204 lines
13 KiB
Markdown
204 lines
13 KiB
Markdown
```
|
|
STEP 3 REPORT — Instrument-neutral composition and deterministic text planning
|
|
Date: 2026-10-19
|
|
Step 3 readiness: TRUE — implemented and verified; ready for orchestrator review.
|
|
Ready to satisfy Step 4 production exit criteria: FALSE — real mapping evidence
|
|
is still absent. Acceptance of Step 3 does not close that evidence gate.
|
|
|
|
IMPLEMENTED
|
|
- Wrote docs\text-description-contract.md before implementing the parser.
|
|
It explicitly defines the bounded English grammar, supported paraphrases,
|
|
defaults, role/subset semantics, timing convention, numeric/resource limits
|
|
and unsupported instructions. README now describes the in-process API and
|
|
distinguishes composition planning from public MCP generation.
|
|
- Added dependency-free Core composition models: global BPM, typed meter/key/
|
|
mode, bars, role tracks, absolute pitched notes, logical drum hits, typed
|
|
articulation intentions, immutable collection snapshots and applied defaults.
|
|
No production profile IDs, playable ranges, channels, vendor switch values
|
|
or guessed SD3 MIDI pitches were introduced.
|
|
- Added normalized immutable signed-Int64 BeatFraction quarter-note timing.
|
|
Default zero is 0/1; denominators must be positive. Arithmetic/comparison
|
|
uses checked Int128 intermediates and checked normalized Int64 results.
|
|
Conversion to 960 PPQ ticks is exact or fails; no floating-point beat drift.
|
|
- Added explicit settings/model validation: positive finite SMF-representable
|
|
tempo, meter fields and denominator-beat representability, positive bars,
|
|
normalized key/mode, distinct selected roles, nonempty tracks, correct event
|
|
kinds, pitch 0..127, sounding velocity 1..127, typed articulation/drum voice,
|
|
nonnegative starts, positive durations, exact timing and full event extent.
|
|
Declared extent remains all bars even with trailing rests.
|
|
- Added parser/planning failure results with stable codes, fields, actionable
|
|
messages and offending text where applicable. Failures expose no partial
|
|
usable description/composition. Meaningful unconsumed text is rejected.
|
|
Expected arithmetic/representability catches are confined to timing/count
|
|
preflight and validation, not arbitrary exceptions or fallback-to-defaults.
|
|
- Added deterministic root quarter/eighth/sixteenth and full-bar sustained
|
|
pitched patterns, explicit kick/snare denominator-beat placement and closed
|
|
hi-hat subdivisions. Track ordering and simultaneous hit ordering are stable.
|
|
All pattern counts and extent are checked before expanding event lists.
|
|
- IntegrationTests now directly references Core. Its existing apphost-copy
|
|
target explicitly queries only Server, preventing the added reference from
|
|
contaminating server-output discovery. Refreshed its generated lock file.
|
|
No new package or package-version change was necessary.
|
|
- Retained all previous protocol/scaffold/process tests. No Server production
|
|
source changed: its real MCP registry remains empty. Full retained real-
|
|
process tests verify that behavior alongside the new in-process pipeline.
|
|
|
|
GRAMMAR, DEFAULTS AND LIMIT DECISIONS
|
|
- Accepted settings: unsigned ASCII integer BPM; positive Int32 bars (also
|
|
one through sixteen in words); numerator/denominator meter; A..G roots with
|
|
optional #/b/Unicode sharp/flat and major/minor mode.
|
|
- Role aliases: lead guitar/lead/guitar, bass, drums. Supported pitched
|
|
modifiers are sustain/palm-muted/palm mute, root-note subdivisions and
|
|
sustained roots. Hyphen/space variants, case, whitespace and ordinary
|
|
clause punctuation are documented. Modifiers bind to their own role.
