893 lines
69 KiB
Markdown
893 lines
69 KiB
Markdown
# AutoForge orchestration state
|
|
|
|
## Current handoff
|
|
|
|
| Field | Value |
|
|
|---|---|
|
|
| Updated | 2026-10-29 |
|
|
| Phase | Corrected dashboard accepted; imperial-default display units next |
|
|
| Active step | Step-06 - Imperial-default metric/imperial display units |
|
|
| Assignment | [Step-06.md](Step-06.md) |
|
|
| Assignment status | READY FOR WORKER / AWAITING MANUAL HANDOFF |
|
|
| Expected worker report | `prompts/Step-06-Report.md` - not yet created |
|
|
| Last accepted correction | Step-05B - accepted 2026-10-29 |
|
|
| Last accepted major milestone | Step-05 with Step-05A/Step-05B - accepted 2026-10-29 |
|
|
| Outstanding corrections | None |
|
|
| Step-02 status | ACCEPTED after Step-02A |
|
|
| Step-03 status | ACCEPTED after Step-03A/Step-03B |
|
|
| Step-04 status | ACCEPTED after Step-04A/Step-04B |
|
|
| Step-04A review | All original corrective criteria closed with Step-04B |
|
|
| Step-05 status | ACCEPTED after Step-05A/Step-05B |
|
|
| Step-05A review | All original corrective criteria closed with Step-05B |
|
|
| Step-06 status | READY FOR WORKER; Imperial (US) first-use default with metric toggle |
|
|
| Step-07 status | Recording/replay, formerly Step-06; BLOCKED until display-unit work is accepted |
|
|
| Worker execution | Step-05B returned and accepted; Step-06 not invoked |
|
|
| Immediate next action | User manually directs the worker to execute Step-06 and shared quality gate only |
|
|
| Next orchestrator action | After manual return, inspect the assignment, report, implementation, tests, Git changes, documentation and recorded command evidence |
|
|
|
|
## Repository baseline at initialization
|
|
|
|
- Repository: `D:\_Repos\Code\GAJ3T\AutoForge`.
|
|
- Branch observed: `main`, tracking `origin/main`.
|
|
- Initial worktree: clean.
|
|
- Initial tracked files: root `README.md` and `.gitignore`.
|
|
- No existing solution, projects, tests, `docs`, `src`, or `prompts` were present.
|
|
- No applicable `AGENTS.md` was found in the repository or its ancestor locations.
|
|
- No `.github` instruction files were found. In particular,
|
|
`.github/copilot-instructions.md` was absent and must remain absent.
|
|
- Existing README describes the product vision, not verified implemented features;
|
|
Step-01 requires preserving it while making implementation status explicit.
|
|
- Existing `.gitignore` already includes common Visual Studio/.NET build patterns.
|
|
Worker must extend only where necessary and preserve existing entries.
|
|
- Initial orchestrator changes were limited to `prompts/ROADMAP.md`, this file,
|
|
and `prompts/Step-01.md`. Step-01 subsequently added the implementation below.
|
|
|
|
## Architecture decisions in force
|
|
|
|
See [ROADMAP.md](ROADMAP.md) for the full planned architecture and milestones.
|
|
|
|
1. The repository has only three top-level project directories: `docs`, `src`,
|
|
`prompts`; existing protected infrastructure is preserved. Tests are under
|
|
`src/tests`. No root `tests`, root `artifacts`, or nested `AutoForge` directory.
|
|
2. Keep the existing single `src/AutoForge.slnx`, Core, Application, UnitTests and
|
|
IntegrationTests. Accepted target-selection code/tests remain useful.
|
|
3. Sole initial application executable: AutoForge.Client, .NET 10 MAUI Blazor
|
|
Hybrid, initially Windows. No required standalone WebAssembly/web shell or
|
|
separate backend. Ordinary desktop capabilities run in-process as a modular
|
|
monolith; additional hosts/processes need a concrete approved requirement.
|
|
4. Accepted Step-01A established Client -> UI -> Components. Client is thin native startup,
|
|
BlazorWebView and DI/lifecycle/platform composition. UI owns complete routes,
|
|
pages, navigation/layouts and feature presentation. Components owns generic
|
|
reusable controls. UI cannot reference Client; Components cannot reference UI.
|
|
5. Application is needed now and retained. Organize use cases into cohesive feature
|
|
slices, beginning with existing execution-target selection. No mediator,
|
|
generic repository/manager layer, prescribed boilerplate or empty future slices.
|
|
UI invokes application contracts; business logic stays outside Razor components.
|
|
6. Reusable domain, simulation, diagnostic, calibration, telemetry and AI capability
|
|
libraries remain independently testable and are added only when justified.
|
|
They do not depend on Client/UI or their coordinating application slices.
|
|
Hardware, inference, storage and UI implementations never own domain truth.
|
|
7. Simulation, replay, and physical hardware targets are explicit and cannot
|
|
silently substitute for one another. Selection is not connection or execution.
|
|
8. Synthetic data is labeled; simulation is deterministic and independent of AI,
|
|
and verification uses an isolated oracle unavailable to ordinary UI/AI paths.
|
|
9. AI plans are validated runbooks; no arbitrary hardware commands or offsets.
|
|
Local inference is replaceable; core operation does not require AI/cloud.
|
|
10. Initial hardware integration is read-only. Simulated approval, physical
|
|
capability discovery, and driver availability cannot authorize physical writes.
|
|
Bench and vehicle programming require separate future authorization/evidence.
|
|
11. All handoffs are manual. Orchestrator never invokes the worker, implements
|
|
application changes, or executes application builds/tests.
|
|
12. The worker does not change the roadmap, state, or assignment; it may write only
|
|
the current assignment's report under `prompts`. No automatic commits/pushes.
|
|
|
|
## Historical Step-01 acceptance review
|
|
|
|
Decision at that review: **ACCEPTED**, 2026-10-28, with no identified blocking
|
|
defect under the then-current architecture. This acceptance and its evidence
|
|
remain historical facts. The later owner decision now requires Step-01A before
|
|
progression; it does not erase the accepted implementation or its reports.
|
|
|
|
Reviewed [Step-01](Step-01.md), the [worker report](Step-01-Report.md), all seven
|
|
production source files, all three test source files, four project files, solution,
|
|
five root configuration files, README/ignore diffs and all four technical documents.
|
|
The source enforces explicit identity/kind selection, case-insensitive uniqueness,
|
|
no cross-target fallback, immutable descriptors and registration snapshots.
|
|
Integration tests exercise the real DI/Core/Application path rather than mocks.
|
|
|
|
| Criterion | Decision | Evidence |
|
|
|---|---|---|
|
|
| AC-01 | ACCEPTED | Expected README/ignore changes only among pre-existing implementation files; empty index; original assignment/roadmap/state hashes matched the report before orchestration updates; protected instructions absent |
|
|
| AC-02 | ACCEPTED | Actual root project directories are docs/src/prompts; tests under src/tests; no root tests/artifacts or nested repository |
|
|
| AC-03 | ACCEPTED | Inspected solution and all project references: Core has none; Application -> Core; both test projects -> Core/Application; all net10.0 |
|
|
| AC-04 | ACCEPTED | Inspected SDK policy, nullable/build/editor settings, central package pins and assets; worker records installed SDK 10.0.402 and actual VSTest execution |
|
|
| AC-05 | ACCEPTED | Descriptor/resolver/DI source satisfies explicit validation, uniqueness, snapshot and no-fallback requirements; no production provider is fabricated |
|
|
| AC-06 | ACCEPTED | All composition tests inspected; real container/service path covers positive selection and empty/invalid/mismatched/duplicate cases |
|
|
| AC-07 | ACCEPTED ON WORKER EXECUTION EVIDENCE | Reported final Release build: zero warnings/errors; unit 35/35, integration 19/19, zero failures/skips; source case counts and existing restore/Release outputs corroborate the report |
|
|
| AC-08 | ACCEPTED | Documentation index, architecture/error contract/Mermaid, ADR, build/test guide and README describe actual scope and planned features accurately |
|
|
| AC-09 | ACCEPTED | No operational hardware/AI/UI dependency or extra placeholder project; no automatic handoff introduced |
|
|
| AC-10 | ACCEPTED | Complete report contains exact command outcomes, corrected failures, acceptance mapping and required sections in one plain copy window; no later implementation present |
|
|
|
|
Worker-reported execution: Windows x64, SDK 10.0.402, runtime 10.0.13;
|
|
restore, Release build and both suites succeeded after the documented
|
|
repository-local NuGet feed correction. Reported total: 54 passed, zero failed,
|
|
zero skipped. Existing assets confirm the framework/dependency graph; Release
|
|
binaries exist for all four projects. Their presence is corroboration, not an
|
|
independent test execution.
|
|
|
|
The orchestrator executed only read-only inspection and document/Git checks,
|
|
including static test-case counting and ignore-policy checks. It did **not**
|
|
execute dotnet, application builds, tests, formatting or hardware operations.
|
|
Runtime results are explicitly worker evidence. The worker's original report and
|
|
assignment remain unchanged; implementation is not committed by this review.
