-11, AC-03/AC-04
Original criterion Decision Evidence/gap
AC-01 PARTIAL / NOT ACCEPTED Actual observation tap/order/time/raw data is supported; valid error/case-variant captures do not all round-trip
AC-02 PARTIAL / NOT ACCEPTED Exact limits and source-close retention are supported; repeated-capture resource release and failed-assertion cleanup are not
AC-03 NOT ACCEPTED Real atomic save/readback works on tested positive paths; typed null handling/v2 semantic consistency/catalogue failure classification remain deficient
AC-04 PARTIAL / NOT ACCEPTED Native capture/save/restart/load and cross-scope retention supported; failed save errors can disappear in the actual panel flow
AC-05 WORKER EXECUTION EVIDENCE REVIEWED Reported 303 passes/clean Release/native smoke are positive preservation evidence, not proof of the untested negative paths
AC-06 PARTIAL / NOT ACCEPTED Docs/report/self-review exist; strict validation/bounded lifetime/visible I/O claims require the corrective evidence
AC-07 PRESERVATION SUPPORTED Original prompts/history/shared gate, nine projects/references and protected files preserved; no playback, package or later-step changes reported

Native evidence separately reports static seven-operation and dynamic two-read archives, source close/unmount retention, app restart/load/inspection and unchanged Metric preference. The worker removed only its two named archive IDs and exact temporary WebView profiles; its LOCALAPPDATA override did not isolate MAUI's recordings root, and that limitation is explicitly disclosed.

The worker also reports an initial NETSDK1112 missing Windows runtime pack: project-scoped Client restore for win-x64 resolved that genuine missing dependency, then the required --no-restore build passed. No workload/system repair/update or manifest/project/package change was reported or authorized by this review.

All findings above are source/test-inspection evidence. The orchestrator executed no application build/test, native launch or failing reproduction. Preserve the returned report unchanged. Step-07A consolidates the four existing requirements; Step-08 remains blocked and no replay assignment is created.

Prerequisites, limitations, and known issues

  • Step-01A worker evidence establishes portable and native Windows compatibility for the accepted foundation. Recheck prerequisites if the environment changes.
  • No major SDK/workload/driver installation has been authorized. Report exact missing prerequisites and mark blocked checks honestly; do not replace .NET 10 MAUI Blazor Hybrid with a web host.
  • Reported workload incident: dotnet workload restore was mistakenly invoked during inspection, began manifest updates and was stopped. Worker reports workload version 10.0.403 and newer iOS/MacCatalyst manifests; Windows manifest stayed 10.0.110. No rollback occurred. Final Windows checks passed, but broader impact is unverified. Do not repeat workload-changing commands or repair/rollback without explicit authorization; this review does not authorize them.
  • Historical Step-01A raw git diff --check failed on README CRLF, against a mixed-line-ending index. Read-only byte inspection found 151 CRLF lines and no trailing spaces/tabs. A command-local CR-at-EOL-aware check passed, with no Git configuration changed. Step-02 resolved working-file normalization: 149 LF and zero CRLF lines observed; the CR-at-EOL-aware diff check passes with no global settings changed.
  • Step-02 worker reports no workload-changing command was invoked; prior incident remains historical and does not authorize future installation/update/rollback.
  • Profile Step-02 R-01/R-02 remain closed and accepted; do not regress those fixes.
  • Step-03 R-01/R-02/R-03/R-04 remain closed; preserve all correction invariants.
  • Step-04 reference/coupling/progress/failure/UI/owner fixes are accepted with Step-04B. Step-05's original and follow-up findings are closed. Preserve the 190-/ 202-/207-case reports and original numerical/native evidence distinctly.
  • Profile metadata/UI, synthetic diagnostics, deterministic dynamics/v2 and the corrected dashboard/display units are accepted. Recording/archive exists but is unaccepted. Replay, calibration values, AI and physical hardware operations remain unimplemented.
  • No application build or test has been executed by the orchestrator.

Review and progression gate

On manual return, evaluate Step-07A and the original Step-07 capture/archive contract/shared gate using the assignment, worker report, actual code/tests, dependency graph, Git changes, README/docs, and recorded build/test evidence. Do not accept solely on a success claim; do not claim independent runtime verification.

  • Inspect valid-source round trips, typed/strict archive rejection, bounded lifetime release/finally cleanup and actual panel/catalogue failure visibility. Preserve prior positive capture/native evidence; no new playback requirements.
  • If accepted: close Step-07A, accept corrected Step-07, update roadmap/state, prepare Step-08 replay and stop for manual handoff.
  • If deficient: issue narrowly scoped Step-07B only for a material unmet contract/ regression, then stop. Planned new features are not corrections.
  • If blocked: retain the active step, document the prerequisite and required worker evidence; do not advance or mark unexecuted checks as successful.
  • Never create the next major assignment while acceptance or corrections are open.