|
|
- Repeated identical clauses/settings deduplicate; conflicting duplicates,
|
|
duplicate beat positions, malformed numbers, unsupported articulations,
|
|
genres, chords, tuning, arbitrary melody/dynamics and unknown words fail.
|
|
- Defaults: 120 BPM, four bars, 4/4, E minor; lead root octave 4 (C4=60),
|
|
bass root octave 2 (C2=36), velocity 96 and sustain articulation.
|
|
Enharmonics normalize before selecting the octave: E gives lead 64/bass 40,
|
|
B# gives C4/C2, Cb gives B4/B2. These are musical choices, not mappings.
|
|
- If no role or drum part is mentioned, select all three. Otherwise select
|
|
only explicit roles. Lead defaults to root eighth notes; bass defaults to
|
|
one full-bar root note per bar.
|
|
- Bare drums in 4/4 defaults to kick 1/3, snare 2/4, eighth-note closed hi-hat.
|
|
Any explicit drum part selects only supplied parts, including with a bare
|
|
drums clause; no omitted drum part is silently added. Non-4/4 drums require
|
|
explicit parts. Every applied default has a field and value; defaults for
|
|
unselected roles/omitted subset parts are not applied.
|
|
- Meter numerator: 1..255. Denominator: power of two, 1..256, so the human
|
|
denominator-note beat is exactly representable at 960 PPQ. In 3/8, beat 2
|
|
is 480 ticks after the bar start, not 960. Bar length is numerator*4/
|
|
denominator quarter notes. Subdivisions must divide the whole bar exactly.
|
|
- SMF tempo requires 60,000,000/BPM in 1..16,777,215 microseconds per quarter;
|
|
nearest-integer rounding, midpoint away from zero, is documented for future
|
|
encoding. Requested BPM remains unchanged in the composition.
|
|
- Fixed internal limit: 100,000 generated notes plus logical hits combined.
|
|
Exactly 100,000 passes; 100,001 fails with event_limit_exceeded before
|
|
pattern expansion. No public override or truncation. Description text is
|
|
bounded to 16,384 UTF-16 characters. Checked counts use Int64.
|
|
|
|
ACCEPTANCE EXAMPLE AND TEST EVIDENCE
|
|
- The exact plan description produces all three tracks, four bars at 120 BPM
|
|
in E minor, 4/4, zero planning lead-in, extent 16 quarter notes/15,360 ticks.
|
|
- Lead: 32 E4/MIDI-64 palm-mute notes, starts every 480 ticks, duration 480.
|
|
Bass: four E2/MIDI-40 sustain notes, starts every 3,840 ticks, duration 3,840.
|
|
Kick: eight hits on beats 1/3; snare: eight on beats 2/4; closed hi-hat:
|
|
32 eighth-note hits. All bar starts and durations are checked exactly.
|
|
- Tests cover normalization, arithmetic/comparison, exact and fractional ticks,
|
|
invalid denominators, wide intermediates and checked overflow; complete
|
|
acceptance values/defaults; paraphrases; enharmonic normalization; role-local
|
|
modifiers; explicit-only roles/drum subsets; defaults and repeated settings;
|
|
rejection of malformed/meaningful leftover instructions; numeric ranges,
|
|
event-kind/role validation, complete extents and trailing rests.
|
|
- Long repeated pitched and hi-hat patterns verify absence of drift. Non-4/4
|
|
tests verify denominator beats and reject inappropriate default/subdivision
|
|
assumptions. Exact event boundaries cover pitched, drums and combined roles;
|
|
the combined 100,001 case and Int32.MaxValue bar requests reject pre-expansion.
|
|
- Repeated calls and reused parsed descriptions are structurally identical.
|
|
Collections are read-only snapshots; source-list mutations and attempts to
|
|
mutate results cannot affect another result.
|
|
- Ten new integration cases exercise real Core parser -> planner -> validator
|
|
in-process, including the complete example, role subsets, 3/8 and failures.
|
|
These are not final public MCP generation/file-writing integration claims.