|
|
|
|
## Owner architectural realignment and current inspection
|
|
|
|
On 2026-10-28 the owner canceled the two-shell plan, required Client/UI/Components
|
|
and application Vertical Slice Architecture, and directed correction before
|
|
Step-02. [Step-01A](Step-01A.md) was the corrective assignment and is now accepted.
|
|
|
|
At correction planning, inspection found the original four-project solution unchanged:
|
|
Core has no dependencies, Application references Core and DI abstractions, and
|
|
both tests reference Core/Application. The existing target resolver and eager
|
|
registration are suitable for a feature slice and must be preserved.
|
|
|
|
There was no host/component implementation to delete or migrate. Correction was
|
|
additive UI composition plus feature organization, not a repository restart.
|
|
The old Step-02 was held, not executed.
|
|
|
|
After acceptance, [Step-02](Step-02.md) was regenerated from the seven-project
|
|
implementation and explicitly supersedes the prior unexecuted assignment. It now
|
|
uses application feature slices, reusable Core models and a thin profile metadata
|
|
consumer in the existing UI. Step-02 implementation/report now exist; acceptance
|
|
was initially withheld for the findings below and is now granted after Step-02A.
|
|
|
|
## Step-01A acceptance review
|
|
|
|
Decision: **ACCEPTED**, 2026-10-28. No Step-01B assignment is required.
|
|
|
|
Reviewed the [assignment](Step-01A.md), [worker report](Step-01A-Report.md),
|
|
solution and all project references, Client native/bootstrap/host code, RCL routes,
|
|
feature pages/view model/component/styles, moved Application feature, new rendered/
|
|
graph tests, package/build configuration, README and all affected technical docs.
|
|
|
|
| Criterion | Decision | Evidence |
|
|
|---|---|---|
|
|
| AC-01 | ACCEPTED | Existing descriptor/resolver semantics and 54 prior cases retained; expanded suites contain 39 unit/26 integration cases; root layout/history/manual workflow preserved |
|
|
| AC-02 | ACCEPTED | Actual seven-project solution, one production executable, MAUI/Windows Client configuration and native Release output |
|
|
| AC-03 | ACCEPTED | MainPage hosts UI Routes through BlazorWebView; UI owns routes/layout/pages, Components owns StatusNotice; native route/assets observations reported |
|
|
| AC-04 | ACCEPTED | Project files, graph test and independent static traversal confirm Client -> UI -> Components, allowed Application references and no cycles |
|
|
| AC-05 | ACCEPTED | Feature folder contains real resolver/DI/errors with stable public namespace and unchanged explicit selection/snapshot/no-fallback behavior |
|
|
| AC-06 | ACCEPTED | Actual HtmlRenderer component/route tests use real Core/Application DI, cover errors/unknown routes and safe text rendering, without Client references |
|
|
| AC-07 | ACCEPTED ON WORKER EXECUTION EVIDENCE | Reported complete Release solution and direct Windows Client builds: zero warnings/errors; 39 unit plus 26 integration passed, zero failed/skipped; matching source counts and Release outputs inspected |
|
|
| AC-08 | ACCEPTED ON WORKER NATIVE EVIDENCE | Detailed reported native home/selection/unregistered-physical/not-found checks, hidden error banner and both RCL CSS assets loading; native executable exists, not rerun by orchestrator |
|
|
| AC-09 | ACCEPTED | README/index/architecture/build guide and ADR-0001/0002 reflect one shell, two RCLs, VSA/modular monolith and metadata-only limitations |
|
|
| AC-10 | ACCEPTED | Evidence-bearing report, corrected failures and environment deviation disclosed; historical reports/assignments preserved and Step-02 unexecuted |
|
|
|
|
Worker-reported verified platform: SDK 10.0.402, runtime 10.0.13, Windows
|
|
10.0.26100.0/win-x64, MAUI Windows manifest 10.0.110 and WebView2 155.0.4283.62.
|
|
The source counts, framework/assets, seven-project graph and native/portable
|
|
Release artifacts corroborate the report. They do not prove an independent
|
|
runtime run. No application builds/tests/native launch were performed here.
|
|
|
|
Acceptance covers the application correction, not approval of the unintended
|
|
workload action or a claim that the broader tool environment is unchanged.
|
|
The deviations below are non-blocking for this verified Windows foundation and
|
|
must remain visible. No environment rollback or source fix was attempted.
|
|
|
|
## Historical Step-02 review and corrective decision
|
|
|
|
Initial decision: **REQUIRES CORRECTION**, 2026-10-28. The findings and criterion
|
|
table below describe the pre-correction implementation. They are preserved as
|
|
history and closed by the Step-02A acceptance review that follows.
|
|
|
|
Inspected the [assignment](Step-02.md), [worker report](Step-02-Report.md),
|
|
complete new Core/profile codec/catalog/DI/UI code, all new unit/integration
|
|
tests, synthetic fixtures, existing composition/reference changes, README and
|
|
affected technical/schema/ADR documentation.
|
|
|
|
| Criterion | Review result | Evidence / remaining work |
|
|
|---|---|---|
|
|
| AC-01 | Preserved on inspected evidence | Same seven-project graph, existing target/UI regressions and manual/protected workflow; no new dependency or shell |
|
|
| AC-02 | Present; validation correction required | Immutable profile/revision/module model works for supplied fixtures, but valid partial module-evidence context is rejected |
|
|
| AC-03 | Present on inspected evidence | Five capability states, custom operations and explicit undeclared Unknown retained; no operational authority |
|
|
| AC-04 | NOT SATISFIED | R-02 treats absent optional evidence identity constraints as exact null matches, rejecting compatible module-scoped evidence |
|
|
| AC-05 | NOT SATISFIED | R-01 permits incomplete timestamp strings that infer ambient date or offset, violating explicit schema data |
|
|
| AC-06 | Existing path inspected; correction regressions required | Real DI catalog/UI and atomic failed imports exist; both findings need direct/service/UI regression coverage |
|
|
| AC-07 | Present on inspected evidence | Three synthetic fixture documents cover baseline, variant, alternate/custom module and all five states |
|
|
| AC-08 | Existing suite passed per worker; insufficient coverage | Reported 59 unit + 34 integration passed, zero failed/skipped; solution/native build and native smoke passed; findings are absent from this coverage |
|
|
| AC-09 | Corrective alignment required | Documentation exists, but timestamp/optional applicability behavior must match the stated contract and correction status |
|
|
| AC-10 | Report/preservation inspected | Required report and scope evidence present; original assignment/report remain unchanged; no Step-03 |
|
|
|
|
### R-01 - Ambient-dependent timestamp import
|
|
|
|
[VehicleProfileJsonCodec.cs](../src/AutoForge.Application/Features/Vehicles/Profiles/VehicleProfileJsonCodec.cs),
|
|
line 478, delegates to DateTimeOffset.TryParse with RoundtripKind. Official .NET
|
|
documentation states that a missing date defaults to the current day, a missing
|
|
offset defaults to the local time zone, and RoundtripKind has no effect for this
|
|
type. Time-only, date-only and offset-free date/time strings therefore are not
|
|
reliably rejected by this supposedly explicit/clock-independent import contract.
|
|
Both publishedAt and retrievedAt use this path.
|
|
|
|
### R-02 - Absent evidence constraints rejected
|
|
|
|
[VehicleProfile.cs](../src/AutoForge.Core/Vehicles/VehicleProfile.cs), lines 367
|
|
and 408, validates each optional module identity using a helper that requires both
|
|
values to be null when the evidence field is null. A module with known hardware
|
|
cannot accept module-scoped evidence that leaves hardware applicability
|
|
unspecified, even when vehicle/profile/module and all supplied constraints match.
|
|
This contradicts the documented optional identity context. Fix absence handling
|
|
without weakening supplied-constraint or unknown-target checks.
|
|
|
|
These are source/contract findings, not claims of independently executed failures.
|
|
Official API documentation corroborates R-01; Step-02A requires worker
|
|
reproduction, corrected regressions and native/UI evidence, now supplied and
|
|
reviewed below.
|
|
|
|
Worker-reported Step-02 execution remains historical: complete seven-project and
|
|
direct native Release builds with zero warnings/errors; 59 unit and 34 integration
|
|
cases passed, zero failed/skipped; native profile import/select/variant/error/export
|
|
and old route/asset checks reported. Static test counts, fixture shape, restore
|
|
assets and Release/native artifacts corroborate it. No build/test/native/workload
|
|
command was executed by the orchestrator.
|
|
|
|
## Step-02A acceptance and corrected Step-02
|
|
|
|
Decision: **ACCEPTED**, 2026-10-28. Step-02A closes R-01/R-02; the corrected
|
|
Step-02 milestone is accepted. No Step-02B is required.
|
|
|
|
Reviewed [Step-02A](Step-02A.md), its [report](Step-02A-Report.md), the complete
|
|
new timestamp parser/shared evidence helper, correction unit/real DI/rendered UI
|
|
tests, data mutation helpers, schema/ADR/README/testing updates and project scope.
