176 lines
8.2 KiB
Markdown
176 lines
8.2 KiB
Markdown
```
|
|
Step 15 — BLOCKED: canonical native requirement is physically incompatible
|
|
Date: 2026-10-20
|
|
|
|
OUTCOME / STEP16 READINESS
|
|
NOT READY for Step16. Stopped at a demonstrated blocker, as instructed.
|
|
No Step15 public hybrid parser is shipped. Provisional implementation and its
|
|
tests were removed after the canonical native acceptance gate failed.
|
|
Accepted Step14 source/tests/docs remain in place. This is not a completion
|
|
report, not an approval to advance, and not a claim that lane descriptions
|
|
work in the restored source or installed package.
|
|
|
|
BLOCKER
|
|
The mandatory canonical example requires two simultaneous D2 major attacks:
|
|
MIDI pitches [38,42,45], at MIDI960 ticks960 and1440, each480 ticks.
|
|
|
|
The selected/default lead profile is ample.ame.4.0.1.riffer.v1.
|
|
Its accepted native tuning, strings6..1, is:
|
|
MIDI [36,43,48,53,57,62], maximum22 frets on every string.
|
|
|
|
Exhaustive legal positions for the D2-major pitches:
|
|
MIDI38 -> string6/fret2 ONLY.
|
|
MIDI42 -> string6/fret6 ONLY.
|
|
MIDI45 -> string6/fret9 OR string5/fret2.
|
|
|
|
MIDI38 and MIDI42 must sound together but require two different frets on the
|
|
same string at the same instant. No legal simultaneous assignment exists.
|
|
This is a physical contradiction, not a whitespace, octave-convention,
|
|
tokenizer, key-resolution, MIDI-grid or backtracking bug.
|
|
|
|
Evidence sources in the preserved code:
|
|
src\riff_groove_builder\data\profiles\
|
|
ample-metal-eclipse-4.0.1-riffer-v1.json:108-114
|
|
src\riff_groove_builder\formats\agp.py:206-244
|
|
_assign searches legal positions and rejects occupied-string overlaps.
|
|
The independent native reader also checks string/fret/pitch and
|
|
nonoverlapping notes on each string.
|
|
|
|
Both the provisional public-description path and, separately, the restored
|
|
Step14 ExplicitAttackPlan -> compose_score -> compile_score -> preflight_riffer
|
|
path reproduce no_physical_string_assignment with all21 pitches preserved.
|
|
No duplicate voicing engine or whole-example canned branch was used.
|
|
|
|
Changing the tuning/default profile, moving D2 to another octave, dropping
|
|
F#2, splitting a simultaneous chord into retriggers, emitting overlapping
|
|
impossible string notes, or accepting MIDI-only output would violate at least
|
|
one mandatory acceptance condition. None was used to claim native success.
|
|
|
|
ACTUAL PUBLIC SOURCE STDIO OBSERVATION DURING THE PROTOTYPE
|
|
The exact canonical description was sent to a real subprocess.
|
|
Text JSON and structuredContent were identical for both calls:
|
|
|
|
allow_midi_fallback=false:
|
|
isError=true
|
|
code=NATIVE_FORMAT_UNAVAILABLE
|
|
details={part:lead, format:griff, reason:no_physical_string_assignment}
|
|
No destination/artifacts published.
|
|
|
|
allow_midi_fallback=true:
|
|
status=midi_fallback
|
|
Exactly one .mid, explicit native-unavailability warning, no .griff.
|
|
Independently parsed MIDI contains all21 required musical note-ons.
|
|
Zero control_change messages; no bar2 musical retrigger.
|
|
|
|
The second result is evidence of the blocker, NOT a passing native result.
|
|
The prototype result included rational interpretation, exact resolved pitches,
|
|
technique and held status. That result surface was removed with the prototype;
|
|
it is not advertised as available in the restored product.
|
|
|
|
INDEPENDENT CANONICAL MIDI READ-BACK
|
|
MIDI960 start/end, pitches, technique:
|
|
0 / 480 [42,46,49] PM
|
|
480 / 960 [42,46,49] PM
|
|
960 / 1440 [38,42,45] PM <-- impossible native simultaneous fingering
|
|
1440 / 1920 [38,42,45] PM <-- same conflict
|
|
1920 / 2400 [46,50,53] PM
|
|
2400 / 2880 [46,50,53] PM
|
|
2880 / 3200 [60] PM
|
|
3200 / 3520 [64] PM
|
|
3520 / 7680 [67] PH, one continuous hold
|
|
|
|
Nine attacks expand to21 independent musical tones.
|
|
Selector-ons: (0,26), (3520,31); selector velocity100 and30-tick gate.
|
|
46 scheduled note events including musical tones and selectors.
|
|
Final G4 start=11/3, duration=13/3 quarter-note beats.
|
|
No retuning into E minor, omitted chord tone, hidden retrigger or controller.
|
|
|
|
After restoring Step14, reconstructed the exact same explicit plan through
|
|
the accepted APIs, repeated native preflight failure, and wrote MIDI bytes
|
|
identical to the provisional real-stdio fallback:
|
|
SHA256:
|
|
4ce995ca751590b32cd85c72c3a2d8dad7f478cdf34d3abb12616d121719c3b4
|
|
|
|
There is deliberately NO canonical native event read-back to present.