|
|
|
|
CHANGED FILES (22 deliverables, including this report)
|
|
README.md
|
|
docs\text-description-contract.md
|
|
src\GAJ3T.MusicGen.RiffGrooveBuilder.Core\Composition\BeatFraction.cs
|
|
src\GAJ3T.MusicGen.RiffGrooveBuilder.Core\Composition\Composition.cs
|
|
src\GAJ3T.MusicGen.RiffGrooveBuilder.Core\Composition\TrackPlan.cs
|
|
src\GAJ3T.MusicGen.RiffGrooveBuilder.Core\Composition\MusicalNote.cs
|
|
src\GAJ3T.MusicGen.RiffGrooveBuilder.Core\Composition\DrumHit.cs
|
|
src\GAJ3T.MusicGen.RiffGrooveBuilder.Core\Composition\MusicalTypes.cs
|
|
src\GAJ3T.MusicGen.RiffGrooveBuilder.Core\Composition\ParsedDescription.cs
|
|
src\GAJ3T.MusicGen.RiffGrooveBuilder.Core\Composition\CompositionDiagnostic.cs
|
|
src\GAJ3T.MusicGen.RiffGrooveBuilder.Core\Composition\CompositionPlanningResult.cs
|
|
src\GAJ3T.MusicGen.RiffGrooveBuilder.Core\Composition\CompositionValidator.cs
|
|
src\GAJ3T.MusicGen.RiffGrooveBuilder.Core\Composition\DescriptionParser.cs
|
|
src\GAJ3T.MusicGen.RiffGrooveBuilder.Core\Composition\CompositionPlanner.cs
|
|
tests\GAJ3T.MusicGen.RiffGrooveBuilder.UnitTests\Composition\BeatFractionTests.cs
|
|
tests\GAJ3T.MusicGen.RiffGrooveBuilder.UnitTests\Composition\CompositionValidatorTests.cs
|
|
tests\GAJ3T.MusicGen.RiffGrooveBuilder.UnitTests\Composition\DescriptionParserTests.cs
|
|
tests\GAJ3T.MusicGen.RiffGrooveBuilder.UnitTests\Composition\CompositionPlannerTests.cs
|
|
tests\GAJ3T.MusicGen.RiffGrooveBuilder.IntegrationTests\Composition\CompositionPipelineTests.cs
|
|
tests\GAJ3T.MusicGen.RiffGrooveBuilder.IntegrationTests\GAJ3T.MusicGen.RiffGrooveBuilder.IntegrationTests.csproj
|
|
tests\GAJ3T.MusicGen.RiffGrooveBuilder.IntegrationTests\packages.lock.json
|
|
prompts\report_3.md
|
|
|
|
EXACT VALIDATION COMMANDS AND RESULTS
|
|
All dotnet commands ran from the repository root with process-local settings:
|
|
$env:PATH = 'C:\Program Files\dotnet;' + $env:PATH
|
|
$env:DOTNET_CLI_TELEMETRY_OPTOUT = '1'
|
|
$env:DOTNET_NOLOGO = '1'
|
|
This uses the installed C:\Program Files\dotnet\dotnet.exe without machine
|
|
configuration changes.
|
|
|
|
1. dotnet restore .\GAJ3T.MusicGen.RiffGrooveBuilder.slnx
|
|
PASS, exit 0. All five projects restored after the project-reference edit.
|
|
Only IntegrationTests' generated lock needed the direct Core project entry.
|
|
|
|
2. dotnet test .\GAJ3T.MusicGen.RiffGrooveBuilder.slnx -c Release --no-restore --filter FullyQualifiedName~Composition
|
|
Development run 1: exit 1.
|
|
UnitTests: 176 passed / 1 failed / 0 skipped.
|
|
IntegrationTests: 9 passed / 1 failed / 0 skipped.