|
|
|
|
| Criterion | Decision | Evidence |
|
|
|---|---|---|
|
|
| AC-01 | ACCEPTED | Anchored ASCII full-date/time/offset grammar, exact invariant calendar parse, bounded minute offset and typed property failures; both timestamp fields have positive/negative vectors and exact offset/tick assertions |
|
|
| AC-02 | ACCEPTED | Null constraint is absence; non-null requires known matching target; each-field omission/matching/mismatch/unknown-target constructor tests and all-null real DI round-trip inspected |
|
|
| AC-03 | ACCEPTED | Actual service/page path accepts module-only evidence, rejects timestamp/supplied mismatch, preserves catalog/current selection and renders explicit errors |
|
|
| AC-04 | ACCEPTED | Previous 93 cases remain in the expanded 140-case suite; fixtures, seven-project graph, metadata/target isolation and public contracts retained |
|
|
| AC-05 | ACCEPTED ON WORKER EXECUTION EVIDENCE | Reported actual pre-fix failures; focused corrected runs; complete sequential Release build 0 warnings/errors; 103 unit + 37 integration passes, zero failed/skipped; native scenarios and original fixtures observed |
|
|
| AC-06 | ACCEPTED | Schema/ADR specify precise grammar/null/offset limits and absent-versus-supplied identity constraints; README/index/test guide preserve historical versus corrective results |
|
|
| AC-07 | ACCEPTED | Scope remains two fixes/tests/docs/report; no new package/project/workload action or later-step implementation; historical assignments/reports preserved |
|
|
|
|
Coverage precision: the direct unit helper's null label retains all known
|
|
constraints, while its four named cases omit each constraint individually.
|
|
The separate real DI/UI integration test supplies all four nulls and constructs/
|
|
round-trips the actual Core model. Acceptance uses that combined inspected
|
|
coverage, not an assumption that the unit loop's null label means all-null.
|
|
|
|
Worker-reported execution: SDK 10.0.402/runtime 10.0.13; Windows target
|
|
10.0.26100.0/win-x64; MAUI Windows manifest 10.0.110; WebView2 155.0.4283.62.
|
|
Before-fix command outcomes and focused runs are recorded in the unchanged report.
|
|
Final build: complete seven-project Release solution, zero warnings/errors.
|
|
Final suites: 103 unit and 37 integration passed, zero failed/skipped.
|
|
Native observations include full explicit-offset timestamps/partial evidence,
|
|
exact invalid-time path, conflicting supplied constraint with unchanged catalog/
|
|
selection, original baseline/variant/alternate imports and target metadata route.
|
|
|
|
Static source case counts, seven-project acyclic references, restored assets,
|
|
Release assemblies and native executable corroborate the report. The orchestrator
|
|
did not execute application builds/tests/native launch or workload commands.
|
|
The original Step-02 and Step-02A assignments/reports remain historical evidence.
|
|
|
|
Step-03 is prepared against the actual accepted profile/Application/UI baseline.
|
|
It assigns Diagnostics and Simulation as two real new library boundaries, with
|
|
provider-neutral Application features and Client composition. They now exist
|
|
and the corrected Step-03 milestone is accepted; dynamics/physical adapters remain
|
|
unimplemented until their separate assignments.
|
|
|
|
## Historical Step-03 review and corrective decision
|
|
|
|
Initial decision: **REQUIRES CORRECTION**, 2026-10-28. R-01/R-02/R-03 below
|
|
describe the pre-Step-03A code and are now closed. Step-03 still requires the
|
|
additional R-04 correction recorded after the Step-03A review below.
|
|
|
|
Inspected the [assignment](Step-03.md), [worker report](Step-03-Report.md),
|
|
Diagnostics contracts/codec/client, Simulation definitions/provider/state and
|
|
internal oracle, application session service, UI view model/page, new protocol/
|
|
session/rendered tests, project references, README and protocol/simulation/ADR/
|
|
build documentation.
|
|
|
|
| Criterion | Review result | Evidence / remaining work |
|
|
|---|---|---|
|
|
| AC-01 | Preserved on inspected evidence | Nine-project graph, sole Client, no reverse references/cycles and IntegrationTests-only internal oracle |
|
|
| AC-02 | Present on inspected evidence | Explicit exact profile/provider/kind/session selection and reset/close with no fallback |
|
|
| AC-03 | Present; validation correction required | Real frames traverse transport, but omitted/duplicate request fields and semantically invalid positive replies are not adequately rejected |
|
|
| AC-04 | Normal flow works per inspected/reported evidence | State isolation, read/clear/reset and static signals present; R-03 must detect clear acknowledgement without empty readback |
|
|
| AC-05 | NOT SATISFIED | R-01/R-02 expose malformed/ambiguous frames and invalid typed data outside existing fault tests |
|
|
| AC-06 | NOT SATISFIED | Probe identity mismatch becomes a discovery ProtocolError after its exchange was already traced PositiveResponse |
|
|
| AC-07 | Corrective verification required | UI/session/provider composition is real, but nonempty successful readback is labeled cleared/verified |
|
|
| AC-08 | Existing suite passed per worker; insufficient coverage | 108 unit + 53 integration passed, zero failed/skipped; complete Release/native build and native smoke reported; new vectors not covered |
|
|
| AC-09 | Corrective alignment required | Documentation exists; wire presence/ambiguity, semantic validation and verified-clear contracts/lifecycle must be aligned |
|
|
| AC-10 | Report/preservation inspected | Required report and scoped changes present; original assignment/report preserved; no Step-04 |
|
|
|
|
### Step-03 R-01 - Required and unambiguous frames
|
|
|
|
[SyntheticProtocolV1.cs](../src/AutoForge.Diagnostics/SyntheticProtocolV1.cs),
|
|
lines 45 and 82, defaults Version to 1 and deserializes without requiring its
|
|
presence or rejecting duplicate JSON properties. Omitting version leaves a valid
|
|
v1 object; omitting logicalTimeTicks can leave zero. Repeated service/version/
|
|
correlation fields can be resolved by last-value deserialization rather than
|
|
rejected. With otherwise valid session binding, the transport can dispatch a
|
|
virtual clear from a malformed/ambiguous request.
|
|
|
|
### Step-03 R-02 - Service semantics and truthful trace
|
|
|
|
[SyntheticDiagnosticProtocolClient.cs](../src/AutoForge.Diagnostics/SyntheticDiagnosticProtocolClient.cs),
|
|
line 143, reads signal ticks and strings into unvalidated result records.
|
|
For example a negative logicalTimeTicks or blank signal ID/unit can still become
|
|
PositiveResponse. DTC strings likewise lack semantic validation.
|
|
|
|
The probe module-identity check at line 55 occurs outside the exchange decoder.
|
|
A mismatched probe is recorded positive at line 289 before discovery converts it
|
|
to ProtocolError. Returned outcome and raw exchange trace therefore disagree.
|
|
Validate the complete interpreted payload before positive result/trace commitment.
|
|
|
|
### Step-03 R-03 - Acknowledgement versus verified clear
|
|
|
|
[DiagnosticPageViewModel.cs](../src/AutoForge.UI/Features/Vehicles/Diagnostics/DiagnosticPageViewModel.cs),
|
|
line 261, tests only readback.IsSuccess and then says the state was cleared.
|
|
A successful response containing remaining DTCs still takes this success path.
|
|
The logical use case must fail verification when readback is nonempty or
|
|
failed/unknown/cancelled, while preserving the actual observed data and no
|
|
physical-operation claim.
|
|
|
|
These are static source/contract findings, not parent-executed reproductions.
|
|
The worker subsequently supplied actual reproductions and corrected evidence.
|
|
|
|
Reported Step-03 evidence remains historical: complete nine-project/native Release
|
|
build zero warnings/errors; 108 unit + 53 integration passed, zero failed/skipped;
|
|
native explicit open/probe/read/clear/reset/close/trace and old routes observed.
|
|
Static case counts, graph, restore assets and Release/native outputs corroborate
|
|
the report. No build/test/native/workload command was executed by the orchestrator.
|
|
|
|
## Historical Step-03A scoped acceptance and additional discovery finding
|
|
|
|
Decision: Step-03A's **R-01/R-02/R-03 corrections ACCEPTED**, 2026-10-28.
|
|
At that review the parent Step-03 milestone was **NOT ACCEPTED**: R-04 required
|
|
Step-03B. The three successful corrections remain closed; R-04 is now also
|
|
closed by the subsequent acceptance review below.
|
|
|
|
Reviewed [Step-03A](Step-03A.md), its [report](Step-03A-Report.md), strict wire
|
|
presence/uniqueness logic, complete reply/trace validation, Application verified
|
|
clear/result and UI adaptation, unit/state-oracle/real-DI/rendered fault tests,
|
|
test-only rewriting transport and directly related docs.