|
|
There is deliberately NO claim of installed-wheel hybrid parsing acceptance.
|
|
|
|
GRAMMAR / INTERPRETATION STATUS
|
|
The disposable parser used case-insensitive labeled rows, exact Fraction
|
|
counts and bracketed triplets; deterministic Step14 pitch-tokenization and
|
|
selected-profile resolution; o/x/^ attacks, rest/tie processing, explicit
|
|
slash/Over/bracket voicings and cross-bar holds. Spacing was lexical only.
|
|
Its76 unit cases passed, including canonical/compact nearby-pitch variants,
|
|
eighth/sixteenth/triplet counts, bare1&a ambiguity, rests, ties, voicing
|
|
conflicts, selected-profile limits, slide rejection and bounded style context.
|
|
The first real source canonical native gate then failed as detailed above.
|
|
Installed hybrid gates were not completed. The implementation was not kept
|
|
as an incomplete new public contract, and those provisional tests are absent
|
|
from the final passing suite.
|
|
|
|
Final supported grammar remains the accepted documented0.1.1 prose/template,
|
|
original beat-range/triplet-hold phrase, and internal Step14 pitch/plan APIs.
|
|
Counts/Events/Chords/Notes lanes, new Grid directives and a new interpretation
|
|
surface are NOT newly supported in this blocked result. No documentation or
|
|
tool guidance was changed to imply otherwise.
|
|
|
|
PRESERVED ORIGINAL E2 MUSIC — SOURCE AND INSTALLED WHEEL
|
|
The full accepted suite reran real source and offline built/installed-wheel
|
|
stdio tests. Both independently read nine MIDI40 musical notes and nine native
|
|
notes, matching the original phrase:
|
|
onsets: 0,480,960,1440,1920,2400,2880,3200,3520
|
|
ends: 480,960,1440,1920,2400,2880,3200,3520,7680
|
|
velocities:80,80,64,80,96,80,80,80,80
|
|
PM26 at0; PH31 at3520; no bar2 retrigger; native PM/PH at half MIDI times.
|
|
|
|
Source and installed-wheel original-byte hashes still match:
|
|
.mid:
|
|
c1967e698a50b8c22a22e458c3e2dd02d04407d1ad1d61f8a462d790b0810e62
|
|
.griff:
|
|
e8195e74c60ac93b1a4c92967a0834a64b2a2ebd74f453d6d3640ea465c4104c
|
|
|
|
FINAL VALIDATION AFTER REMOVING THE PROTOTYPE
|
|
All commands used .\.venv\Scripts\python.exe:
|
|
-m pytest -q --tb=short:
|
|
PASS,1661 tests,64.71s; full unit/integration/package suite.
|
|
Includes offline sdist/wheel build, isolated wheel installation, real
|
|
source/installed stdio, pitch/native/CC/privacy/atomic and old phrase tests.
|
|
-m ruff check .:
|
|
PASS, all checks passed.
|
|
-m ruff format --check .:
|
|
PASS,101 files already formatted.
|
|
-m mypy --strict src tests:
|
|
PASS, no issues in54 source files.
|
|
-m pip check:
|
|
PASS, no broken requirements.
|
|
git diff --check:
|
|
PASS.
|
|
Earlier targeted preserved description/phrase/explicit-plan run:
|
|
PASS,186 tests.
|
|
|
|
PRESERVATION / PERSISTENT EVIDENCE
|
|
Final git status matches the initial accepted dirty state, plus this report.
|
|
No version/dependency/release metadata, profile tuning, native/CC compiler,
|
|
public tools, application configuration or existing source behavior changed.
|
|
No commits, delegation, later prompts, user-app manipulations or new dependency
|
|
installation. Prototype files and project-local validation scratch removed.
|
|
The Step14 preservation manifest still has exactly82/85 unchanged baseline
|
|
files, with ONLY its already accepted changes:
|
|
docs\architecture.md
|
|
src\riff_groove_builder\compose.py
|
|
src\riff_groove_builder\schemas.py
|
|
|
|
Retained reproducible numeric/error/transport evidence and actual MIDI:
|
|
.test-artifacts\step15\blocker-source\evidence.json
|
|
.test-artifacts\step15\blocker-source\
|
|
canonical-midi-fallback\canonical-midi-fallback.mid
|
|
.test-artifacts\step15\accepted-foundation\canonical.mid
|
|
.test-artifacts\step15\preserved-original-evidence.json
|
|
|
|
REQUIRED RESOLUTION BEFORE STEP15 CAN BE ACCEPTED
|
|
An authorized requirement decision is needed: permit an explicitly chosen,
|
|
evidence-backed alternate tuning/profile that can voice both low tones;
|
|
change the canonical D2 voicing/register; or permit declared MIDI fallback
|
|
for this physically impossible native chord. None can be chosen silently.
|
|
Step16 remains NOT READY. Stopped here with the blocker demonstrated.
|
|
```
|