|
|
Both failures were incorrect new assertions: the 3/8 two-bar example has
|
|
12 hits (4 kick + 2 snare + 6 hi-hat), not 10; fractional numbered-beat
|
|
text correctly returned invalid_number rather than unsupported_text.
|
|
Corrected the assertions without permitting fractional beats or dropping
|
|
any musical events.
|
|
Development run 2: PASS, exit 0.
|
|
UnitTests: 177 passed / 0 failed / 0 skipped.
|
|
IntegrationTests: 10 passed / 0 failed / 0 skipped.
|
|
Added the combined-role 100,001-event regression before final validation.
|
|
|
|
FINAL REQUIRED ACCEPTANCE COMMANDS
|
|
3. dotnet build .\GAJ3T.MusicGen.RiffGrooveBuilder.slnx -c Release --no-restore
|
|
PASS, exit 0. All five projects built. 0 warnings, 0 errors.
|
|
|
|
4. dotnet test .\GAJ3T.MusicGen.RiffGrooveBuilder.slnx -c Release --no-build
|
|
PASS, exit 0. Both test assemblies discovered and executed:
|
|
UnitTests: 294 passed, 0 failed, 0 skipped (708 ms).
|
|
178 new composition cases + all 116 retained baseline cases.
|
|
IntegrationTests: 24 passed, 0 failed, 0 skipped (977 ms).
|
|
10 new Core pipeline cases + all 14 retained real-process cases.
|
|
TOTAL: 318 passed, 0 failed, 0 skipped.
|
|
188 new cases + all 130 prior cases.
|
|
|
|
5. dotnet restore .\GAJ3T.MusicGen.RiffGrooveBuilder.slnx --locked-mode
|
|
PASS, exit 0. All five projects restored using generated locks.
|
|
|
|
ADDITIONAL CHECKS
|
|
- Editor runTests over the five new test files reported "No tests found".
|
|
Used the already-approved CLI fallback; no empty editor discovery was
|
|
misreported as a passing test run.
|
|
- Final editor problems check over src/tests: no errors found.
|
|
- git --no-pager diff --check: PASS, exit 0.
|
|
- In-memory PowerShell trailing-whitespace audit: PASS, exit 0; all 21
|
|
Step 3 deliverables preceding this report checked, excluding bin/obj.
|
|
- Core project XML audit: PASS, exit 0; no package or project references.
|
|
- SHA256 preservation audit: PASS, exit 0; plan.md, step_1.md, step_2.md,
|
|
step_3.md, report_1.md and report_2.md unchanged from worker entry.
|
|
The pre-existing modified plan was preserved, not reset or edited.
|
|
|
|
ISSUES, UNRUN CHECKS AND READINESS
|
|
- The two development assertion issues are resolved. No unresolved Step 3
|
|
implementation/test blocker remains. Step 3 is ready for review, not an
|
|
authorization to proceed beyond its scope.
|
|
- No native/plugin/Cubase imports, MIDI/native output checks, self-contained
|
|
publication or public generation-tool integration were run: those require
|
|
later steps and/or unavailable authorized production evidence.
|
|
- Step 4 evidence remains ABSENT: exact installed product versions/settings,
|
|
verified Eclips/Ray playable/articulation/keyswitch/CC/velocity/timing/state/
|
|
channel rules, and the actual SD3 library/drum map have not been supplied.
|
|
Native schemas, confirmed AGP/SDP semantics, lawful fixtures/template rights
|
|
and successful target-application import evidence also remain unverified.
|
|
Musical pitch defaults/logical drum voices do not establish any of these.
|
|
Step 4 production mapping exit criteria cannot be declared ready; obtain
|
|
evidence/owner direction rather than fabricate profiles or mappings.
|
|
- Core remains independent of DryWetMIDI. Production MCP tools remain empty.
|
|
No new packages, future-step implementation, orchestrator prompt/plan edits,
|
|
commits, delegation or scratch artifacts were introduced.
|
|
- Stopping after this report.
|
|
```
|