|
|
|
|
| Criterion | Scoped decision | Evidence |
|
|
|---|---|---|
|
|
| AC-01 | ACCEPTED | All ten request fields required, explicit zero retained, duplicate/unknown fields rejected; malformed clear vectors leave independent state unchanged |
|
|
| AC-02 | ACCEPTED | Exact reply/service shapes, semantic identifiers/timing/uniqueness and positive/error/data consistency validated before positive result; malformed vectors return no value |
|
|
| AC-03 | ACCEPTED | Wrong probe module is now checked within the exchange decoder; one matching ProtocolError trace retains actual request/reply rather than false positive |
|
|
| AC-04 | ACCEPTED | Application clear-and-verify separates acknowledgement/readback, rejects nonempty/failed/unknown readback, preserves remaining codes and renders failure |
|
|
| AC-05 | ACCEPTED WITHIN CORRECTIVE SCOPE | Original 161-case baseline retained, nine-project graph/state/target/profile/clock boundaries unchanged; R-04 is an additional pre-existing discovery case |
|
|
| AC-06 | ACCEPTED ON WORKER EXECUTION EVIDENCE | Reported actual 2-unit/5-integration pre-fix failures; corrected focused runs; full Release build 0 warnings/errors; 111 unit + 64 integration passes, zero failed/skipped; native baseline observed |
|
|
| AC-07 | ACCEPTED | README/protocol/simulation/ADR/test docs reflect corrected wire/verification and historical versus corrective results |
|
|
| AC-08 | ACCEPTED | No new project/package/workload action or future step; original assignments/reports and orchestration files preserved by worker |
|
|
|
|
Worker-reported final coverage: 175 passed (111 unit, 64 integration), zero
|
|
failed/skipped. Native evidence covers genuine verified clear/empty readback,
|
|
probe/read/trace/reset/close and old routes. The false-ack/nonempty-readback fault
|
|
is explicitly real DI/rendered integration evidence, not native coverage; the
|
|
production Client has no runtime fault control and none was added just for proof.
|
|
|
|
Static source case counts, nine-project acyclic graph and existing restore/
|
|
Release/native artifacts corroborate the report, not independent runtime
|
|
execution. The orchestrator did not run builds/tests or launch the app.
|
|
|
|
### R-04 - Successful probe evidence discarded when identity is unavailable
|
|
|
|
[SyntheticDiagnosticProtocolClient.cs](../src/AutoForge.Diagnostics/SyntheticDiagnosticProtocolClient.cs),
|
|
line 72, always follows a valid probe with an identity read, then constructs the
|
|
entry solely from identity outcome and drops the validated service list when
|
|
identity fails. [ProviderContracts.cs](../src/AutoForge.Diagnostics/ProviderContracts.cs),
|
|
line 257, defines Responders as non-null identities.
|
|
[DiagnosticPageViewModel.cs](../src/AutoForge.UI/Features/Vehicles/Diagnostics/DiagnosticPageViewModel.cs),
|
|
line 132, labels this identity count as actual endpoints that responded.
|
|
|
|
A valid module definition implementing `probe` but not `read.identity` is allowed.
|
|
It returns a positive validated probe and an unsupported identity reply, yet it
|
|
is omitted from the responder count. Likewise, a successful probe is lost if
|
|
the subsequent identity reply is malformed, timed out or cancelled. Reachability,
|
|
advertised services and identity verification are different facts.
|
|
|
|
Step-03B was required to preserve both phase outcomes, keep valid probe/service evidence,
|
|
label probe responders versus identified modules honestly, and keep unavailable
|
|
identity explicit without fabricating profile-derived identity or relaxing
|
|
existing identity-dependent action guards. The source finding was not executed
|
|
by the orchestrator; the worker subsequently supplied the pre-fix reproduction
|
|
reviewed below.
|
|
|
|
## Step-03B acceptance and corrected Step-03
|
|
|
|
Decision: **ACCEPTED**, 2026-10-28. Step-03B closes R-04; corrected Step-03 is
|
|
accepted with Step-03A/Step-03B. No Step-03C is required.
|
|
|
|
Reviewed [Step-03B](Step-03B.md), its [report](Step-03B-Report.md),
|
|
phase-specific discovery/probe/identity models and aggregation, UI summary/rows/
|
|
guards, actual Simulation/DI/rendered regression tests, trace assertions and
|
|
directly related protocol/simulation/ADR/README/testing documentation.
|
|
|
|
| Criterion | Decision | Evidence |
|
|
|---|---|---|
|
|
| AC-01 | ACCEPTED | Valid positive probe and immutable services retained independently of optional identity result; unsupported/unavailable identity stays null with explicit phase reason |
|
|
| AC-02 | ACCEPTED | Expected/probed/identified counts distinct; partial UI preserves services and unknown identity; controls disabled and direct view-model guards emit no operation |
|
|
| AC-03 | ACCEPTED | Negative/malformed/mismatched/timed-out/cancelled identity preserves positive probe and its own trace; failed probe does not invent identity/services; close clears active presentation |
|
|
| AC-04 | ACCEPTED | Normal synthetic workflow, R-01/R-02/R-03, profile/target/state/oracle boundaries and nine-project graph retained; 175 prior cases included in 183 |
|
|
| AC-05 | ACCEPTED ON WORKER EXECUTION EVIDENCE | Reported actual pre-fix phase-conflation failure; focused 35 passes; complete Release build zero warnings/errors; 111 unit + 72 integration passes, zero failed/skipped; native baseline observed |
|
|
| AC-06 | ACCEPTED | README/protocol/simulation/architecture/ADR/testing docs describe phase/count/action policy and native versus rendered evidence |
|
|
| AC-07 | ACCEPTED | Only scoped source/tests/docs/report work; previous assignments/reports and orchestration files preserved; no new project/package/workload action or future step |
|
|
|
|
Chosen policy: a validated probe without advertised read.identity does not issue
|
|
an unsupported identity request. Its probe/services remain available as claims;
|
|
identity is explicitly not attempted and never populated from profile metadata.
|
|
Identity-dependent actions stay fail-closed.
|
|
|
|
Worker-reported coverage: 183 passed (111 unit, 72 integration), zero failed/skipped.
|
|
Native baseline covers explicit load/open, 3 expected/2 successful probes/2
|
|
identified modules, no-response, read/static signals/raw trace, verified clear,
|
|
reset/close and old routes. Partial-identity faults/action guards/cancellation are
|
|
real-DI/rendered test coverage, not claimed native fault coverage.
|
|
|
|
Static source counts, nine-project acyclic references and existing restore/
|
|
Release/native artifacts corroborate the report. No application build/test/
|
|
native/workload command was executed by the orchestrator.
|
|
|
|
Step-04 is prepared against the actual accepted interfaces. It assigns a separate
|
|
explicit dynamics provider/configuration, fixed-step clock/model/scenario controls,
|
|
configuration-preserving reset and versioned dynamic telemetry through diagnostics.
|
|
The dynamics implementation now exists under review, still without any extra
|
|
executable/project, physical integration or calibration programming.
|
|
|
|
## Historical Step-04 review and corrective decision
|
|
|
|
Initial decision: **REQUIRES CORRECTION**, 2026-10-28. The original findings
|
|
below describe pre-Step-04A code. At the follow-up, most were fixed but an
|
|
overlap criterion still required Step-04B. The closing review below now accepts
|
|
the corrected milestone.
|
|
|
|
Inspected the [assignment](Step-04.md), [worker report](Step-04-Report.md),
|
|
configuration/initial/model validation and fingerprinting, complete physics/
|
|
scenario/control implementation, dynamic provider and v2 binding, Application
|
|
configuration/session paths, UI controls/status, all new unit/integration tests
|
|
and related model/protocol/build documentation.
|
|
|
|
| Criterion | Review result | Evidence / remaining work |
|
|
|---|---|---|
|
|
| AC-01 | Present; reference correction required | Immutable config/shape/fingerprint and profile binding exist; missing profile/module references can escape the import UI's handled exception contract |
|
|
| AC-02 | NOT SATISFIED | Progress resets at phase boundaries and async owner/active-pacer behavior lacks controlled proof; tests use wall delays/polling |
|
|
| AC-03 | Present on inspected evidence | Separate static/dynamics factories and exact original-config reset/session isolation implemented; no fallback or extra project |
|
|
| AC-04 | NOT SATISFIED | Initial and runtime locked-RPM/speed/gear consistency is not guaranteed across accepted inputs; independent force tests are absent |
|
|
| AC-05 | Baseline passed per worker | Default 650-rpm/45-MPH/full 300-s hold/stop/repeatability gates are meaningfully asserted; broader boundary inputs are not covered |
|
|
| AC-06 | Present; fault policy correction required | Actual strict v2 snapshots and static v1 compatibility exist; faulted/invalid model state must not become healthy success or an unhandled serialization failure |
|
|
| AC-07 | Corrective lifecycle/status required | Real controls/table/DI exist; faulted-run success notices, overwritten cancellation ownership and stale async publication require correction |
|
|
| AC-08 | Existing suite passed per worker; insufficient coverage | 115 unit + 75 integration passed, zero failed/skipped; complete Release/native and numerical baseline evidence supplied; review vectors not covered |
|
|
| AC-09 | Corrective alignment required | Equations/contracts/native guide present; operating envelope, fault/progress/clock ownership and corrected verification need documentation |
|
|
| AC-10 | Report/preservation inspected | Required report, nine-project scope and prior history preserved; no Step-05 |
|
|
|
|
### Step-04 R-01 - Unhandled configuration reference errors
|
|
|
|
[DynamicsConfigurationService.cs](../src/AutoForge.Application/Features/Vehicles/Simulation/DynamicsConfigurationService.cs),
|
|
line 68, selects the referenced profile inside Import but catches only JSON and
|
|
argument exceptions. Missing profile/revision throws VehicleProfileCatalogException.