History

Date Event Evidence / result
2026-10-28 Initial repository inspection Clean main; only root README and ignore file tracked; no application or protected instruction files found
2026-10-28 Initial roadmap, state, and Step-01 prepared Amendment layout/naming adopted; READY FOR WORKER, no implementation accepted
2026-10-28 User returned Step-01 for review Original assignment, worker report, code/tests, configuration, Git changes and documentation inspected
2026-10-28 Step-01 ACCEPTED No blocking deficiency; worker evidence reports successful Release build and 54 passed, zero failed/skipped tests; no orchestrator runtime execution
2026-10-28 Step-02 prepared Profile/module model, versioned JSON, synthetic fixtures and application selection; manual worker handoff pending
2026-10-28 Owner architecture decision superseded the dual-shell plan One MAUI Client, UI/Components RCLs, vertical-slice modular monolith; Step-01 acceptance preserved but corrective 01A required
2026-10-28 Existing solution re-inspected Only four headless projects; no obsolete hosts to delete; no application changes/builds/tests executed
2026-10-28 Step-01A prepared; Step-02 placed on hold Correction is ready for manual worker execution; old Step-02 body retained, final regeneration deferred until correction acceptance
2026-10-28 Step-01A returned and ACCEPTED Seven-project single-shell/RCL/VSA implementation inspected; worker reports successful solution/native builds, 65 passing cases and native route/asset checks
2026-10-28 Deviations recorded Unintended workload manifest updates disclosed; no rollback; README CRLF-only diff hygiene noted for next documentation update
2026-10-28 Step-02 regenerated Explicitly supersedes unexecuted pre-correction version; actual seven-project baseline and profile feature/UI scope; READY FOR WORKER
2026-10-28 Step-02 returned for review Profile models/codec/catalog/UI, tests/fixtures/docs and reported 93-case/native verification inspected
2026-10-28 Step-02 requires correction R-01 ambient-dependent timestamp parser and R-02 absent optional applicability constraints; passing reported tests do not cover them
2026-10-28 Step-02A prepared Narrow correction with worker regressions/documentation/native checks; Step-03 blocked and not assigned
2026-10-28 Step-02A returned and ACCEPTED Parser/constraint fixes and direct/DI/UI/native evidence reviewed; 103 unit + 37 integration passes and clean Release build reported
2026-10-28 Corrected Step-02 ACCEPTED R-01/R-02 closed; prior 93-case and corrective 140-case reports preserved; no Step-02B
2026-10-28 Step-03 prepared Explicit simulated sessions, virtual modules, synthetic protocol/read-clear/telemetry/trace and deterministic faults; manual handoff pending
2026-10-28 Step-03 returned for review Nine-project protocol/provider/session/UI path and reported 161-case/native verification inspected
2026-10-28 Step-03 requires correction Missing/ambiguous wire fields, semantic positive replies/false-positive probe trace, and clear acknowledgement treated as verification
2026-10-28 Step-03A prepared Narrow correction with pre-fix regressions, state/trace/UI verification and documentation; Step-04 blocked
2026-10-28 Step-03A returned; scoped corrections ACCEPTED R-01/R-02/R-03 fixed; actual pre-fix failures, clean Release build, 175-case passing run and native baseline inspected
2026-10-28 Additional Step-03 finding R-04 Valid positive probe is discarded from responder count/service evidence when identity is unavailable; not covered by current tests
2026-10-28 Step-03B prepared Preserve phase-specific probe/identity facts and truthful counts without relaxing identity-dependent action gates; Step-04 remains blocked
2026-10-28 Step-03B returned and ACCEPTED R-04 closed; phase/count/guard/trace source and reported 183-case/native evidence inspected
2026-10-28 Corrected Step-03 ACCEPTED All R-01/R-02/R-03/R-04 closed; normal and partial diagnostics, wire integrity and verified clear retained
2026-10-28 Step-04 prepared Fixed-step coupled dynamics, explicit configuration/control and dynamic diagnostic telemetry; manual worker handoff pending
2026-10-28 Step-04 returned for review Model/config/controller/provider/UI and reported 190-case/numerical/native evidence inspected
2026-10-28 Step-04 requires correction Missing-reference handling, drivetrain boundary states and failed/progress/async lifecycle gaps; baseline drive cycle itself reports all numeric gates met
2026-10-28 Step-04A prepared Narrow correctness and controlled-proof correction; Step-05 blocked and not assigned
2026-10-28 Step-04A returned for review Reference/coupling/progress/failure/UI fixes and reported 202-case/native evidence inspected; pending owner-drain transition remains
2026-10-28 Owner requested orchestration reassessment Prospective scope sizing, frozen contract/evidence matrices and worker self-review gate introduced; no retrospective criteria