|
|
[DynamicsConfiguration.cs](../src/AutoForge.Core/Simulation/DynamicsConfiguration.cs),
|
|
line 340, uses GetModule and can throw KeyNotFoundException for a missing module.
|
|
[SimulationPageViewModel.cs](../src/AutoForge.UI/Features/Vehicles/Simulation/SimulationPageViewModel.cs),
|
|
line 106, handles only DynamicsConfigurationException for import. Those valid
|
|
JSON/invalid-reference inputs can therefore escape the ordinary visible-error
|
|
path instead of leaving a usable page with actionable input feedback.
|
|
|
|
### Step-04 R-02 - Unsupported or contradictory drivetrain states
|
|
|
|
Configuration checks RPM range/gear count but not redundant initial kinematics.
|
|
For example a running first-gear state at 10 m/s and 650 rpm is accepted under
|
|
the default ratios even though reset publishes zero slip and the wheel equation
|
|
requires a different RPM. Reading before any step exposes the contradiction.
|
|
|
|
[DynamicsEngine.cs](../src/AutoForge.Simulation/DynamicsEngine.cs), line 385,
|
|
independently caps coupled RPM with Math.Min while leaving speed/gear and zero
|
|
slip unchanged. Allowed high-speed/shift configurations can violate the promised
|
|
locked equation. At line 368, a slipping condition caused by below-idle wheel RPM
|
|
can also produce zero reported slip when speed exceeds a low configured launch
|
|
threshold. Validation or truthful modeled limits/slip/failure must replace those
|
|
healthy contradictory states, without gaming the default cruise gate.
|
|
|
|
### Step-04 R-03 - Progress, terminal failures and async ownership
|
|
|
|
[DynamicsEngine.cs](../src/AutoForge.Simulation/DynamicsEngine.cs), line 486,
|
|
clears cumulative completed time immediately after adding the finished phase,
|
|
so scenario progress drops at phase transitions.
|
|
|
|
[SimulationPageViewModel.cs](../src/AutoForge.UI/Features/Vehicles/Simulation/SimulationPageViewModel.cs),
|
|
line 204, reports every returned scenario status via SetSuccess, including
|
|
Faulted; RefreshTelemetryAsync can overwrite the failure with another success.
|
|
The run method also replaces its pending cancellation slot before rejecting a
|
|
second runner, leaving the first runner no longer reachable through Cancel.
|
|
Post-await status/data publication lacks the earlier diagnostic UI's current-
|
|
session guard, so old work can update presentation during reset/close/reopen.
|
|
|
|
Finite/domain failures mutate engine fields before checking them. The producer
|
|
can then read that failed snapshot and serialize positive Good telemetry;
|
|
non-finite fields can instead escape as a serialization exception. A clear
|
|
failed-run/last-valid-snapshot or typed negative policy is required.
|
|
|
|
The active pacer uses direct Task.Delay; the lifecycle test uses fixed wall delays
|
|
and polling, and repeatability tests bypass the pacer. Add a controlled scheduler/
|
|
time seam and actual active-run pause/resume/stop/reset/restart/close and pacing
|
|
tests, plus independent force/kinematic boundary evidence.
|
|
|
|
All findings are source/contract review, not orchestrator-executed failures.
|
|
Worker baseline evidence remains historical: complete nine-project/native Release
|
|
build zero warnings/errors; 115 unit + 75 integration passed; 3,361 equal samples,
|
|
10 s warm idle, 10.3 s acceleration, 3,000/3,000 cruise samples in band/coupled,
|
|
5.8 s braking and 10 s return idle, plus actual native workflow. These useful
|
|
default results do not prove the missing boundary/failure/lifecycle cases.
|
|
Source case counts, graph and existing artifacts corroborate the report.
|
|
|
|
## Historical Step-04A review and focused follow-up
|
|
|
|
Decision at that review: most scope was satisfied, but existing R-03/AC-04
|
|
required Step-04B. The follow-up below has now closed that condition.
|
|
|
|
Reviewed [Step-04A](Step-04A.md), its [report](Step-04A-Report.md), typed
|
|
reference handling, initial/runtime coupling/limit guards and rollback, phase/
|
|
overall progress, terminal v2 failures, UI generations/cancellation ownership,
|
|
actual controller/pacer code, independent numerical and controlled tests and docs.
|
|
|
|
| Criterion | Review result | Evidence / remaining work |
|
|
|---|---|---|
|
|
| AC-01 | Satisfied on inspected/reported evidence | Missing profile/revision/module/calibration inputs are typed and atomic; rendered/native recoverable input errors reported |
|
|
| AC-02 | Satisfied on inspected/reported evidence | Initial coupled relation, redline validation/runtime guard, actual RPM-discrepancy slip and rollback; independent force/RPM boundary tests |
|
|
| AC-03 | Satisfied on inspected/reported evidence | Cumulative/phase progress corrected, fault snapshots rollback, negative DYNAMICS_RUN_FAULTED, persistent error and no healthy poisoned telemetry |
|
|
| AC-04 | NOT YET SATISFIED | Sequential controlled lifecycle and UI owner tests improved, but Start/Resume can mutate before rejecting an undrained advancement task |
|
|
| AC-05 | Existing regressions/numerical gates retained | Reported unchanged 3,361-sample baseline and all 190 cases within 202 passes; static/profile/wire/clear/discovery/source graph preserved |
|
|
| AC-06 | Reported execution inspected | Before-fix reference/coupling/progress failures, corrected focused runs, clean complete Release build, 122 unit + 80 integration passes and native smoke supplied |
|
|
| AC-07 | Satisfied on inspected evidence | Directly related model/config/lifecycle/v2/README/testing documentation updated |
|
|
| AC-08 | Preservation/scope inspected | Only scoped correction/source/tests/docs/report; no new project/package/workload action, orchestration/history edit or later step |
|
|
|
|
### Remaining existing criterion: reject before lifecycle mutation
|
|
|
|
[DynamicsEngine.cs](../src/AutoForge.Simulation/DynamicsEngine.cs),
|
|
StartOrResumeAsync around line 772 calls engine.Start/Resume before
|
|
StartRunnerLocked checks its still-active task. StopRunnerAsync changes state,
|
|
cancels the owner, releases the gate and then awaits its completion.
|
|
|
|
If Resume/Start arrives while that cleanup is pending, the engine can become
|
|
Running and only then throw "already active". The cancelled old owner exits and
|
|
the rejected command can leave Running without an owner. A rejected operation
|
|
must wait under a documented policy or leave state unchanged; it cannot mutate
|
|
first. Existing controlled tests await Pause/Stop/Reset before the next start/
|
|
resume, so the pending-transition overlap is absent.
|
|
|
|
This is a source/contract finding within the original Step-04A overlap/lifecycle
|
|
criterion, not a new requirement introduced by the owner's process-improvement
|
|
request. The orchestrator did not execute it; Step-04B requires a controlled
|
|
pre-fix reproduction and is limited to this issue.
|
|
|
|
Worker-reported Step-04A results remain historical: full nine-project/native
|
|
Release build zero warnings/errors; 122 unit + 80 integration passed (202 total,
|
|
zero failed/skipped); unchanged default numerical gates, independent force
|
|
equations, controlled pacing comparison and native input/fault/baseline smoke.
|
|
Source counts, graph and existing artifacts corroborate that evidence; the
|
|
orchestrator ran no application builds/tests/native/workload commands.
|
|
|
|
## Step-04B acceptance and corrected Step-04
|
|
|
|
Decision: **ACCEPTED**, 2026-10-28. C-01 through C-05 and the remaining
|
|
Step-04A criterion are satisfied; corrected Step-04/04A/04B are accepted.
|
|
No Step-04C is required.
|
|
|
|
Reviewed [Step-04B](Step-04B.md), its [report](Step-04B-Report.md), the shared
|
|
owner precondition before all start mutations, complete controlled status/
|
|
sample assertions for pending pause/stop/reset, cleanup/retry/invalid/disposed
|
|
cases, real SimulationPage service/UI rejection and documentation/self-review.
|
|
|
|
| Criterion | Decision | Evidence |
|
|
|---|---|---|
|
|
| AC-01 | ACCEPTED | All frozen cases covered; EnsureNoActiveAdvancementOwner precedes engine.Start/Resume/scenario state changes, with defensive check retained at owner installation |
|
|
| AC-02 | ACCEPTED | Old task drains without holding its cleanup gate; rejection preserves full status/sample count; one retry advances once; real UI error never reports resumed success |
|
|
| AC-03 | ACCEPTED ON WORKER EXECUTION EVIDENCE | Reported complete Release build zero warnings/errors; 126 unit + 81 integration passes (207 total, zero failed/skipped), original numerical gates and native lifecycle/reset/telemetry smoke |
|
|
| AC-04 | ACCEPTED | C-01..C-05 matrix, actual pre-fix observations, source-path self-review and matching lifecycle/README/testing policy |
|
|
| AC-05 | ACCEPTED | Single-issue guard/tests/docs/report change, no new project/package/interface/physics/protocol; historical assignments/reports and orchestration files preserved |
|
|
|
|
Worker source-path self-review explicitly walks precondition order, producer/
|
|
consumer callers, failure cleanup and barrier-finally behavior. The exact race
|
|
is controlled unit/real-DI/UI evidence, not claimed human-timed native proof.
|
|
|
|
Static source case counts, nine-project acyclic references, restored assets,
|
|
Release assemblies and native output corroborate the report. The orchestrator
|
|
did not execute application builds/tests/native/workload commands.
|
|
|
|
Step-05 is prepared under the revised prospective policy: one user outcome,
|
|
one acquisition-owner contract, numeric/bar rendering and validated in-memory
|
|
configuration. No new persistence/wire format, clock/model, project or host.
|
|
The frozen matrix states missing/uncertain/stale/range and source-lifetime
|
|
outcomes before coding; future enhancements stay out of acceptance.
|
|
|
|
## Prospective orchestration/process improvement
|
|
|
|
The owner requested fewer corrective handoffs through better planning/prompts.
|
|
The [revised roadmap policy](ROADMAP.md) and
|
|
[WORKER-QUALITY-GATE.md](WORKER-QUALITY-GATE.md) now require:
|
|
|
|
- Smaller capability-complete assignments instead of several new subsystems/
|
|
state machines/formats in one handoff.
|
|
- A compact agreed input/outcome/transition matrix before implementation.
|
|
- Worker source-path self-review after the first green run, fixing issues inside
|
|
the active assignment before COMPLETE.
|
|
- Evidence mapped to exact cases/invariants, not test-count proxies.
|
|
- One consolidated review against frozen criteria; new preferences are planned,
|
|
not retroactively called defects.
|
|
|
|
The rules apply to new work beginning with Step-04B, not retroactively to
|
|
Step-04A. No automated agents/handoffs or weaker quality bar is introduced.
|
|
Step-01A was owner-driven architecture change, not an implementation-quality
|
|
failure. Earlier technical cycles exposed contract/coverage and overlarge-scope
|
|
gaps; orchestration shares responsibility for those gaps.
|
|
|
|
The Step-05 dashboard envelope remains limited to numeric/bar gauges,
|
|
validated bindings/ranges/units and missing/stale states with one acquisition
|
|
owner. Basic add/edit/remove controls are already assigned; advanced charts and
|
|
layout designers stay later. Future broad calibration/AI/
|
|
hardware envelopes must be split before assignment if needed; history is not
|
|
renumbered and corrective letters are not used for planned features.
|
|
|
|
## Historical Step-05 review and required completion
|
|
|
|
Decision at that review: **REQUIRES CORRECTION / NOT ACCEPTED**, 2026-10-29.
|
|
The [returned report](Step-05-Report.md) says PASSED with native smoke NOT EXECUTED.
|
|
That is not satisfaction of [Step-05](Step-05.md) or its shared exit gate.
|
|
Step-05A addresses only existing C-01..C-10/AC-01..AC-07; no new feature is assigned.
|
|
|
|
Reviewed all new dashboard models/acquisition/component code and tracked host/DI
|
|
changes, actual diagnostic session cancellation/disposal, existing route tests,
|
|
simulation host inventory, technical-document status, nine-project references
|
|
and existing Release outputs. Source review identifies:
|
|
|
|
| Finding | Evidence | Original contract |
|
|
|---|---|---|
|
|
| R-01 - incomplete/broken configured host workflow | DiagnosticPageViewModel validates generated definitions before its fresh feed has read bindings; with no prior reads it starts empty and has no editor. Only Numeric defaults exist; simulation host is unwired. Start disables on any snapshot, including Stopped, and background refresh changes fields without a page render notification. | C-01/C-04/C-10, required UI section, AC-01/AC-04 |
|
|
| R-02 - owner/source lifetime | Factory Create always returns a new independent feed. Its token is not session-linked. Close/reset stops but never clears/disposes the old feed/callback, so later startup reuses the old session; scope disposal is not implemented. Direct session close does not end the poll loop. | C-05/C-06/C-07, AC-02 |
|
|
| R-03 - false current data and failed cleanup | Error feed state can still project cached positive data as Good; Stop rethrows a faulted owner, skipping the host's session-close/reset path. Latest unit changes are not compared to the definition, and the UI drops RangeState and sample context. | C-02/C-03/C-08/C-09, AC-01/AC-02/AC-03 |
|
|
| R-04 - unsafe/incomplete presentation | Empty bar divs have no height/styles, so width alone cannot display a bar. Null percent becomes 0 and NaN can become a CSS width. Range/state/source-time presentation and accessible descriptions are incomplete. | C-01/C-02/C-03/C-04, required component section, AC-01/AC-04 |
|
|
| R-05 - unsupported completion claims | Tests and technical docs/README are unchanged; no dashboard test references exist. Only the original 207 tests are reported, with no case-specific executions. Required native smoke is unexecuted, not out of scope. | C-01..C-10, AC-05/AC-06/AC-07, shared gate |
|
|
|
|
| Original criterion | Decision | Evidence gap |
|
|
|---|---|---|
|
|
| AC-01 | NOT ACCEPTED | Some definition/number validation exists; assigned rendered states/editor and meaningful component tests do not |
|
|
| AC-02 | NOT ACCEPTED | Single loop per instance is not single owner per session; source/fault/cleanup paths are incomplete and untested |
|
|
| AC-03 | NOT VERIFIED | Source groups module reads, but no actual wire-count/v1-v2/paused-model dashboard test proves the criterion |
|
|
| AC-04 | NOT ACCEPTED | Generic dependency boundary is preserved, but real configured static/dynamic host workflow is incomplete |
|
|
| AC-05 | PARTIAL / NOT ACCEPTED | Worker reports zero-warning/error Release build and baseline 126 unit + 81 integration passes; no new dashboard tests, required native smoke NOT EXECUTED |
|
|
| AC-06 | NOT SATISFIED | No technical-document/README updates; claimed matrix/self-review lacks named assertions and executed cases |
|
|
| AC-07 | PARTIAL / NOT ACCEPTED | Prompt protection, historical reports and single-fenced report preserved; completion/coverage claims do not meet the exit contract |
|
|
|
|
The nine-project graph remains acyclic with one Client executable and independent
|
|
Components. Existing Release assemblies corroborate compilation artifacts only;
|
|
they do not independently prove test execution or dashboard behavior. The
|
|
orchestrator ran no application builds/tests/native/workload commands and did
|
|
not execute these reproductions.
|
|
|
|
Preserve the returned report unchanged. [Step-05A](Step-05A.md) requires actual
|
|
pre-fix failures for existing broken paths, completion of the already-assigned
|
|
editor/static-dynamic integration, controlled source/owner/rendering tests and
|
|
honest native evidence. If native execution is unavailable, report the exact
|
|
blocker and INCOMPLETE/BLOCKED, not PASS or an acceptance waiver.
|
|
At that review Step-06 denoted recording/replay. Its assignment was withheld.
|
|
The owner decision below now inserts display units first.
|
|
|
|
## Historical Step-05A review and focused follow-up
|
|
|
|
Decision at that review: most scope was corrected, but Step-05B was required
|
|
for the remaining existing range/test obligations. The closing review below
|
|
now accepts corrected Step-05/05A/05B. The new units request was not used as
|
|
an acceptance criterion for these completed assignments.
|
|
|
|
Reviewed [Step-05A report](Step-05A-Report.md), all dashboard/session-lifetime/
|
|
host/component changes, all new dashboard tests and existing route assertions,
|
|
technical-document/README changes, nine-project graph and existing Release
|
|
outputs. Original scope decisions:
|
|
|
|
| Area | Decision | Evidence |
|
|
|---|---|---|
|
|
| Host/editor/start/stop/live rendering | Corrected on inspected evidence | Same panel in diagnostics/simulation; actual feed discovers choices before edit; state-based actions; dispatcher subscription and rendered cycle-2 assertion |
|
|
| Single owner/session/visibility lifetime | Corrected on inspected evidence | Session-keyed shared factory, registered session resource, cancel-before-drain/disposal, direct close/scope/late-response tests and widget-independent polling |
|
|
| Fault/unit/context/presentation | Mostly corrected; range edge remains | Terminal error yields Stale/Error; cleanup continues; unit/origin changes rejected; visible safe geometry and source/time context. Uncertain branch omits range projection. |
|
|
| Tests/build/native/docs | Substantial evidence supplied; test gaps remain | Worker reports 133 unit + 91 integration passes, zero failed/skipped, clean full Release build; actual static/dynamic native workflows and final rebuilt-Client recheck; new usage/docs |
|
|
| Protected workflow/history/dependencies | Preserved on inspected evidence | Nine acyclic projects, one Client, independent Components; original assignments/reports and orchestration files retained; no dependency/system change reported |
|
|
|
|
Remaining findings, limited to existing criteria:
|
|
|
|
1. **R-01:** In
|
|
[CreateGaugeValueLocked](../src/AutoForge.Application/Features/Vehicles/Telemetry/LiveDashboard/LiveDashboardAcquisition.cs:581),
|
|
Uncertain values call CreateValue without GetRangeState. CreateValue does not
|
|
derive range from that quality, so -10/1100 over 0..1000 has no low/high label.