2026-10-28 Step-04B prepared Single existing reject-before-mutate overlap; no physics/protocol/new feature scope; Step-05 remains blocked
2026-10-28 Step-04B returned and ACCEPTED Frozen C-01..C-05 satisfied; guard ordering, before/after status/state tests, real UI, self-review and reported 207-case/native evidence inspected
2026-10-28 Corrected Step-04 ACCEPTED Original and 04A/04B criteria closed; source and numerical history preserved; no 04C
2026-10-28 Step-05 prepared Bounded numeric/bar dashboard with one acquisition owner, in-memory validated bindings and frozen data/lifecycle matrix; manual handoff pending
2026-10-29 Step-05 returned and reviewed Partial Application feed and generic gauge/diagnostic wiring; same 207 baseline passes/clean Release build reported; required native smoke not executed
2026-10-29 Step-05 requires correction Consolidated R-01..R-05: host/editor/startup, session owner/lifetime, fault/data truth, generic rendering, missing tests/docs/native evidence; no new acceptance criteria
2026-10-29 Step-05A prepared Complete original frozen contract and worker self-review before manual return; Step-04 remains accepted and Step-06 blocked
2026-10-29 Step-05A returned and reviewed Real shared editor/panel/session owner, safe gauges, 17 new cases/docs and worker-reported 224-case/clean Release/native evidence inspected
2026-10-29 Focused Step-05B required Existing Uncertain low/high independence and decisive boundary-test/finally-cleanup obligations remain; no new product scope
2026-10-29 Owner approved imperial-default display units SI calculations unchanged; global metric/Imperial (US) preference and conversions must precede recording/replay; not a Step-05A acceptance change
2026-10-29 Future numbering updated Display units inserted as unassigned Step-06; former unassigned 06-20 become 07-21; completed assignments/history preserved
2026-10-29 Step-05B prepared Narrow range/test correction only; next major handoff is units after dashboard acceptance, not recording/replay
2026-10-29 Step-05B returned and ACCEPTED Frozen range/test/cleanup matrix satisfied; actual red regression, 225-case/clean Release/native recheck evidence and source-path self-review inspected
2026-10-29 Corrected Step-05 ACCEPTED Original and 05A/05B criteria closed; no 05C; reports/source/numerical history preserved
2026-10-29 Step-06 prepared Imperial-default shared presentation preference/conversions, stable canonical source bounds and explicit editor/raw-data policy; manual handoff pending, Step-07 blocked
2026-10-30 Step-06 returned and reviewed Exact conversion/default/native persistence/editor/source-invariance paths and reported 270-case/clean Release/native evidence inspected
2026-10-30 Step-06 requires focused correction R-01 fresh-invalid initialization and failed-selector reconciliation; R-02 null/non-numeric/Unknown display bypass; original C-07/C-08/C-09, not new product scope
2026-10-30 Step-06A prepared Narrow rejection/readout correction with real pre-fix/event/provider tests; preserve approved imperial defaults/mappings, no Step-07
2026-10-30 Step-06A returned and ACCEPTED Frozen rejection/readout contract satisfied; actual regressions, binding callbacks, real provider/readout states and reported 284-case/clean Release/isolated native evidence inspected
2026-10-30 Corrected Step-06 ACCEPTED Original and 06A criteria closed; Imperial default/metric options/source invariants preserved; no 06B
2026-10-30 Telemetry envelope split prospectively Step-07 bounded recording/archive, Step-08 replay; former unassigned 08-21 become 09-22; no completed history renumbered
2026-10-30 Step-07 prepared Single capture-owner outcome, strict source-faithful archive/readback and explicit limits; no playback clock, manual handoff pending
2026-10-30 Step-07 returned and reviewed Real observer/capture/archive/UI implementation and reported 303-case/clean Release/native save/restart/readback/unmount evidence inspected
2026-10-30 Step-07 requires correction Four original-scope findings: valid-source round trips, typed/strict archive semantics, released-capture retention/test cleanup, and catalogue/panel I/O visibility
2026-10-30 Step-07A prepared Consolidated corrective matrix with real pre-fix/negative/lifecycle/panel evidence; prior recording/unit/source behavior preserved and replay blocked

Manual handoff instruction

Provide Step-07A.md, original Step-07.md and the shared worker gate to the separate worker and request execution of the correction only. The worker must produce prompts/Step-07A-Report.md and stop for review. Do not begin Step-08 replay. Return manually to the orchestrator for review. Reports, including final chat reports, must follow the single plain triple-backtick copy-window requirement.