|
|
Existing Step-05 C-02/C-03 and Step-05A R-03 require independent quality/range.
|
|
2. **R-02:** The invalid-definition test covers unit/span overflow/count but not
|
|
the full originally required C-04 bounds/precision/kind/ID/source vectors.
|
|
Non-finite geometry tests set Unknown/`--`, so they pass without exercising the
|
|
finite-percent guard. The controlled Stop-drain test releases its barrier and
|
|
session only after assertions, not in finally as the existing gate requires.
|
|
|
|
These are source/test-inspection findings; the orchestrator executed no runtime
|
|
reproduction, application build/test, native launch or workload command.
|
|
The reported 224 cases preserve the prior 207 and add seven unit plus ten
|
|
integration cases. Existing assemblies and case inventory corroborate the report,
|
|
not independent execution or missing matrix assertions.
|
|
|
|
Native evidence now explicitly covers static 850 rpm/85% bar, invalid range/unit,
|
|
editor/hide/remove/stop/restart/reset/close; actual v2 time/config/run context,
|
|
explicit stepping and paused polls not advancing physics; old routes and a
|
|
final-build static/dynamic cycle-1/close recheck. Preserve this positive evidence.
|
|
Do not redo corrected features or add conversion work to Step-05B.
|
|
|
|
## Step-05B acceptance and corrected Step-05
|
|
|
|
Decision: **ACCEPTED**, 2026-10-29. Frozen C-01..C-05 and AC-01..AC-05 are
|
|
satisfied. Step-05 with Step-05A/05B is accepted; no Step-05C is required.
|
|
|
|
Reviewed [Step-05B](Step-05B.md), its [report](Step-05B-Report.md), the focused
|
|
projection diff, actual real-provider/rendered range tests, independent invalid
|
|
definition vectors, isolated finite-percent assertions, finally/async cleanup,
|
|
documentation and existing Release/native artifacts.
|
|
|
|
| Criterion | Decision | Evidence |
|
|
|---|---|---|
|
|
| AC-01 | ACCEPTED | Actual pre-fix Uncertain -10 expected OutOfRangeLow/actual null; shared helper now supplies range without changing quality/value; real numeric/bar low/high and exact-bound assertions |
|
|
| AC-02 | ACCEPTED | Independent invalid bounds/precision/kind/ID/label/source/unit/count vectors assert exact prior snapshot/source/Running state; Good numeric percent-only null/NaN/infinities test and actual 85% width/accessibility control |
|
|
| AC-03 | ACCEPTED | Stop-drain finally releases its barrier before awaiting cleanup; session disposal is protected on failed assertions; other new session tests use async lifetime cleanup |
|
|
| AC-04 | ACCEPTED ON WORKER EXECUTION EVIDENCE | Reported complete nine-project Release build zero warnings/errors; 134 unit + 91 integration passes (225 total, zero failed/skipped); rebuilt native static-v1 bar/dynamics-v2 numeric baseline and close recheck |
|
|
| AC-05 | ACCEPTED | Focused projection/tests/verification-doc change and single corrective report; no future feature/dependency/project/interface/physics/wire expansion; original assignments/history preserved |
|
|
|
|
Worker self-review maps finite-value validation through independent quality/
|
|
range to actual numeric/bar consumers and safe test cleanup. Native observations
|
|
are distinguished from controlled Uncertain/invalid-input proof; no production
|
|
fault selector or fabricated native fault claim was introduced.
|
|
|
|
Source case inventory, unchanged nine-project acyclic references and existing
|
|
Release outputs corroborate the report. The orchestrator ran no application
|
|
builds/tests/native/workload commands and did not execute the reproduction.
|
|
|
|
Original Step-05 findings and its Step-05A follow-up are closed. Preserve the
|
|
207-/224-/225-case reports and original dynamics numerical/native history.
|
|
Step-06 is the sole ready assignment for new display units, with one shared
|
|
preference/conversion contract and explicit editor/raw-data invariants.
|
|
|
|
## Owner decision - imperial-default display units
|
|
|
|
The owner approves a Metric / Imperial toggle with Imperial (US) default while
|
|
keeping all internal calculations in SI. This is a new presentation requirement,
|
|
not a Step-05A defect. It must be implemented before recording/replay.
|
|
|
|
The [dated roadmap contract](ROADMAP.md) inserts the next major Step-06 for
|
|
display units and shifts only former unassigned Steps 06-20 to 07-21.
|
|
Recording/replay is now Step-07, not removed or silently bypassed. Completed
|
|
history and original assignments/reports keep their existing numbering.
|
|
|
|
Intended display defaults: mph for normal vehicle speed (ft/s engineering option),
|
|
ft lengths, lb mass, lb/h fuel mass rate, lbf*ft torque, degF temperature and
|
|
ft/s^2 acceleration. Metric counterparts include km/h or m/s as appropriate.
|
|
RPM/volts/ratios/booleans/counts remain unchanged. Preserve source/SI values in
|
|
physics/config/wire/raw views; use one shared presentation conversion path with
|
|
explicit source versus display units. Convert gauge labels/editor bounds without
|
|
changing canonical physical bounds, quality, range or acquisition/model ownership.
|
|
|
|
First use is Imperial (US); retain an explicitly saved local choice across
|
|
navigation/restarts. Unsupported units remain explicitly unconverted, and no
|
|
fuel mass-to-volume conversion may invent density. Apply consistently across
|
|
current human-facing simulation/diagnostic/dashboard surfaces.
|
|
|
|
No display-unit implementation exists yet. Following Step-05B acceptance,
|
|
[Step-06](Step-06.md) is ready before recording/replay. It freezes the two unit
|
|
systems plus Road/Engineering speed presentation, first-use/saved/error behavior,
|
|
exact conversion vectors and stable source-unit gauge bounds. Open editor
|
|
drafts retain their explicitly captured input unit until saved/cancelled, so a
|
|
toggle cannot reinterpret unsaved numbers.
|
|
|
|
## Prerequisites, limitations, and known issues
|
|
|
|
- Step-01A worker evidence establishes portable and native Windows compatibility
|
|
for the accepted foundation. Recheck prerequisites if the environment changes.
|
|
- No major SDK/workload/driver installation has been authorized. Report exact
|
|
missing prerequisites and mark blocked checks honestly; do not replace .NET 10
|
|
MAUI Blazor Hybrid with a web host.
|
|
- Reported workload incident: `dotnet workload restore` was mistakenly invoked
|
|
during inspection, began manifest updates and was stopped. Worker reports
|
|
workload version 10.0.403 and newer iOS/MacCatalyst manifests; Windows manifest
|
|
stayed 10.0.110. No rollback occurred. Final Windows checks passed, but broader
|
|
impact is unverified. Do not repeat workload-changing commands or repair/rollback
|
|
without explicit authorization; this review does not authorize them.
|
|
- Historical Step-01A raw `git diff --check` failed on README CRLF, against a mixed-line-ending index.
|
|
Read-only byte inspection found 151 CRLF lines and no trailing spaces/tabs.
|
|
A command-local CR-at-EOL-aware check passed, with no Git configuration changed.
|
|
Step-02 resolved working-file normalization: 149 LF and zero CRLF lines observed;
|
|
the CR-at-EOL-aware diff check passes with no global settings changed.
|
|
- Step-02 worker reports no workload-changing command was invoked; prior incident
|
|
remains historical and does not authorize future installation/update/rollback.
|
|
- Profile Step-02 R-01/R-02 remain closed and accepted; do not regress those fixes.
|
|
- Step-03 R-01/R-02/R-03/R-04 remain closed; preserve all correction invariants.
|
|
- Step-04 reference/coupling/progress/failure/UI/owner fixes are accepted with
|
|
Step-04B. Step-05's original and follow-up findings are closed. Preserve the 190-/
|
|
202-/207-case reports and original numerical/native evidence distinctly.
|
|
- Profile metadata/UI, synthetic diagnostics, deterministic dynamics/v2 and the
|
|
corrected dashboard are accepted. Display units, replay, calibration values,
|
|
persistence, AI and physical hardware operations remain unimplemented.
|
|
- No application build or test has been executed by the orchestrator.
|
|
|
|
## Review and progression gate
|
|
|
|
On manual return, evaluate Step-06 and its frozen display-unit contract/shared gate using the
|
|
assignment, worker report, actual code/tests, dependency graph, Git changes,
|
|
README/docs, and recorded build/test evidence. Do not accept solely on a success
|
|
claim; do not claim independent runtime verification.
|
|
|
|
- Inspect shared default/saved preferences, conversion vectors, all assigned UI
|
|
surfaces, canonical bounds/draft invariants, raw/source preservation and real
|
|
provider/native evidence. Do not add deferred recording/layout/unit families.
|
|
- If accepted: accept Step-06, update roadmap/state, prepare Step-07
|
|
recording/replay and stop for manual handoff.
|
|
- If deficient: issue narrowly scoped Step-06A only for a material unmet contract/
|
|
regression, then stop. Planned new features are not corrections.
|
|
- If blocked: retain the active step, document the prerequisite and required
|
|
worker evidence; do not advance or mark unexecuted checks as successful.
|
|
- Never create the next major assignment while acceptance or corrections are open.
|
|
|
|
## History
|
|
|
|
| Date | Event | Evidence / result |
|
|
|---|---|---|
|
|
| 2026-10-28 | Initial repository inspection | Clean `main`; only root README and ignore file tracked; no application or protected instruction files found |
|
|
| 2026-10-28 | Initial roadmap, state, and Step-01 prepared | Amendment layout/naming adopted; READY FOR WORKER, no implementation accepted |
|
|
| 2026-10-28 | User returned Step-01 for review | Original assignment, worker report, code/tests, configuration, Git changes and documentation inspected |
|
|
| 2026-10-28 | Step-01 ACCEPTED | No blocking deficiency; worker evidence reports successful Release build and 54 passed, zero failed/skipped tests; no orchestrator runtime execution |
|
|
| 2026-10-28 | Step-02 prepared | Profile/module model, versioned JSON, synthetic fixtures and application selection; manual worker handoff pending |
|
|
| 2026-10-28 | Owner architecture decision superseded the dual-shell plan | One MAUI Client, UI/Components RCLs, vertical-slice modular monolith; Step-01 acceptance preserved but corrective 01A required |
|
|
| 2026-10-28 | Existing solution re-inspected | Only four headless projects; no obsolete hosts to delete; no application changes/builds/tests executed |
|
|
| 2026-10-28 | Step-01A prepared; Step-02 placed on hold | Correction is ready for manual worker execution; old Step-02 body retained, final regeneration deferred until correction acceptance |
|
|
| 2026-10-28 | Step-01A returned and ACCEPTED | Seven-project single-shell/RCL/VSA implementation inspected; worker reports successful solution/native builds, 65 passing cases and native route/asset checks |
|
|
| 2026-10-28 | Deviations recorded | Unintended workload manifest updates disclosed; no rollback; README CRLF-only diff hygiene noted for next documentation update |
|
|
| 2026-10-28 | Step-02 regenerated | Explicitly supersedes unexecuted pre-correction version; actual seven-project baseline and profile feature/UI scope; READY FOR WORKER |
|
|
| 2026-10-28 | Step-02 returned for review | Profile models/codec/catalog/UI, tests/fixtures/docs and reported 93-case/native verification inspected |
|
|
| 2026-10-28 | Step-02 requires correction | R-01 ambient-dependent timestamp parser and R-02 absent optional applicability constraints; passing reported tests do not cover them |
|
|
| 2026-10-28 | Step-02A prepared | Narrow correction with worker regressions/documentation/native checks; Step-03 blocked and not assigned |
|
|
| 2026-10-28 | Step-02A returned and ACCEPTED | Parser/constraint fixes and direct/DI/UI/native evidence reviewed; 103 unit + 37 integration passes and clean Release build reported |
|
|
| 2026-10-28 | Corrected Step-02 ACCEPTED | R-01/R-02 closed; prior 93-case and corrective 140-case reports preserved; no Step-02B |
|
|
| 2026-10-28 | Step-03 prepared | Explicit simulated sessions, virtual modules, synthetic protocol/read-clear/telemetry/trace and deterministic faults; manual handoff pending |
|
|
| 2026-10-28 | Step-03 returned for review | Nine-project protocol/provider/session/UI path and reported 161-case/native verification inspected |
|
|
| 2026-10-28 | Step-03 requires correction | Missing/ambiguous wire fields, semantic positive replies/false-positive probe trace, and clear acknowledgement treated as verification |
|
|
| 2026-10-28 | Step-03A prepared | Narrow correction with pre-fix regressions, state/trace/UI verification and documentation; Step-04 blocked |
|
|
| 2026-10-28 | Step-03A returned; scoped corrections ACCEPTED | R-01/R-02/R-03 fixed; actual pre-fix failures, clean Release build, 175-case passing run and native baseline inspected |
|
|
| 2026-10-28 | Additional Step-03 finding R-04 | Valid positive probe is discarded from responder count/service evidence when identity is unavailable; not covered by current tests |
|
|
| 2026-10-28 | Step-03B prepared | Preserve phase-specific probe/identity facts and truthful counts without relaxing identity-dependent action gates; Step-04 remains blocked |
|
|
| 2026-10-28 | Step-03B returned and ACCEPTED | R-04 closed; phase/count/guard/trace source and reported 183-case/native evidence inspected |
|
|
| 2026-10-28 | Corrected Step-03 ACCEPTED | All R-01/R-02/R-03/R-04 closed; normal and partial diagnostics, wire integrity and verified clear retained |
|
|
| 2026-10-28 | Step-04 prepared | Fixed-step coupled dynamics, explicit configuration/control and dynamic diagnostic telemetry; manual worker handoff pending |
|
|
| 2026-10-28 | Step-04 returned for review | Model/config/controller/provider/UI and reported 190-case/numerical/native evidence inspected |
|
|
| 2026-10-28 | Step-04 requires correction | Missing-reference handling, drivetrain boundary states and failed/progress/async lifecycle gaps; baseline drive cycle itself reports all numeric gates met |
|
|
| 2026-10-28 | Step-04A prepared | Narrow correctness and controlled-proof correction; Step-05 blocked and not assigned |
|
|
| 2026-10-28 | Step-04A returned for review | Reference/coupling/progress/failure/UI fixes and reported 202-case/native evidence inspected; pending owner-drain transition remains |
|
|
| 2026-10-28 | Owner requested orchestration reassessment | Prospective scope sizing, frozen contract/evidence matrices and worker self-review gate introduced; no retrospective criteria |
|
|
| 2026-10-28 | Step-04B prepared | Single existing reject-before-mutate overlap; no physics/protocol/new feature scope; Step-05 remains blocked |
|
|
| 2026-10-28 | Step-04B returned and ACCEPTED | Frozen C-01..C-05 satisfied; guard ordering, before/after status/state tests, real UI, self-review and reported 207-case/native evidence inspected |
|
|
| 2026-10-28 | Corrected Step-04 ACCEPTED | Original and 04A/04B criteria closed; source and numerical history preserved; no 04C |
|
|
| 2026-10-28 | Step-05 prepared | Bounded numeric/bar dashboard with one acquisition owner, in-memory validated bindings and frozen data/lifecycle matrix; manual handoff pending |
|
|
| 2026-10-29 | Step-05 returned and reviewed | Partial Application feed and generic gauge/diagnostic wiring; same 207 baseline passes/clean Release build reported; required native smoke not executed |
|
|
| 2026-10-29 | Step-05 requires correction | Consolidated R-01..R-05: host/editor/startup, session owner/lifetime, fault/data truth, generic rendering, missing tests/docs/native evidence; no new acceptance criteria |
|
|
| 2026-10-29 | Step-05A prepared | Complete original frozen contract and worker self-review before manual return; Step-04 remains accepted and Step-06 blocked |
|
|
| 2026-10-29 | Step-05A returned and reviewed | Real shared editor/panel/session owner, safe gauges, 17 new cases/docs and worker-reported 224-case/clean Release/native evidence inspected |
|
|
| 2026-10-29 | Focused Step-05B required | Existing Uncertain low/high independence and decisive boundary-test/finally-cleanup obligations remain; no new product scope |
|
|
| 2026-10-29 | Owner approved imperial-default display units | SI calculations unchanged; global metric/Imperial (US) preference and conversions must precede recording/replay; not a Step-05A acceptance change |
|
|
| 2026-10-29 | Future numbering updated | Display units inserted as unassigned Step-06; former unassigned 06-20 become 07-21; completed assignments/history preserved |
|
|
| 2026-10-29 | Step-05B prepared | Narrow range/test correction only; next major handoff is units after dashboard acceptance, not recording/replay |
|
|
| 2026-10-29 | Step-05B returned and ACCEPTED | Frozen range/test/cleanup matrix satisfied; actual red regression, 225-case/clean Release/native recheck evidence and source-path self-review inspected |
|
|
| 2026-10-29 | Corrected Step-05 ACCEPTED | Original and 05A/05B criteria closed; no 05C; reports/source/numerical history preserved |
|
|
| 2026-10-29 | Step-06 prepared | Imperial-default shared presentation preference/conversions, stable canonical source bounds and explicit editor/raw-data policy; manual handoff pending, Step-07 blocked |
|
|
|
|
## Manual handoff instruction
|
|
|
|
Provide [Step-06.md](Step-06.md) and the shared
|
|
[worker gate](WORKER-QUALITY-GATE.md) to the separate worker and request execution
|
|
of that assignment only. The worker must produce `prompts/Step-06-Report.md`
|
|
and stop for review. Do not begin Step-07 recording/replay.
|
|
Return manually to the orchestrator for review. Reports, including final chat
|
|
reports, must follow the single plain triple-backtick copy-window requirement.
|